Selfish motives, not fairness, the best message for criminal justice advocacy groups

July 19, 2017 by Jeffron Boynés, University of Illinois at Chicago

Advocacy groups and activists should appeal to self-interests if they want to obtain public support for criminal justice reform, according to a new study.

"Messages that appeal to self-interest are more effective at building public for eliminating for nonviolent offenses than that emphasize the human costs of incarceration," says author Aaron Gottlieb, assistant professor in the Jane Addams College of Social Work at the University of Illinois at Chicago.

The results suggest that messages appealing to fairness by emphasizing the harm done to certain subgroups of the population (i.e. African Americans and children) are not effective, said Gottlieb.

To arrive at his findings, Gottlieb surveyed approximately 3,100 respondents on Amazon Mechanical Turk, a crowdsourcing website used by social scientists to collect experimental data. He tested the impact of six different messages on for policies eliminating the use of incarceration for three nonviolent offense types: nonviolent drug offenses, nonviolent property offenses less than or equal to $1,500, and technical parole violations.

Gottlieb identified several messages which are most effective:

1. Self-interest is an important factor motivating human behavior.

Messages emphasizing the substantial cost of incarceration and the high rates of recidivism among individuals released from prison were more likely to support the elimination of incarceration for nonviolent offenses.

2. Appealing to fairness of who is punished, while important, was no more effective than no messages at all.

Messages emphasizing the racial disparities in incarceration, the harm done to children, and the mental health and substance abuse challenges common among people in prison do not appear to influence support for reform.

3. Appealing to unfairness of the punishment itself can be effective.

Messages emphasizing the massive growth in incarceration caused by harsher sentences were more likely to support reform.

Gottlieb said his research is important because the U.S. incarcerates the largest number of people in the world. However, in recent years, there has been "growing bipartisan agreement that we need to reform the system," he added.

"Reform remains possible because the most impactful criminal justice policies are made at the state and local level," Gottlieb said.

Given what is known about the high number of people who enter prison and jail for nonviolent offenses and the negative implications of incarceration for individuals, families, and communities, these reforms could have a dramatic positive impact on American society, he said.

The study, "The Effect of Message Frames on Public Attitudes Toward Criminal Justice Reform for Nonviolent Offenses," was published in the May edition of the journal Crime & Delinquency.

Explore further: 'Color-blind' sentencing alone can't cure racial bias in U.S. criminal justice system, new study suggests

More information: Aaron Gottlieb. The Effect of Message Frames on Public Attitudes Toward Criminal Justice Reform for Nonviolent Offenses, Crime & Delinquency (2017). DOI: 10.1177/0011128716687758

Related Stories

Study finds gender disparities for inmates with HIV

July 17, 2015

In the largest study of inmates with HIV receiving antiretroviral therapy, Yale researchers uncovered significant differences in HIV treatment outcomes for men and women in the justice system. Their findings point to the ...

Recommended for you

Galactic center visualization delivers star power

March 21, 2019

Want to take a trip to the center of the Milky Way? Check out a new immersive, ultra-high-definition visualization. This 360-movie offers an unparalleled opportunity to look around the center of the galaxy, from the vantage ...

Ultra-sharp images make old stars look absolutely marvelous

March 21, 2019

Using high-resolution adaptive optics imaging from the Gemini Observatory, astronomers have uncovered one of the oldest star clusters in the Milky Way Galaxy. The remarkably sharp image looks back into the early history of ...

When more women make decisions, the environment wins

March 21, 2019

When more women are involved in group decisions about land management, the group conserves more—particularly when offered financial incentives to do so, according to a new University of Colorado Boulder study published ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.