An engineer's perspective on using silver against microbes

April 13, 2017 by Silke Schmidt, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Disposable hospital gowns are ubiquitous, but leave a lasting environmental legacy in landfills. Nanoscale silver-coated reusable gowns may be an alternative. Credit: Bryce Richter

Humans have appreciated silver's antimicrobial activity for millennia. Hippocrates used the precious metal for wound dressings while the pioneers of the American frontier placed coins in their water to guard against bacteria and algae.

But it takes 21st-century technology to push the amount of silver needed to combat disease-causing microbes into the nanoscale realm—something like a sheet of paper divided by 100,000. As researchers explore these limits, they are walking a fine line between silver's desirable properties and its potential toxicity to the environment.

A perfect case in point is a recent question that Andrea Hicks, an assistant professor of civil and environmental engineering at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, and colleagues set out to answer: What is the environmental impact of nanoscale silver-coated reusable hospital gowns, compared to the single-use disposable gowns employed by 80 percent of our hospitals, when the goal is to reduce the incidence of hospital-acquired infections?

These nosocomial infections cause an estimated 99,000 deaths per year in the United States; combined with other forms of medical error, they are considered the third-biggest killer after heart attacks and cancer. "It's one of these silent things that most people don't think about," Hicks says. "But the rise of MRSA, or methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, a few years ago illustrates the importance of preventing hospital textiles from transmitting pathogens."

Since most nanosilver textiles lose some of their silver coating every time they're laundered, Hicks zoomed in on a novel technology that aims to solve this problem. "The nanosilver solution we studied is sold with a chemical linking agent," Hicks explains. "You put the silver and linking agent into an industrial washer, along with the reusable hospital gown, and it will re-coat the textile every time."

Hicks used a tool called life cycle assessment to model the energy required to produce the two types of hospital gown—silver-coated reusable versus disposable—and the energy needed to maintain and eventually dispose of them. The concept of "embodied energy" is a commonly used metric for comparing the environmental impact of different products.

Researchers evaluate the amount of silver needed to inhibit the growth of E. coli bacteria. Credit: Tatiana Zaikova, University of Oregon

After a single use, a disposable gown ends up in the landfill, while a reusable gown is laundered an average of 75 times before it is discarded. Taking into account the greater amount of energy needed to produce and maintain the reusable gown, Hicks found the break-even point, or environmental parity, to be about 12 wearings.

"After 12 uses, the reusable gown has a lower environmental impact than the disposable gown," Hicks says. "The longer it is in use, the greater the difference will be."

The exact difference depends on how often the silver has to be reapplied to maintain its antibacterial properties. For the current study, the researchers estimated this quantity from the amount of silver needed to inhibit the growth of E. coli, one of the best-characterized human bacteria. The environmental parity point would likely change if other pathogens were considered.

The also depends on the chemical form in which silver is released during the 's use phase. From the wastewater treatment plant, the laundry water is ultimately discharged into a natural body of water. The researchers assumed a worst-case scenario of ionic silver—more toxic to fish and other aquatic organisms than silver chloride or silver sulfite—being released at that time.

While the environmental scale tipped in favor of nano-enabled reusable gowns under these assumptions, Hicks considers it premature to endorse their large-scale adoption. "We need to better understand how well they protect against hospital-acquired infections and how to prevent the from harming the environment or our own bodies before deciding whether the benefits outweigh the convenience and lower cost of disposable gowns," she says.

Hicks plans to pursue these questions in future work, but won't limit herself to nanosilver textiles. "I enjoy studying novel consumer technology, whether it is used in textiles, plastic containers, coffee pods or light bulbs, because estimating a new product's environmental legacy is an important aspect of bringing it to market," she says.

Explore further: Rampant use of antibacterial nanosilver is a resistance risk

Related Stories

Rampant use of antibacterial nanosilver is a resistance risk

March 31, 2017

Researchers at the University of Technology Sydney warn that the broad-spectrum antimicrobial effectiveness of silver is being put at risk by the widespread and inappropriate expansion of nanosilver use in medical and consumer ...

The impact of anti-odor clothing on the environment

March 30, 2016

Anti-odor athletic clothes containing silver nanoparticles have gained a foothold among exercise buffs, but questions have arisen over how safe and effective they are. Now scientists report in ACS' journal Environmental Science ...

Knocking nanoparticles off the socks

October 28, 2009

Scientists in Switzerland are reporting results of one of the first studies on the release of silver nanoparticles from laundering those anti-odor, anti-bacterial socks now on the market. Their findings, scheduled for the ...

Nanosilver and the future of antibiotics

May 27, 2015

Precious metals like silver and gold have biomedical properties that have been used for centuries, but how do these materials effectively combat the likes of cancer and bacteria without contaminating the patient and the environment?

Recommended for you

Scientists create gold nanoparticles in water

April 19, 2018

An experiment that, by design, was not supposed to turn up anything of note instead produced a "bewildering" surprise, according to the Stanford scientists who made the discovery: a new way of creating gold nanoparticles ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (3) Apr 13, 2017
Seems to me that the best solution is to recover the silver from the wash water. Adding a bit of (table) salt will drive the silver to either metal or AgCl which is insoluble. (Technically it is very slightly soluble, but the presence of chloride ions from the salt should push the silver and silver chloride in solution below nanograms/liter.)

Now filter the precipitate which will contain silver, silver chloride, fibers from the gown, and mostly organic dirt. Pyrolysis (burning) can recover the silver. In a hospital situation, I'd expect the washing and precipitate collection to be done on site, with the precipitate sent off site for further processing. There might be an ion exchange process cheaper than pyrolysis for recovering the silver, but I doubt it.

Would the precipitate need to be handled as a biohazard? Probably good practice to do so, but with that much silver and silver chloride, infection risk seems remote.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.