Protestantism still matters when it comes to education, study shows

September 25, 2018 by Andy Dunne, University of Bath
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

An 'enduring historical legacy' of Protestant religion is still having a significant, positive impact on secondary school enrolment rates around the world, according to the results of a new international study from a researcher at the University of Bath (UK).

Despite nearly two centuries of secularization and a dramatic expansion of government-provided secondary since the mid-20th century in many countries around the world, the research by Dr. Horst Feldmann—just published in the journal Comparative Sociology —finds that in countries with a historical legacy of Protestantism more young people are attending secondary school.

Looking at data from 147 countries—both from developed and developing countries—the paper studies the influence of historical as well as contemporary Protestantism on education in recent years—specifically the period from 1975 to 2010.

At the start of the Reformation in 1517, initiated by Martin Luther, Protestantism made strenuous efforts to expand schooling. Luther demanded compulsory elementary education for boys and girls from all social classes. Other German Protestants soon developed a comprehensive system of schooling, including a system of secondary education. The German reforms quickly became a blueprint for education across many other countries in western and northern Europe.

Britain exported Protestantism to its colonies around the globe, which profoundly shaped their educational systems as well. Here too, Protestants introduced mass education, including formal education for women as well as for marginalized groups, including slaves. The Protestant missionaries in the British colonies were also the first to provide post-primary education. As a result of these reforms, school enrolment rates were substantially higher than in colonies of, for example, Spain and France.

However, from the 19th century Protestantism's influence on schooling had strongly waned—first in traditionally Protestant countries and, further to decolonization, in Britain's former colonies. School systems were secularized and almost completely taken over by the state.

Still, Dr. Feldmann argues that Protestantism's original influence on education and schooling has become part of the national culture in traditionally Protestant countries and in several former British colonies such as Australia and the United States.

His statistical analysis finds that countries with larger Protestant population shares in 1900 had higher secondary school enrolment rates over the years 1975 to 2010. For example, the Nordic countries have both the highest historical Protestant population shares and some of the highest contemporary enrolment rates.

Dr. Feldmann statistically controlled for other factors that determine school enrolment rates, such as income per person and demographic factors, to eliminate their effects.

He explains: "In contrast to what many might expect, the Protestant legacy has an enduring effect on secondary schooling—in spite of almost 200 years of secularization.

"This study is the first to show that the historically positive effect of Protestantism on schooling is still noticeable today.

"It also shows that this is not only the case in a few traditionally Protestant countries. Rather the historically positive effect of Protestantism on schooling is a global phenomenon."

Dr. Feldmann's study suggests that the magnitude of the effect is small. Moreover, it indicates that Protestantism's traditional influence on schooling has diminished over time and that contemporary Protestantism, in contrast to historical Protestantism, does not affect schooling.

Explore further: Study reveals long-term detrimental education effects of Spanish and French colonial systems

More information: Comparative Sociology , booksandjournals.brillonline.c … 63/15691330-12341474

Related Stories

Doing school differently

July 18, 2018

Alternative schooling programs could deliver greater learning outcomes for young people who are struggling at school, according to University of South Australia researcher, Dr. Thomas Stehlik.

Education boosts brain function long after school

March 11, 2014

European populations are growing older on average, a trend that could pose serious challenges to health care, budgets, and economic growth. As a greater proportion of a country's population grows into old age, average cognition ...

Recommended for you

Study forces a rethink on population history of Ibiza

December 7, 2018

Otago researchers have discovered a rare case of genetic population discontinuity on the Mediterranean Island of Ibiza. Essentially, the original genetic signature of the founding female population, handed down through centuries ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3.8 / 5 (4) Sep 25, 2018
Secularisation as a way of eliminating religion from society is a form of enslavement to the State, as one form of devotion (to religion) is replaced by another form of devotion (to the State, government), or to the devotion of self, as in atheism.

As there are many denominations within Protestantism, everyone has a choice of beliefs, dogma, and level of devotion to their chosen denomination.

The main advantage of Protestantism is that it makes available to children the teaching of good values as a human being in the context of the belief in God the Creator, as well as good citizenship.

The lack of belief in a religion doesn't mean that unreligious human beings cannot also have good values and good citizenship - but those values in an atheistic context are not usually carried as hard and fast rules. But it depends on the choices of each individual.
1 / 5 (2) Oct 01, 2018
Protestants used education for evangelism, it was during the Enlightenment that secular schooling took off.

Another problem for the study is that it classifies secular nations after vanishing state or former state religions, e.g. Sweden - a Nordic country - that is secular is erroneously labeled with "protestantic" population shares. The number of remaining active religious is a few percent.

Secularisation as a way of eliminating religion from society

Secularisation means simply separating mundane social matters from religious - ironically here to avoid enslavement to diverse sects - and ratifies freedom of religion as a human right.

That religion is dying because it is not useful is its own problem.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.