Study suggests little dogs lift legs higher to fool other dogs into thinking they are bigger

August 6, 2018 by Bob Yirka, Phys.org report
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

A team of researchers at Cornell University has found evidence suggesting that little dogs lift their legs when peeing at a higher angle than bigger dogs as a means of tricking other dogs into thinking they are bigger than they actually are. In their paper published in Journal of Zoology, the group describes a study they carried out with volunteer dogs and what they found.

Most anyone familiar with knows that they tend to pee in a lot of spots, especially males. They also seem to like peeing on objects that extend up from the ground, such as bushes, fire hydrants, etc. Prior research has suggested that such behavior is a way for dogs to communicate with one another. Communications can occur because dogs have very keen noses and brain parts able to tease out specifics from other dogs simply by sniffing their urine. By sniffing the pee left by another dog, dogs can learn a lot about the dog that did the peeing—such as its gender, age, fertility and some aspects of its health. These communications occur as a means for dogs to learn more about other dogs in the area, both male and female. And now it seems that some dogs have added a little something to the message they want to convey—some trickery involving size.

It is assumed that a dog cannot discern the size of another dog simply by sniffing his pee, so that leaves some leeway for the donor, the researchers learned. Their study consisted of taking many dogs of all sizes out for walks and observing (and videotaping) very closely how they behaved when peeing. One important factor they noted was the angle of the leg when raised. Another was measuring where on an the wound up.

The team then analyzed their data looking for patterns—they found that little dogs lifted their at a higher angle than bigger dogs and in so doing caused their pee to be applied higher up on targeted objects than it would be otherwise. The suggest this likely indicates that the little dogs are attempting to trick others dogs in the area into thinking they are bigger than they actually are.

Explore further: Like humans, dogs found to have fitful sleep after negative experiences

More information: B. McGuire et al. Urine marking in male domestic dogs: honest or dishonest?, Journal of Zoology (2018). DOI: 10.1111/jzo.12603

Abstract
Scent marking is a common mode of communication in mammals. Such marking is thought to communicate information about the signaler's size and corresponding competitive ability and accurately reflect the signaler's attributes (i.e., an honest signal). However, new data suggest that scent marking can be dishonest in certain circumstances. Via two studies, we tested the hypothesis that urine marking is a dishonest signal in adult male domestic dogs, which raise a hindlimb when marking vertical objects. In Study 1, we tested whether raised‐leg angle (i.e., during a urination, the angle between a dog's raised leg and the axis normal to the ground) is a proxy for urine mark height (n = 15 dogs) and, in Study 2, we tested whether small dogs exhibit larger raised‐leg angles than large dogs (n = 45 dogs). We videotaped urinations of adult male dogs and, afterwards, measured height of urine marks (Study 1) and degree of raised‐leg angles (Studies 1 and 2). In Study 1, we found significant positive relationships between both raised‐leg angle and height of urine mark and body size (using either body mass or height at withers) and height of urine mark; raised‐leg angle was a stronger predictor than either measure of body size. In Study 2, we found a significant negative relationship between body size (using either body mass or height at withers) and average raised‐leg angle. Our findings support raised‐leg angle as a proxy for urine mark height and provide additional evidence that scent marking can be dishonest. Assuming body size is a proxy for competitive ability, small adult male dogs may place urine marks higher, relative to their own body size, than larger adult male dogs to exaggerate their competitive ability. We did not control for over marking, which also may explain our findings.

Related Stories

See spot see

March 2, 2013

(HealthDay)—It's a dog-see-dog world. With no sniffing involved, dogs can recognize the faces of other dogs among the faces of humans and other animal species, according to a new study.

New sniffer dog research could save lives

December 13, 2017

A team of scientists has provided the first evidence that dogs can learn to categorise odours and apply this to scents they have never encountered before.

Recommended for you

6 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

LesRof2Evils
not rated yet Aug 06, 2018
I knew a Maltese female that stood on her front legs to pee on at tree. I have always wondered if she was trying to be a bigger dog.
jerone
5 / 5 (1) Aug 06, 2018
How about they are avoiding the splash, leg higher because they stand closer to the spot.
You can PayPal the research grant.
TrollBane
5 / 5 (1) Aug 06, 2018
Metaphorically, the intellectual 'little dogs' here post their pseudoscience and political propaganda again and again to compensate for their lack of scientific credibility.
Beckler
5 / 5 (1) Aug 06, 2018
I see the zoologists over at Cornell are running out of research ideas. :D
dan42day
not rated yet Aug 06, 2018
Smaller animals can lift proportionally larger weights for proportionally equal effort since their own body parts are smaller and lighter, for example ants are able to lift many time their body weight. So the smaller dog may not even be aware that his leg is at a higher angle because he is expending the same effort.
Moltvic
5 / 5 (1) Aug 07, 2018
This makes sense. While anecdotal, when using a urinal I tend to stand on my tippy toes to appear anatomically larger those around me.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.