Analyzing how ISIS recruits through social media

June 16, 2016
Credit: University of Miami

A team of University of Miami researchers has developed a model to identify behavioral patterns among serious online groups of ISIS supporters that could provide cyber police and other anti-terror watchdogs a roadmap to their activity and indicators when conditions are ripe for the onset of real-world attacks.

The researchers, who identified and analyzed second-by-second online records of 196 pro-ISIS groups operating during the first eight months of 2015, found that even though most of the 108,000-plus individual members of these self-organized groups probably never met, they had a striking ability to adapt and extend their online longevity, increase their size and number, reincarnate when shut down—and inspire "lone wolves" with no history of extremism to carry out horrific attacks like the nation's deadliest mass shooting at a gay nightclub in Orlando this week.

"It was like watching crystals forming. We were able to see how people were materializing around certain social groups; they were discussing and sharing information—all in real-time," said Neil Johnson, a physicist in the College of Arts and Sciences who uses the laws of physics to study the of not only particles but people. "The question is: Can there be a signal of how people are coming collectively together to do something without a proper system in place?"

The answer, according to the study, "New online ecology of adversarial aggregates: ISIS and beyond," to be published in the journal Science on June 17, is yes. Generalizing a mathematical equation commonly used in physics and chemistry to the development and growth of ad hoc pro-ISIS groups, Johnson and his research team witnessed the daily interactions that drove online support for these groups, or "aggregates," and how they coalesced and proliferated prior to the onset of real-world campaigns.

The researchers suggest that by concentrating just on these relatively few groups of serious followers—those that discuss operational details like routes for financing and avoiding drone strikes— and other anti-terrorist watchdogs could monitor their buildup and transitions and thwart the potential onset of a burst of violence.

"This removes the guess work. With that road map, law enforcement can better navigate what is going on, who is doing what, while state security agencies can better monitor what might be developing," Johnson said. "So the message is: Find the aggregates—or at least a representative portion of them—and you have your hand on the pulse of the entire organization, in a way that you never could if you were to sift through the millions of Internet users and track specific individuals, or specific hashtags," Johnson said.

While the Johnson team concentrated on the ecology of collective behavior, not on single individuals, he said their roadmap could eventually help security officials track individuals like Omar Mateen, who claimed allegiance to ISIS and other extremist groups while killing 49 people and wounding 53 others at Orlando's Pulse nightclub early Sunday. Authorities say the New York-born Florida man was a lone actor who was radicalized online.

"Our research suggests that any online 'lone wolf' actor will only truly be alone for short periods of time," Johnson said. "As a result of the coalescence process that we observe in the online activity, any such lone wolf was either recently in an aggregate or will soon be in another one. With time, we would be able to track the trajectories of individuals through this ecology of aggregates."

For the study, Johnson and his research team monitored pro-ISIS groups on VKontakte, the largest online social networking service in Europe, which is based in Russia and has more than 350 million users from multiple cultures who speak multiple languages. Unlike on Facebook, which very quickly shuts down these groups, they are able to survive longer on VKontakte.

The researchers began their online search of pro-ISIS chatter manually, identifying specific social media hashtags, in multiple languages, which they used as "signals" to trace the more serious groups. Study co-author Stefan Wuchty, a computer science professor in the College of Arts and Sciences and member of the Center for Computational Science, compared the hashtag search to throwing a stone in a lake, watching the ripples, then following each one.

UM researchers studied the connection and communication of ISIS-supporting online social media groups, such as this one, on VKontakte, Europe's largest online social networking service, based in Russia. Credit: University of Miami

The hashtags were tracked to the online groups, and the data was fed into a software system that mounted the search; the results were repeated until the chase lead back to groups previously traced in the system. The mathematical equation Johnson and his team borrowed from chemistry and physics illustrated the fluctuation of online groups and pointed to possible predictions.

"The mathematics perfectly describes what we saw in real-time—how big and quickly these online groups grew and how quickly they were shut down by agencies or other monitoring groups," Johnson said.

As cyber police or other anti-terror entities got better at shutting down the groups, Johnson and his team watched the groups reincarnate by changing their names and identities, or shutting themselves down and going quiet, as if they were in stealth mode, only to reappear under a different identity later.

"Much of the scientific community is focusing on different explanations as to why social media is so important, and I think we found research that presents a kind of crystallization method, looking at the dynamics of these groups and how they crystalize, appear, and morph into other groups."

Johnson and his team's quest to distinguish serious pro-ISIS support from casual chatter began largely by coincidence in 2014, when he was working on a grant from the U.S. Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Activity to develop a model for predicting unrest or mass protest based on online activity. Just as that grant was concluding, ISIS emerged on the world stage, becoming a feared and familiar household name after the beheading of one then another U.S. journalist on camera. More would follow.

The second journalist to lose his life in such a ghastly fashion, Miami native Steven Sotloff, has ties to the University of Miami. To honor their son's work overseas, his parents established the 2Lives: Steven Joel Sotloff Memorial Foundation, which awarded its first Steven Joel Sotloff Memorial Endowed Scholarship to a UM student in the School of Communication.

Explore further: Data mining of Twitter posts can help identify when people become sympathetic to groups like ISIS

More information: DOI: 10.1126/science.aaf0675 "New online ecology of adversarial aggregates: ISIS and beyond," Science, http://science.sciencemag.org/cgi/doi/10.1126/science.aaf0675

Related Stories

ISIS propaganda collected in real time

May 27, 2016

University of Exeter experts will collect large amounts of propaganda put on the internet by Islamic State terrorists in real time to understand how it radicalises people.

Why you can't shut down the Internet

December 17, 2015

Donald Trump says the government must work with "brilliant people" in Silicon Valley to keep violent extremists offline, even if it means shutting down parts of the Internet.

Recommended for you

The oldest plesiosaur was a strong swimmer

December 14, 2017

Plesiosaurs were especially effective swimmers. These long extinct "paddle saurians" propelled themselves through the oceans by employing "underwater flight"—similar to sea turtles and penguins. Paleontologist from the ...

2 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Otto_Szucks
1 / 5 (2) Jun 16, 2016
What? No mention of psychological factors such as the influence of radicalized Imams who preach hate of anyone who isn't Muslim and doesn't live the Sharia lifestyle. Also, the inability to assimilate into western culture due to a sense of being socially stigmatized because of differences of opinion/ideology and upbringing?

This study appears to be saying that these groups, and possible individuals, are all so predictable that their movements are following a special math formula that allows these groups to be tracked quite easily. If the formula was working so well, then how did Omar Mateen somehow slip through the cracks?
Da Schneib
5 / 5 (1) Jun 17, 2016
This is quite important research, but unfortunately law enforcement is extremely conservative and unlikely to follow up on it.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.