Burst of newborn stars in young star cluster puzzles astronomers

May 7, 2018, Chinese Academy of Sciences
Each point represents one star. Black points are normal stars. Blue and red points represent blue straggler stars belonging to two clear sequences. The blue solid and blue dashed lines are theoretical model predictions. The left sequence is composed of blue straggler stars formed roughly at the same time. Credit: NAOC

Since the limited amount of gas that survived from the first bulk star-forming process will be quickly expelled within several million years, star clusters have long been thought of as "infertile" stellar systems that cannot form new stars. Only collisions or mergers of stars can lead to rejuvenation of much older stars, making them look younger than most normal stars in much the same way as humans apply facelifts.

Such are known as "blue stragglers," because they appear to "straggle" behind the natural evolution of most stars in a star cluster: They still resemble extremely hot (and therefore blue) young stars.

Using the Hubble Space Telescope, an international research team led by Dr. DENG Licai from the National Astronomical Observatories of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (NAOC) detected an unexpected population of blue straggler stars in a young "globular" cluster, known by its catalogue number NGC 2173.

This is surprising, because blue straggler stars in this cluster seem to have formed in a well-defined burst. The team's findings were published in The Astrophysical Journal.

"In principle, stellar collisions or binary mergers should not take place at the same time. They will happen randomly in star clusters and produce blue straggler stars that seem to have different ages," said Dr. LI Chengyuan of Australia's Macquarie University, the first author of this work.

Astronomers study stellar ages using a common diagram that relates stellar brightness to temperature at the stellar surface. Blue straggler stars formed randomly would produce a smattering of stars across the diagram. If they were born at the same time, however, they would clearly show a tight sequence. In NGC 2173, Dr. DENG and his colleagues detected two distinct sequences of blue straggler stars in the diagnostic diagram.

Although this is not the first time astronomers have detected such clearly distinct blue straggler sequences in star clusters, such features were previously only found in old "globular" clusters, with ages more than 10 billion years. This is the first time astronomers have found a similar pattern in a much younger cluster of only 1 to 2 billion years old.

"When the very cores of clusters collapse under the gravity of all the stars in that small volume of space, we witness one of the most extreme astronomical events. When this happens, the cluster becomes extremely dense and you can imagine that many stellar collisions could happen in the core region. As a result, lots of blue straggler stars could be produced. For this reason, the double sequence of blue stragglers can be expected in clusters only when they get old, older than 10 billion years," said Dr. DENG.

"However, we did not find any evidence that supports the presence of a collapsed core in this cluster. In addition, the conditions in this even disfavor the occurrence of many stellar collisions," said Dr. LI.

An anonymous reviewer solicited by the editors of The Astrophysical Journal wrote, "This work certainly presents unexpected, and therefore interesting observational results... It challenges the generality of explanations put forward for other such blue straggler sequences."

In a News & Views commentary published in the journal Nature Astronomy, Prof. Alison Sills from McMaster University in Canada wrote, "This is contradictory to our expectation. Star clusters and their populations seem to keep providing surprises every time we look just a litter closer."

Explore further: Even stars get fat -- And 'stellar cannibalism' is the reason

More information: Chengyuan Li et al, An Unexpected Detection of Bifurcated Blue Straggler Sequences in the Young Globular Cluster NGC 2173, The Astrophysical Journal (2018). DOI: 10.3847/1538-4357/aaad65

Related Stories

Stellar family portrait in X-rays

May 3, 2018

In some ways, star clusters are like giant families with thousands of stellar siblings. These stars come from the same origins—a common cloud of gas and dust—and are bound to one another by gravity. Astronomers think ...

Exotic binary stars

April 9, 2018

Cataclysmic variable stars (CVs) are white dwarf stars that are accreting from an orbiting, low mass binary companion star. The accretion is facilitated by the proximity of the stars; typical orbital periods range from about ...

Stellar vampires unmasked

October 2, 2006

Astronomers have found possible proofs of stellar vampirism in the globular cluster 47 Tucanae. Using ESO's Very Large Telescope, they found that some hot, bright, and apparently young stars in the cluster present less carbon ...

Hubble's celestial snow globe

December 12, 2017

It's beginning to look a lot like the holiday season in this NASA Hubble Space Telescope image of a blizzard of stars, which resembles a swirling snowstorm in a snow globe.

Young stars at home in ancient cluster

February 9, 2012

(PhysOrg.com) -- Looking like a hoard of gems fit for an emperor's collection, this deep sky object called NGC 6752 is in fact far more worthy of admiration. It is a globular cluster, and at over 10 billion years old is one ...

Recommended for you

Physicists reveal why matter dominates universe

March 21, 2019

Physicists in the College of Arts and Sciences at Syracuse University have confirmed that matter and antimatter decay differently for elementary particles containing charmed quarks.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (2) May 07, 2018
Strike 53..? I count at least four previous strikes against cluster models alone! See my comments thereunder.





So in view of:
"This is contradictory to our expectation. Star clusters and their populations seem to keep providing surprises every time we look just a litter closer."

This is surprising, because blue straggler stars in this cluster seem to have formed in a well-defined burst.

"However, we did not find any evidence that supports the presence of a collapsed core in this cluster.

Isn't it time to study the correct model, instead of the fanciful tale that merger maniacs so love?

In any case, I told you so, long ago. Read my earlier comments?
5 / 5 (3) May 08, 2018
In any case, I told you so, long ago.

No, you didn't. In every case you use post-diction, claiming that any results found by the people that are doing all the hard work could be explained by your own pet theory, subquantum kinetics. But your model appears to horrible at pre-dicting anything, primarily because it is mostly a bunch of story telling and hand waving and not so much a quantifiable mathematical model of real physics. I could be wrong though. Please post any paper by LaViolette or any of his followers that specifically predicted large numbers of similarly aged blue stragglers in young star clusters.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.