Obese dogs could have similar 'personality' traits to overweight humans – new study

June 6, 2018 by Naomi D. Harvey, The Conversation
Credit: Shutterstock

We're all told we need to eat healthier and exercise more to combat obesity, but did you know that there's also an obesity epidemic among pets, at least in the West? Between 39% and 59% of pet dogs in Europe, Australia and the US are estimated to be overweight or obese. In fact, obesity is now considered the biggest threat to the the health and well-being of our pets.

Just as in humans, in involves many different factors. Certain breeds of dog seem to be more prone to obesity than others, and scientists have found a genetic mutation that seems to make dogs more likely to seek out . So genetics certainly seems to be involved, alongside the amount of food and exercise dogs get.

But one aspect of obesity in dogs that has received little attention to date is the emotional and cognitive aspect. That is to say, how motivated different dogs are to access food, and how personality traits such as the response to rewards might play a part. In a new study published in Royal Society Open Science, a team of European researchers have looked at just that. They found that overweight dogs were more likely to choose food containing larger amounts of energy, and more likely to hesitate if they didn't know what kind of they were being offered.

This could be interpreted in different ways but, at the very least, it shows the importance of individual behaviour and "personality" when it comes to obesity in dogs. This supports the suggestion that dogs could be a promising model for experimentally investigating the emotional and cognitive aspects of obesity in humans.

Scientists have shown that overweight and obese people often record a stronger attraction to energy-rich foods high in fat and sugar than people of healthy weight. Scientists think how attracted you are to these foods is related to how sensitive to rewards you are. This is seen as a "personality" trait that differs between individuals and is part of the brain's reward system.

Do I look motivated to you? Credit: Shutterstock

The researchers in the latest study wanted to see if the eating habit of dogs and therefore their weight were related to their sensitivity to rewards in a similar way. To do this, they measured how long the dogs would listen to a human indicating at a bowl of low-energy food when a second bowl of high-energy, more rewarding food was also available. The researchers also studied how eager the dogs were to reach a bowl of food whose energy content was unknown, offering an ambiguous reward.

Using these tasks, the authors concluded that dogs behaved in a similar way to people. The overweight dogs were more likely to choose the higher-energy reward compared to dogs of an ideal weight, even when it meant ignoring directions given by a person. The overweight dogs were also slower to respond to the ambiguous reward.

Emotional or physical response?

The researchers concluded that this showed overweight dogs were indeed more sensitive to rewards. But there could be an alternative explanation for their findings. Overweight dogs might have more sensitive energy regulation systems. This could be mean they would be more likely to conserve their energy when the rewards of acting are uncertain, and more motivated to consumer higher-value foods.

Obesity in dogs is rising, and overweight dogs die sooner and are more likely to develop such as osteoarthritis and diabetes than non-. For these reasons alone, understanding the factors that contribute to obesity in dogs is worthwhile. But whatever the explanation for the latest findings, the fact the overweight and ideal weight dogs behaved differently suggests this kind of experiment could be useful for scientists wanting to understand the psychological aspects of obesity more generally.

Experimental studies of human behaviour have to adhere to strict ethical regulations, which often makes studying motivations challenging because you need to deceive those participating. If you're told a study is about your behaviour around food, you would likely act differently than if you didn't know what it was about. But non-invasive studies of dog behaviour such as this one can be conducted on without the same ethical qualms, while providing the dogs themselves with a free meal and a fun day out.

Explore further: Dogs could be more similar to humans than we thought

More information: Ákos Pogány et al. The behaviour of overweight dogs shows similarity with personality traits of overweight humans, Royal Society Open Science (2018). DOI: 10.1098/rsos.172398

Related Stories

Obese dogs helped by 'effective' weight loss trials

September 21, 2017

On average overweight dogs lose an average of 11% of their bodyweight when enrolled on a weight loss trial according to researchers who have conducted the largest international multi-centre weight study.

Study shows how a dog's diet shapes its gut microbiome

January 24, 2017

Studies of the gut microbiome have gone to the dogs—and pets around the world could benefit as a result. In a paper published this week in mBio, researchers from Nestle Purina PetCare Company report that the ratio of proteins ...

Recommended for you

Staying a step ahead of the game

October 18, 2018

Trypanosoma brucei, which causes sleeping sickness, evades the immune system by repeatedly altering the structure of its surface coat. Sequencing of its genome and studies of its 3-D genome architecture have now revealed ...

Elucidating cuttlefish camouflage

October 18, 2018

The unique ability of cuttlefish, squid and octopuses to hide by imitating the colors and texture of their environment has fascinated natural scientists since the time of Aristotle. Uniquely among all animals, these mollusks ...

Biodiversity can also destabilize ecosystems

October 18, 2018

Ecosystems have a variety of benefits to humans, including food, water and other resources, as well as recreational space. It is therefore important that these systems remain functional and stable—especially in view of ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.