S. Africa opposes online rhino horn auction

August 18, 2017 by Susan Njanji
Rhino horn is worth more than gold or cocaine per kilo on the black market

South Africa on Friday moved to halt an online auction of rhino horn starting next week, as outraged conservationists said the sale would undermine the global ban on rhino trade.

The three-day auction by South African John Hume, who runs the world's biggest rhino farm, comes after a ban on domestic trade in the country was lifted three months ago.

Hume's lawyer Izak du Toit claimed the permits had already been approved—but not issued.

The High Court in Pretoria started hearing the case on an urgent basis on Friday.

The court is expected to make a decision on Sunday, shortly before to the auction is scheduled to open at midday (1000 GMT) on Monday, officials said.

"The Minister of Environmental Affairs is opposing the application," the government said in a statement on Friday, declining to comment further.

Hume and some other campaigners say poaching can only be halted by meeting the huge demand from Asia through legally "harvesting" horn from anaesthetised live .

He has stockpiles of six tonnes of horns and wants to place 500 kilogrammes or 264 horns, under the hammer.

South Africa is home to around 20,000 rhinos, some 80 percent of the worldwide population, but in recent years has suffered record slaughter by poachers.

Rhino horn is composed mainly of keratin, the same component as in human nails.

It is sold in powdered form as a supposed cure for cancer and other diseases—as well as an aphrodisiac—in Vietnam and China.

While any auctioned horn could not exported from South Africa, conservationists fear the sale will stimulate black market demand and undermine the four-decade old international ban on rhino trading.

The auction website is in English, but also in Chinese and Vietnamese.

A fair price?

Joseph Okori, of the International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW), described the auction as "deplorable".

"There is deliberate motive to target people in countries where people consume ," Okori told AFP.

Rhino horns are highly prized, estimated to fetch up to $60,000 a kilo on the black market - more than the price of gold or cocaine.

Johan Van Eyk of Van's Auctioneers who will conduct the auction said there is no set opening price because this will be the first ever rhino horn auction.

"We will have to look at what people are willing to pay and that will give us an idea of the price on the legal market," Van Eyk told AFP.

The association of private rhino owners is banking on the planned auction to determine demand and the "fair market" value of the horn, according to its president Pelham Jones.

Hume is also planning a physical auction in September.

South Africa has over 300 private rhino breeders who say they have spent more than two billion rand ($150 million) to protect their herds over the past nine years.

The farmers hope to recuperate expenses from the sale of the horns taken by dehorning rhinos.

"The (security) burden has now become so severe that many rhino reserves simply cannot afford any longer," said Jones.

But for animal rights activists, the legal sale of rhino horns will only fuel poaching.

"It's going to exacerbate it," said Dex Kotze, a South African wildlife activist. "Is this a money making scheme or do they want to save the rhino?"

Explore further: South Africa moves ahead on domestic trade in rhino horn

Related Stories

Rhino poaching dips slightly in South Africa

July 24, 2017

The number of rhinos killed for their horns by poachers in South Africa dipped slightly in the first half of this year, but more than 500 were still slaughtered, the government announced Monday.

Recommended for you

Acidic oceans cause fish to lose their sense of smell

July 23, 2018

When carbon dioxide is absorbed by seawater carbonic acid is formed, making the water more acidic. Since the Industrial Revolution, oceanic CO2 has risen by 43% and is predicted to be two and a half times current levels by ...

Should you share data of threatened species?

July 23, 2018

Scientists publishing locations of rare species have been blamed for helping poachers drive them to extinction, such as the local extinction of the Chinese cave gecko.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.