Trump administration throws cold water on climate change threat to coral reefs

coral reef
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

When pollsters informed President Donald Trump that he faces political exposure in the 2020 election with swing voters on environment policy, he decided to respond with a White House address claiming stewardship of clean water, air and oceans.

But as some Trump aides were drafting that speech, others were casting doubt on the significance of a climate threat to a key battleground state: the degradation of coral reefs in Florida.

Weeks before, a senior intelligence analyst at the State Department had submitted a draft of planned testimony to Congress detailing the national security implications of climate change for White House review.

Among the edits that the analyst, Rod Schoonover, received back from the White House was a novel argument. National Security Council officials issued a challenge to the scientific consensus that warming oceans pose an intensifying mortal threat to , home to a quarter of all marine life and a vital resource in the global food market.

In the past decade, 90-95% of coral on the Florida Reef have died or incurred severe damage, according to scientists with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, which estimates the sustains roughly 70,000 jobs in South Florida and generates over $4.4 billion in annual sales.

"There is no evidence that is intensifying now or will in the future," reads the comment, attributed to the NSC. Two sources said it was written by William Happer, a prominent skeptic of climate change. "Coral reefs have bleached and usually recovered throughout their evolutionary history."

That position has spooked government experts who have worked in marine biology for decades, and who in recent years sounded alarm bells over the consequences of mass die-offs along U.S. shorelines and beyond.

Scientists say bleaching occurs when coral expel algae in response to an increase in sea temperatures. The algae give coral their color, and without it, they are left bone white. But algae also provide coral with their primary source of food and sustenance.

The more frequently bleaching events occur, the less time damaged coral have to recover from the last event—and the more likely they are to die from starvation or disease.

Corals in Florida were hit by severe bleaching in both 2014 and 2015—the warmest years on record—and in 2015, Hawaii saw the worst bleaching and coral mortality ever recorded. Guam and American Samoa have also experienced repeat bleaching events over the past six years, according to Mark Eakin, coordinator of the NOAA Coral Reef Watch.

Eakin questioned the scientific basis of the NSC commentary.

"Clearly this is someone who either is not aware of the scientific literature that overwhelmingly shows that coral bleaching has increased—and most certainly will continue to increase as the climate warms—or they're ignoring that literature," Eakin said. "Normally, documents of this sort require vetting by experts within the administration, and those experts usually include people who are knowledgeable in the subject. We don't know what was done in this case."

Schoonover's leaked testimony, Eakin continued, "appears accurate and consistent with a large amount of public literature, including the last four reports from an intergovernmental panel on climate change. And it is consistent with what we have analyzed at NOAA and with what we have published on coral bleaching multiple times."

The wide scope of climate-related threats facing Florida has convinced some of its leading Republican lawmakers to acknowledge humanity's role in the crisis. The state's two GOP senators, Marco Rubio and Rick Scott, joined Hawaii's Democratic Sens. Brian Schatz and Mazie Hirono last week in sponsoring the Restoring Resilient Reefs Act of 2019, a bill that would restore federal assistance for coral protection and emphasizes their economic and ecological significance.

That bill attributes the challenges facing coral reefs to "human-accelerated changes, including increasing ocean temperatures, ocean acidification, coral bleaching, coral diseases, and invasive species."

White House officials would not confirm the authenticity of the Schoonover document, first obtained by the Washington Post. Schoonover—who resigned from the State Department over the NSC edits—later ruffled feathers in the administration by publishing an op-ed in the New York Times accusing the White House of politicizing climate science.

"We don't comment on deliberative matters, where this appears to be a clear example—someone in the U.S. bureaucracy believing their way is the only way, and trying to undermine the president by leaking internal deliberative information," a senior administration official told McClatchy.

But the degradation of coral reefs "is a problem," the official continued. "We're serious about it."

"We understand that and their ecosystems offer benefits to humankind, as sources of food, livelihood, recreation and shoreline protection," said the official, who was not authorized to speak on the record. "Reefs are facing multiple threats including pollution, unsustainable destructive fishing practices, coastal development, and global threats such as ocean acidification and coral bleaching."

The official pointed to language in the International Coral Reef Initiative's "call to action" in 1995, which claims that "reasons for the decline in reef health are varied, complex, and often difficult to accurately determine."

Since the mid-1990s, reef systems around the globe have faced increasingly frequent mass bleaching events.

While the Florida and Caribbean reefs have been especially damaged, Australia's Great Barrier Reef—the most publicly recognizable system in the world—has suffered from mass bleaching events in 2016 and 2017, leaving over a third of its coral stark white.

"There's denialism, and then there's really fringe," said one climate expert who has worked on interagency government review efforts.

"Coral bleaching has not typically fallen within denialist rhetoric," the expert continued. "Most people would not see this as a climate issue, and wouldn't feel the need to deny it—you could believe in warmer oceans without believing in climate change. But this goes well beyond that. This says all marine biology is off."


Explore further

Rapid coral death and decay, not just bleaching, as marine heatwaves intensify

©2019 McClatchy Washington Bureau
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Citation: Trump administration throws cold water on climate change threat to coral reefs (2019, August 9) retrieved 21 September 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2019-08-trump-administration-cold-climate-threat.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
152 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Aug 11, 2019
National Security Council officials issued a challenge to the scientific consensus that warming oceans pose an intensifying mortal threat to coral reef systems,
In other words, purely for political reasons, some science-ignorant politicians ignore what all the science and the scientists say and arrogantly claim they know better about a science than the scientists doing active research into it and say the scientists, you know, the people that actually know what they are talking about when they talk about the issue as opposed to some science-ignorant politicians who have done no research into it, not only got it all wrong but the exact opposite of whatever they (the scientists) say is the truth. Does that just about sum it up?
Who should we trust more by default on a science topic? The scientists who are expert on the topic? Or the word of some science-ignorant laypeople and politicians?

Aug 11, 2019
Cyanide fishing and Coral polyps expelling their zooxanthellae!

Cyanide slows photosynthesis in zooxanthellae
Many fishing and diving areas across the whole of South East Asia
Already severely damaged from the impact of dynamite fishing
Have been ruined or totally lost through cyanide fishing
Cyanide concentration slows photosynthesis in zooxanthellae
Results in coral reefs losing colour
Eliminating one of their major food sources
Even at very low doses
Cyanide results in higher mortality levels among corals
https://en.wikipe..._fishing

p.s. unfortunately folks, not to be a bearer of bad news but coral polyps require zooxanthellae, climate change or no climate change, it is the use of Cyanide-fishing that is eliminating zooxanthellae that is starving, diminishing and consequently bleaching coral polyps, foreth President Trump cannot be blamed for looking at the actual cause's for coral polyps expelling their zooxanthellae!

Aug 11, 2019
granville583762

OBVIOUSLY, No one doubts that cyanide use in fishing, along with many other causes, ALSO harms coral (not to mention other wildlife).
This isn't an argument against global warming ALSO harming coral as those two things are not mutually exclusive. Where is the logical contradiction in BOTH causing harm to coral?
Thus If Trump does nothing to reduce man made global warming and instead just makes matters worse then he will be partly to blame for some of the future harm to coral.

Aug 11, 2019
"We don't comment on deliberative matters, where this appears to be a clear example—someone in the U.S. bureaucracy believing their way is the only way, and trying to undermine the president by leaking internal deliberative information," a senior administration official told McClatchy.
It can hardly be characterized as a deliberative process when the administration refuses to release the information to the public which it serves...

This current administration hates science...

Aug 11, 2019
Climatic ejection by coral polyps of zooxanthellae

Humy: Why do coral polyps eject zooxanthellae?
humy> This isn't an argument against global warming ALSO harming coral as those two things are not mutually exclusive. Where is the logical contradiction in BOTH causing harm to coral

When their very survival relies on zooxanthellae
Foreth
If it is temperature dependant
This can be ascertained in coral polyps
Kept
In
Temperature controlled tanks

Aug 11, 2019
Or the word of some science-ignorant laypeople and politicians?


It is even worse, note how (an anonymous) climate expert refers to it as fringe. Happer is a retired physicist who - for reasons of his own - is adamant that human made global warming does not exist despite the overwhelming evidence from experts. The politicians who hired him as 'expert' are perverse.

Speaking of which, this week the national press hereabouts switched from noting how the current US administration harm the global economy and the global climate to how it may manage to combine both. A non-governmental group analysis show that the projected harm from the US war on economy puts the world on a +3 degC trajectory. (We have already made +1.1 degC from a pre-industrial baseline IIRC, and hope to stay below + 2 degC since it is increasingly deadly, costly and risky to go over that.) Likely highly arguable, but notable!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more