Encryption fears for law enforcement overblown: study

February 1, 2016
Credit: Symantec

Encrypted communication is making law enforcement and counterterrorism investigations more difficult, but fears of "going dark" are overblown, a study said Monday.

The by Harvard University's Berkman Center said that despite efforts to boost encryption in smartphone and online services, investigations still can gain access to data in many circumstances.

The study sought to evaluate claims by US and that encryption is leading to a situation where they are unable to obtain data even with a legitimate warrant—a scenario described by some as "going dark."

"We question whether the 'going dark' metaphor accurately describes the state of affairs," the report said.

"Are we really headed to a future in which our ability to effectively surveil criminals and bad actors is impossible? We think not."

The researchers acknowledged that it has become increasingly difficult to get data from encrypted smartphones powered by software Apple or Google software.

But they also pointed out a distinction between data "at rest" on smart devices and in transmission.

"The distinction is important because an overwhelming percentage of Internet users communicate through web-based services, such as webmail, instant messages, and that are not end-to-end encrypted," the report said.

"In the course of an investigation, government officials can intercept communications and seek access to stored communications held by these intermediaries by obtaining a warrant, court order, or subpoena, provided that the company is capable of producing the information sought," it added.

The encryption debate has heated up in the United States and other countries in light of concerns raised by FBI and National Security Agency officials who claim investigations are being hindered by encryption.

US presidential candidates and others have argued for solutions that could allow encrypted data to be delivered with an appropriate warrant.

But the Berkman report said that "short of a form of government intervention in technology that appears contemplated by no one outside of the most despotic regimes, communication channels resistant to surveillance will always exist."

It also noted that for , "we must consider whether providing access to encrypted communications to help prevent terrorism and investigate crime would also increase our vulnerability to cyber espionage and other threats."

The researchers said that despite the latest encryption efforts, many software systems are "fragmented" and that a lack of coordination will leave open some avenues for investigation.

The report said that with the number of connected devices on the rise, "this has the potential to drastically change surveillance. The still images, video, and audio captured by these devices may enable real-time intercept and recording with after-the-fact access."

"The going dark metaphor suggests that communications are becoming steadily out of reach—an aperture is closing, and once closed we are blind," the report concluded.

"This does not capture the current state and trajectory of technological development."

Explore further: Attacks revive debate on encryption, surveillance

Related Stories

Attacks revive debate on encryption, surveillance

November 17, 2015

The deadly Paris attacks have reignited debate on encrypted communications by terror cells and whether law enforcement and intelligence services are "going dark" in the face of new technologies.

Data encryption in sharp focus after deadly attacks

December 12, 2015

With renewed focus on how encrypted messages can be used to plot terrorist attacks, President Barack Obama's administration is stepping up pressure on the tech sector to help in the battle.

Making sense of the encryption debate

December 22, 2015

Last week, candidates in both the Republican and Democratic presidential debates offered some interesting views about the Internet. Whether it was Donald Trump suggesting that parts of the Internet be closed, saying "I would ...

CIA worked to break Apple encryption: report

March 10, 2015

The Central Intelligence Agency has been working for years to break encryption on Apple devices, to spy on communications of iPhone and iPad users, a report said Tuesday.

FBI chief urges 'robust debate' on encryption

July 6, 2015

FBI Director James Comey called Monday for public debate on the use of encrypted communications, saying Americans may not realize how radical groups and criminals are using the technology.

Recommended for you

Microbes help turn Greek yogurt waste into fuel

December 13, 2017

Consumers across the world enjoy Greek yogurt for its taste, texture, and protein-packed punch. Reaching that perfect formula, however, generates large volumes of food waste in the form of liquid whey. Now researchers in ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Feb 01, 2016
Personally I could couldn't care less about gov snoops being hindered by encryption. People's personal messages are none of the Gov's business anyway.

If they want to arrest someone with OR without reason and hold them illegally forever they can already do it thinks to that Patriot act and the other same type of laws passed since then. They have already bypassed every constitution right we have and have ever had and there is very little we can do about it since it's being done by the people we put into office.
not rated yet Feb 01, 2016
All rules have more in common with each-other than their respective steeple. It follows that the ruled are the ultimate enemy for the powers that be

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.