Oldest kids in class do better, even into university, study finds

September 8, 2017, University of Toronto
Credit: Victoria Choi via Flickr

It's been known for years that the oldest children in class perform better in school than their youngest classmates. But according to a new study co-authored by University of Toronto Scarborough economist Elizabeth Dhuey, that gap can persist, with older children more likely to attend post-secondary school and graduate from an elite university.

"Older , in this case those born in early September, do better in elementary school than their younger peers," says Dhuey, whose past research has explored this phenomenon.

"What we found in this study is that gap persists throughout their school careers, so they end up being more likely to attend a post-secondary school and graduate from an elite university."

The study, by Dhuey, an associate professor of economics, and a team of three economists from U.S.-based universities, was published by the National Bureau of Economic Research. It followed differences between Florida children born just before and after the Sept. 1 cut-off date to start kindergarten. (In Ontario, the cut-off date to start kindergarten is Jan. 1.)

Dhuey says what was surprising about the data is that the effect is fairly significant and is experienced across all socioeconomic groups.

For example, in looking at children from the middle socioeconomic group, the researchers found that older September-born students were 2.6 per cent more likely to attend post-secondary school, and 2.6 per cent more likely to graduate from an elite university compared to their younger, August-born peers.

The researchers also found that August-born children were one per cent more likely to be incarcerated for juvenile crimes, a finding Dhuey says was really surprising.

"These are not massive differences, but it's certainly large enough to be economically significant," she says.

While past studies have shown that do better in , there's been some debate as to whether the effect disappears over time. This study is unique because of the high-quality nature of the data and the fact it looked at the long-term effects by following students throughout their academic careers and into university.

Dhuey suggests older children could be enjoying small advantages from getting a head start, which continues over the years. It's not clear how these gaps can be resolved, she says.

Notably, and somewhat controversially, Dhuey's past research has been used as evidence to support academic redshirting, which is the practice of parents delaying entrance into kindergarten for their children born late in the year (for example December-born children for those living in Ontario). Her research was also cited by Malcolm Gladwell in his book Outliers.

Does this study mean that parents of children born late in the year should be rushing to redshirt their children?

Not at all, says Dhuey. "It's not clear at all that we should be redshirting our children," she says. "I think these are large effects and they're important to understand, but parents shouldn't place undue importance on it."

For one, redshirting means removing your child from the labour market for a year further down the road, which can be costly in itself. She also notes it's unclear whether redshirting is even an effective technique, since it's never been measured: there is little data comparing students who were redshirted compared to those who weren't.

"My ultimate goal is to somehow provide a causal effect of redshirting, that way we can really understand whether it's a beneficial intervention to take or not," she says.

Dhuey says it's important that parents understand the and meet with their child's teacher early on to talk about how to mitigate it. But they shouldn't panic – it's not a predictor of whether their child will be at a severe disadvantage.

"It's important to remember these are on-average statistics, and that there are plenty of December-born children who are doing just fine," she says.

Explore further: 'Redshirting' kindergarteners not as common as reported

More information: Elizabeth Dhuey et al. School Starting Age and Cognitive Development, (2017). DOI: 10.3386/w23660

Related Stories

'Redshirting' kindergarteners not as common as reported

April 26, 2013

New research findings from the University of Virginia's Curry School of Education and the Stanford School of Education show that "redshirting" in kindergarten – the practice of delaying for a year a child's entry into kindergarten ...

Most ADHD medicine used by December-born children

June 9, 2017

Children born at the end of the year are more likely to receive ADHD medication or an ADHD diagnosis than children born early in the year. This is according to a new study from the Norwegian Institute of Public Health.

'Redshirting' kids yields no advantage in higher education

July 29, 2015

While many parents and educators believe holding children back from entering kindergarten offers advantages if they are older relative to their classmates, Cornell researchers Kevin Kniffin and Andrew Hanks have found that ...

Recommended for you

Study: Social media sways exercise motivation

January 17, 2019

It's January – a time when students are looking for that extra bit of oomph. For some, time spent on social media might provide the necessary inspiration to get up and exercising – but that time can come with consequences, ...

5 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

dirk_bruere
2 / 5 (4) Sep 08, 2017
So, astrology is correct - what month you are born in does have an effect on your life
Jeffhans1
3.7 / 5 (3) Sep 08, 2017
So, astrology is correct - what month you are born in does have an effect on your life


Even a broken calendar page is right every few decades. This doesn't mean we should plan our lives around astrology or broken calendar pages though.
ugosugo
not rated yet Sep 08, 2017
2.6%; 1% Statistically significant but irrelevant in practical terms
rrwillsj
2 / 5 (2) Sep 08, 2017
Well us, 1% irrelenant? Tell yah what a great deal I have for you! Your lucky day, I will give you 10% of ten dollars, once you give me 1% of a million dollars.

1% of millions of people will fill up how many prisons?

Myself, I opinionate that these findings are more likely the result of the bigger kids bullying the smaller, taking their lunch money and forcing them to give up their homework.
Nik_2213
not rated yet Sep 09, 2017
Due care, please; I've seen 'Autumn' kids struggle due to sheer boredom. Worse, they can find stuff so easy, they fail to learn how to study-- Which may come back to bite them...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.