Feasting rituals and the cooperation they require are a crucial step toward human civilization

July 3, 2018 by Charles Stanish, The Conversation

Coming together for a solstice feast in ancient Peru. Credit: Robert Gutierrez, Author provided
"The Epic of Gilgamesh" is one of the earliest texts known in the world. It's the story of a god-king, Gilgamesh, who ruled the city of Uruk in Mesopotamia in the 3rd millennium B.C. Within its lines, the epic hints at how the ancients viewed the origins of their civilization.

Gilgamesh's antagonist, Enkidu, is described as a wild man, living with the beasts and eating grasses with the gazelles. But he's seduced by a beautiful temple priestess who then offers him clothing and food, saying "Enkidu, eat bread, it is the staff of life; drink the wine, it is the custom of the land." And so Enkidu is transformed from a naked wild beast into a "civilized" man living with other people.

Both bread and wine are products of settled society. They represent the power to control nature and create civilization, converting the wild into the tamed, the raw into the cooked – and their transformation cannot be easily done alone. The very act of transforming the wild into the civilized is a social one, requiring many people to work together.

Over the past few decades, archaeological theory has shifted toward the idea that civilization arose in different regions around the world thanks to the evolution of cooperation. Archaeologists have discovered that the consumption of food and drink in ritually prescribed times and places—known technically as feasting—is one of the cornerstones of heightened sociality and cooperation throughout human history. My own research in Peru bears this out. The data from my colleagues' and my work provides yet another detailed case study for theorists to model the evolution of complexity in one of the rare places where a civilization independently developed.

Geoglyphs that modified the landscape are still visible, delineating a path to where the sun sets on the summer solstice. Credit: Charles Stanish, CC BY-ND
Signs of cooperation in Peru

How does complex society originate out of the hunter-gatherer bands and small settled villages that dominated the globe well into the early Holocene around 9,000 years ago? And once such social organizations develop, what kinds of mechanisms sustain these new societies sufficiently to develop into the Uruks of the ancient world?

Six years ago, after 30 years of research in the Titicaca Basin in the high Andes, my colleague Henry Tantaleán and I started a long-term archaeological research program in the valley of Chincha in the south coast of Peru. Thanks to work by previous archaeologists and our own new data, we have been able to piece together a comprehensive prehistory of the valley beginning several millennia ago.

One significant time period is known as Paracas; it lasted from roughly 800 to 200 B.C. This is the time when the first complex societies developed in the region, the origin of civilization in this part of the . We documented a massive Paracas presence in the valley, ranging from large pyramid structures to modest villages scattered over the landscape.

Across the hyper-arid pampa lands above the valley, the Paracas peoples built linear geoglyphs: designs etched into the desert landscape that they lined with small field stones. We found five sets of lines that all concentrated on the five major Paracas sites at the edge of the pampa. We also found many small structures built between the lines.

Excavation of a structure in the Chincha pampa with the walls aligned to the June solstice. Credit: Charles Stanish, CC BY-ND

Our research indicated that a number of these small structures and many of the lines pointed to the June solstice sunset. Previous work by our team and others throughout Peru unequivocally indicates that the pre-Columbian peoples of the Andes used the solstices to mark important events.

We concluded that these sites were the endpoints of ritually significant social events that were timed by the solstices and possibly other astronomical phenomena.

Feasting at Paracas

We chose to intensively study one endpoint site, called Cerro del Gentil, to assess its significance in Paracas culture. The site is a large platform mound with three levels. The base level measures 50 by 120 meters at its maximum. Each level contains a sunken patio measuring around 12 meters on a side.

Excavations by Tantaleán and his team in one of these patios yielded a rich trove of artifacts, including textiles, food stuffs, pottery, decorated gourds, stone objects, reeds, miscellaneous objects and human offerings. We found large pottery vessels that held chicha or maize beer, the equivalent to Enkidu's wine. There was evidence of food preparation as well, though we did not find a resident population. We found large numbers of pottery serving vessels and evidence of termination rituals involving liquid libations poured into the patio at the conclusion of some elaborate feasts.

A woven cloth bag stuffed with human hair. Credit: PNAS, CC BY

Cerro del Gentil, in fact, was a classic archaeological example of a very significant feasting place. No one seemed to live at this well-built location year-round, though there was plenty of evidence that from time to time many people were present to eat, drink and even make human sacrifices together, probably at particular special times of the astronomical calendar.

We used the Cerro del Gentil data to test the following hypotheses about how the earliest cooperative human groups came together: Did people start out small, feasting within their local group and then expanding to incorporate more distant groups? Or, did the earliest successful groups develop contacts with distant autonomous groups around a large region?

Our colleague Kelly Knudson from Arizona State University analyzed the strontium ratios in 39 organic objects found in the patios as offerings. The ratio of 87Sr/86Sr in any organic object, including humans, tells us from what geographical zone that object is from. We discovered that objects in the patio were from a very broad range of ecozones all around the south central Andes. Some objects came from as far as the Titicaca Basin 600 kilometers away, others from the south coast 200 or so kilometers distant.

Feasting rituals build a young civilization

This case study demonstrates that the earliest successful complex societies in the south coast of Peru circa 400 B.C. involved a wide catchment of people and objects. At least in Paracas society, the optimal strategy of civilization building involved creating widespread alliances early on and then expanding on this model over centuries. We know this because people in Cerro del Gentil incorporated objects and even people in their offerings from distant areas.

A small geoglyph in the Chincha pampa with the center line defining the June solstice. Credit: Charles Stanish, CC BY-ND

In contrast, at a later ceremonial site where the catchment was quite small, all of the objects and human remains were from the immediate environs, as evidenced by strontium analysis. The Paracas pattern detected at Cerro del Gentil contrasts with a strategy in which people focused on their local group and then grew incrementally over time. My colleagues and I plan to use these sorts of comparative cases to try to understand which strategies work better in which environmental and social contexts.

The evidence from Cerro del Gentil supports the theory I wrote about in my recent book "The Evolution of Human Co-operation" – that cooperation in non-state societies is achieved by "ritualizing" the economy. People construct norms, rituals and taboos to organize their economic and political life. Far from being quaint and exotic customs of "primitive peoples," elaborate rules of behavior, encoded in rich ritual practices, are ingenious means of organizing a society where coercion is absent.

Ritual practices reward cooperators and punish cheaters. They therefore promote sustained group behavior toward common goals and solve what is famously known as the "collective action problem" in human social life – how do you get everyone to work together toward something that's in everyone's long-term self-interest? Feasting is a key component of this kind of sociality and cooperation. Enkidu's bread and wine is still relevant 5,000 years later.

Explore further: Field study suggests geoglyphs in ancient Peru were made to lead travelers to trade fairs

More information: Charles Stanish et al. Feasting and the evolution of cooperative social organizations circa 2300 B.P. in Paracas culture, southern Peru, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2018). DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1806632115

Related Stories

Archaeologists discover a 1,000-year-old mummy in Peru

May 25, 2018

A team from the Université libre de Bruxelles's centre for archaeological research (CReA-Patrimoine) has completed a significant excavation in Pachacamac, Peru, where they have discovered an intact mummy in especially good ...

Truck damages Peru's ancient Nazca lines

January 30, 2018

Peru's ancient Nazca lines were damaged when a driver accidentally plowed his cargo truck into the fragile archaeological site in the desert, officials said Tuesday.

Recommended for you

Sensual fresco discovered in ancient Pompeii bedroom

November 19, 2018

Archaeologists have found a fresco in an ancient Pompeii bedroom that depicts a sensual scene of the Roman god Jupiter, disguised as a swan, and a legendary queen of Sparta from Greek mythology.

Excavators find tombs buried in Bolivia 500 years ago

November 17, 2018

Archaeologists say they found tombs at a Bolivian quarry containing remains from more than 500 years ago that give an insight into the interaction of various peoples with the expanding Inca empire.

Preventing chemical weapons as sciences converge

November 15, 2018

Alarming examples of the dangers from chemical weapons have been seen recently in the use of industrial chemicals and the nerve agent sarin against civilians in Syria, and in the targeted assassination operations using VX ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jul 03, 2018
"We found … evidence of termination rituals …"

As in pregnancy termination?
1 / 5 (1) Jul 03, 2018
I have a different understanding of Gilgamesh...Ok hear me out.. https://billymeie...ing-e-t/
He is an E.T. from galaxy M94 – NGC 4736. He is around 50,000 years old. Allegedly, he needs to live near heavy/radioactive water. He is also morphogenic, which would explain why he was described as being 3 meters tall. According to the Plejaren, Gilgamesh's people no longer exists because a sudden and unpredictable planetary catastrophe caused the whole race to become extinct within a few minutes. There were no survivors because no human beings of this people also stayed outside of the planet.
Gilgamesh is, thus, the sole survivor, who has adapted his shape, however, to that of the earthly human and has morphogenetically transformed and found a new home in this world, which he no longer wants to leave.
not rated yet Jul 04, 2018
"Both bread and wine are products of settled society"

-Well actually they are evidence of chronic overpopulation. Grass is the last food any self-respecting hunter gatherer would eat. Too much effort, too little nutrition. Processing it into something edible is an act of desperation.

And wine is spoiled juice, again with little nutritional value.

But both result from the need to store food to feed excess populations who are already chronically malnourished.
"The Epic of Gilgamesh contains one of the three Akkadian flood myths. In the Atrahasis Epic, Enlil, the god of wind, uses famine and drought to control the overpopulation of humans..."

-Even the gods knew what mankind greatest problem was.

I think the early flood legends were adapted to refer to the coming flood of humanity upon the earth, and the efforts of an enochian priesthood to preserve its store of accumulated knowledge despite the ruination this flood will inevitably cause.
1 / 5 (1) Jul 04, 2018
The floods were drunken godlings amusing each other, pissing on humanity.

Hey! That's as believable as any of the other twaddling bunkum offered in these comments.
not rated yet Jul 04, 2018
Poopoo willis, nobody reads his comments, nobody cares what he has to say, nobody thinks hes as great as he thinks he is.

Must be our fault.
1 / 5 (1) Jul 04, 2018
Yet otto you continue to fail a pushing that ignore button. Should I send a monkey around to show you how to do it?
not rated yet Jul 08, 2018
Jus doin my job there buddy

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.