More stringent rape laws reduce chances a country will face civil war, study finds

September 6, 2017
Women read about their legal rights in a public awareness campaign in Benin, Nigeria, in 2011. A study led by a University of Kansas researcher found that countries with more stringent rape laws were less likely to experience civil strife and violence. The researchers identified 10 countries including Nigeria that experienced civil strife since 1954 and later made reforms to strengthen rape laws and women's rights. Credit: E. C. Ahoundou/USAID/U.S. government work

Countries that have longer punitive sentences for rape crimes are less likely to have civil war and strife, according to a new study led by a University of Kansas researcher.

"The transmission of rape laws across countries correlates with democratization and a general trend toward progressive laws. It proceeds then that countries are more likely to adopt gender-neutral laws and stricter laws against rape," said Nazli Avdan, a KU assistant professor of Political Science and the study's lead author.

Avdan and her co-author Victor Asal, chair of public administration and associate professor of political science at University at Albany, paired a statistical analysis of data on rape legislation for 194 states across the world from 1965 to 2005 with the number of intrastate conflicts or civil wars over that time span.

The study published recently in the journal Dynamics of Asymmetric Conflict addresses an expanding body of research that argues that gender inequality heightens the probability of intrastate conflict by creating a structure of violence.

Avdan said their study proposes the legal system and the penal code, especially punishment for rape, are the missing links between social norms and an intrastate conflict.

States that did little to punish perpetrators of rape likely include exemptions for the crime of rape if the perpetrator and victim are married, or possibly they treat genders differently under the law. In other cases, some penal systems exonerate the assailant if he agrees to marry the .

"A so-called marriage loophole is a situation with a perpetrator is married to a victim would exonerate the assailant," Avdan said. "That is at its core a misogynistic policy. Countries with these policies - for example, Middle Eastern countries like Jordan and Lebanon but also other countries such as the Philippines—have received condemnation for not reforming these laws."

The researchers argue that nations that have laws that are gender neutral in how they protect citizens, especially in granting equal protection and rights to women, the more likely the state's society will embody liberal and progressive norms.

"These norms cohere with ideas about peaceful conflict resolution," Avdan said. "These ideas in turn mitigate civil conflict."

The researchers identified 13 states that experienced or were prone to conflict:

  • Angola
  • Georgia
  • Haiti
  • Iraq
  • Nigeria
  • Pakistan
  • Uzbekistan
  • Guinea
  • India
  • Liberia
  • Tajikistan
  • Myanmar
  • Senegal

All but three—Liberia, Myanmar and Senegal—of those nations have in past decades reformed rape laws toward stringency and gender neutrality. The researchers also found that states that establish similar sentences for female and male offenders alike also significantly decreased chances of an internal . This showcases that the gender neutrality of the law correlates with progressive and liberal societal norms.

Avdan said their findings support research that has identified political liberalism and progressive, individualistic and emancipatory ideas, including gay rights, for example, tend to correlate with reduced propensities of armed conflicts.

"Rape law showcases an angle about gender norms," she said. "And we know that masculine norms tend to support militarism and militant nationalism as well. Rape law can be another proxy to look at equality in society."

The transmission of egalitarian rape law and criminalization of rape like other ideas about liberty, self-determination, and physical integrity have followed an evolutionary trajectory, Avdan said.

The researchers examined the rape law legislation that was adopted in states across the world, but the study does not address other potential obstacles around rape law, such as the enforcement side and prevalent stigmas victims suffer, she said.

"Even if the law significantly punishes perpetrators of , other factors like a corrupt police force or the victim encountering stigma in society," Avdan said, "can create a mismatch or a big gap between de jure and de facto policy, or between law and enforcement."

Explore further: Using feminist theory to understand male rape

More information: Nazli Avdan et al, Outlawing sexual violence: rape law and the likelihood of civil war, Dynamics of Asymmetric Conflict (2017). DOI: 10.1080/17467586.2017.1346814

Related Stories

Using feminist theory to understand male rape

October 20, 2014

Decades of feminist research have framed rape and sexual assault as a 'women's issue', leaving little room for the experiences of male victims. But a new study published in the Journal of Gender Studies suggests that feminist ...

What motivates males who commit sexual assault on campus?

January 6, 2015

The shocking statistic that about one in five women will be the victim of sexual assault while in college is made even more so by the fact that most of those women will know their assailants. No one-size-fits-all approach ...

Recommended for you

Political polarization? Don't blame the web, study says

September 19, 2017

Despite the popular narrative that the web is to blame for rising political polarization, a study by a Brown University economist has found that recent growth in polarization is greatest for demographic groups in which individuals ...

Ancestor of sea reptile super-predators found in Germany

September 15, 2017

A new species of extinct sea monster from the Early Jurassic has been identified by a team of German and Swedish researchers. The fossilized bones were found in a clay pit near the city of Bielefeld in Germany. The findings ...

Research on big ears, crocodile gambling wins Ig Nobels

September 14, 2017

Scientists who discovered that old men really do have big ears, that playing the didgeridoo helps relieve sleep apnea and that handling crocodiles can influence gambling decisions are among this year's recipients of the Ig ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Dark_Solar
not rated yet Sep 06, 2017
Interesting....very interesting. I'd like to see a ruling-out of variables (social stigma, corrupt/lax policing, under-reporting, etc.) that can be ruled out as influences before wholly endorsing this study, but it definitely has legs. Waiting to see where this goes....

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.