Math explains why your bus route seems so unreliable

June 29, 2018 by Vikash V. Gayah, S. Ilgin Guler, The Conversation
The tricky math behind your bus route. Credit: Monkey Business Images/shutterstock.com

Have you ever waited for your bus at a bus stop for a very long time – only to be greeted by two or more buses arriving together?

This phenomenon, known as "bus bunching," is a problem that bus transit systems around the world have been trying to solve for decades. During this time, researchers have used mathematical models to study the behavior of bus transit systems to better understand why this happens. The mathematics identify what causes this problem – and also suggests that bus-tracking technology can be combined with simple control algorithms to improve the situation.

Bunching is annoying for riders, since it increases both the average time spent waiting for the bus and the variability in this waiting time.

Bunching also makes the bus system less reliable, because it causes to get off . The long waits induced by bunching can also cause people to shift away from buses toward other, less sustainable modes of transportation.

Bus bunching occurs because bus routes are inherently unstable. When the buses are on schedule, everything seems to work fine. They travel from stop to stop, waiting at each for passengers to exit or climb aboard. However, once a bus gets behind schedule, it's nearly impossible for it to get back on track. It will continue to get further and further behind schedule until the next bus on the route catches up.

The same thing happens to buses that are early: They continue to get earlier and earlier as they travel through their route, until they catch up to the bus just ahead.

Equations that describe how buses move along a route identify why this happens. The time buses spend serving passengers at a stop is related to the amount of time between consecutive bus arrivals, commonly known as bus headway. When a bus runs late, its headway increases and more passengers arrive that need to be served at its next stop. But the more passengers waiting at a stop, the longer a bus needs to spend there. So late buses need to spend more time at each subsequent stop, causing them to run even later. The opposite happens for a bus that's early. This cycle continues until multiple buses eventually catch up to each other and bunch.

So what can be done to stop this? Transit agencies have worked with researchers such as ourselves to propose many different ideas to eliminate bus bunching.

One strategy is to instruct late buses to skip stops where passengers don't need to get off or to limit the number of people allowed to board late buses at each stop. Both of these allows the late bus to spend less time at each stop, which allows it the opportunity to catch up. Of course, doing so can leave potential users stranded.

Another common strategy is to build more time than needed into a bus's schedule. This additional time – called slack – helps accommodate the variability in bus travel time. Buses that are early are instructed to hold at selected stops until the scheduled time to depart. However, this strategy does not help late buses recover. It's also susceptible to any disturbances that cause buses to get off schedule. Delaying or holding buses in this way also reduces the speed at which passengers can travel along the route.

New technology may be able to help. Transit agencies can now track the location of buses in real time and offer tailored feedback to drivers. These novel strategies treat consecutive buses as if they were all connected by springs. Buses that are too close together along the are given instructions to help "push" them apart, while buses that are too far apart are given information to help "pull" them back together. Drivers might be told to spend this much extra time to spend at a stop or to travel that much slower or faster along a route.

Researchers have developed algorithms that agencies can use to provide such instructions to individual buses and avoid bus bunching. These instructions could be sent from dispatchers at the transit agency who monitor the system and provide simple guidance to drivers or through on-board computers that calculate exactly what drivers should do to prevent bunching automatically. Computer simulations and field tests suggest that these dynamic strategies may one day make bunching a thing of the past.

Explore further: Georgia Tech researchers address bus bunching

Related Stories

Georgia Tech researchers address bus bunching

April 19, 2012

As any city dweller knows, buses are rarely on time. It’s typical to wait a while, only to have several buses show up one after another, a phenomenon known as bus bunching.

Bus scheduling algorithm picks up the slack

October 23, 2007

A prizewinning paper by a USC Viterbi School engineer elegantly solves a basic transit scheduling problem, potentially meaning shorter waits and faster trips for riders.

London transport body to test battery-charging at bus stands

August 28, 2014

Transport for London (TfL) on Wednesday announced a trial to enable specially designed buses to wirelessly charge their batteries while they wait at bus stands. The trial will involve the use of extended-range diesel electric ...

A better way to calculate school bus routes

March 15, 2017

Here's a math problem even the brightest school districts struggle to solve: getting hordes of elementary, middle and high school students onto buses and to school on time every day.

Six rules for improving city bus services

May 2, 2018

Public transport that is safe, efficient and effective is a core priority when it comes to city-building. While trains get a lot of attention, buses can also deliver successful public transport services – if we can overcome ...

Recommended for you

Fish-inspired material changes color using nanocolumns

March 20, 2019

Inspired by the flashing colors of the neon tetra fish, researchers have developed a technique for changing the color of a material by manipulating the orientation of nanostructured columns in the material.

7 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Eikka
3 / 5 (2) Jun 29, 2018
One strategy is to instruct late buses to skip stops where passengers don't need to get off


Most busses have buttons for passengers wanting to leave. If nobody wants to, the bus doesn't stop. If there's nobody lining up for the bus to pick up, same deal. The common practice is for the first person to step up to the curb and raise their hand for the bus, and if none do then the bus doesn't stop.

If on the other hand, the bus runs past the stop despite people lining up and waving their hands for the bus, that puts people off of public transportation.

or to limit the number of people allowed to board


Which would only put people off of public transportation.
adam_russell_9615
5 / 5 (2) Jun 30, 2018
"The same thing happens to buses that are early: They continue to get earlier and earlier as they travel through their route, until they catch up to the bus just ahead."

40 years ago I was told by a bus driver that they werent allowed to leave the stop ahead of schedule. They are allowed to be late but not early. If they get to a stop ahead of time they have to wait at that stop until they are back on schedule.
pntaylor
not rated yet Jul 01, 2018
Due to the myriad of variables involved, this will never be solved, at least not until
the systems are completely automated and allowed to cut that "one too many" passenger
in half, with the closing door and avoid any prosecution. Before that happens, as stated,
the public will have completely given up on public transportation.
Da Schneib
1 / 5 (2) Jul 01, 2018
None of these draconian measures are proposed. Instead, the bus drivers are instructed to drive slower or faster. That's where the slack in the system is useful. What you do is limit the buses to less than the speed limit almost all the time; then, if they have to go faster, they can, and if they have to go slower they can.

But that's too smart for libertardians.
Da Schneib
1.5 / 5 (2) Jul 01, 2018
Just so it's clear for everyone, the bus information system tells the driver what speed to drive at. If you're really slick, you modify the traffic light timing in coordination with the speeds the bus drivers are told to drive. This is not rocket science.
Eikka
4 / 5 (1) Jul 01, 2018
What you do is limit the buses to less than the speed limit almost all the time; then, if they have to go faster, they can, and if they have to go slower they can.


You have to account for the average speed, because the bus stops for variable amounts of time. On average it's always going slower than the speed limit, but how slow is dependent on the number of passengers and stops.

The speed adjustments have to come by waiting at the stops, because the bus can't drive significantly slower than the speed limit without being a plug for other traffic, and it can't speed past the limit (although some do).

But waiting at the stops carries additional problems, because multiple bus routes serve the same stops, so one bus can't be blocking the stop, it would be making other busses run late.
pntaylor
not rated yet Jul 01, 2018
Also, if a bus is late to a stop, passengers may miss an interconnecting bus.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.