What to expect from the next generation of Windows

July 11, 2014 by David Tuffley
Windows 8 is loved and hated in equal measure. So what will Windows 9 do differently? Credit: Microsoft Sweden/Flickr, CC BY-SA

The tech world is abuzz with speculation on what Microsoft is planning for the next generation of its operating system to replace Windows 8.

It was always going to be difficult to create an operating system that bridged the gap between the mouse and keyboard-driven desktop PCs and the huge market of touchscreen devices.

That was the challenge that Windows 8 was created to meet.

But when it was first released in 2012, customer reaction was extreme – people either loved it or hated it.

The Windows 8.1 upgrade was a major improvement through the creation of profiles for different hardware platforms from desktop to tablet, but strangely this has not translated into widespread uptake.

Slow to no uptake

By July 2014, Windows 8.1 had only 6.61% of the total PC operating system market, while Windows 8 had even less at 5.93%.

Windows 7 on the other hand, the version that 8 was meant to replace, is going strong at 50.55%.

It seems that many users who until recently had been running Windows XP – until Microsoft ended its support this April – decided to move up to Windows 7 instead of 8.

The reason people are avoiding the later version might have something to do with the perception that every other version of Windows is something of a dud.

Skipping generations

Observers have commented on the pattern that the good versions of Windows skip a generation – Windows 95 good, Windows Millennium not so good, Windows XP good, Windows Vista not so good, Windows 7 good, Windows 8 not so good.

If the pattern holds true, the next version of Windows is likely to be good. But why does this pattern exist?

Producing a rock-solid operating system is an expensive and time-consuming business. Getting your products to market where they can generate revenue is a strong incentive for developers to release software before it is fully debugged.

Windows 95 was one of the ‘good’ ones.

When you own more than 90% of the PC market globally, you might even be able to get away with having your users debug your software and pay for the pleasure.

While Windows 8.1 Update is not a whole new version, it would certainly seem to be the version that Microsoft should have released from the beginning instead of the half-baked touchscreen OS that so incurred the wrath of desktop and laptop users.

Project Threshold – is this Windows 9?

So what goodies are we likely to see in the next version of Windows (codenamed Project Threshold) when it is released sometime in May or June of 2015?

Long-time Microsoft watcher and confidante Mary-Jo Foley says that Microsoft will do its best to persuade Windows 7 hold-outs to skip 8 and go directly to 9.

That's a tall order considering I've already pointed out that still more than half of all PCs in the world are currently running Windows 7.

Threshold is designed to win back the desktop and laptop users who are alienated by Windows 8.

These folks should be back in their comfort zone with Windows 9, where the user interface can be configured to work with whatever type of hardware you are using – desktop, laptop, ultra-book, smartphone or tablet.

In short, the look and feel of the OS will suit the hardware type.

If you run Threshold (Windows 9) on a desktop PC, you can have the familiar Windows Desktop interface that lets you to run existing applications.

Hybrid devices that can operate in both desktop and touchscreen modes will support being toggled between the Metro-tile interface (seen for the first time with Windows 8) and the familiar Windows desktop.

At the smartphone and tablet end of the market, there will not be a desktop environment at all, though it will allow you to run applications side by side.

In the meantime, around August or September 2014, we are likely to see the release of 8.1 update 2. This should be the last major release before Windows 9 emerges in the northern Spring of 2015.

The Windows ecosystem – PC, phone and Xbox

Threshold will extend to Xbox in an effort to create a common user experience across all elements of the Windows ecosystem.

That common look and feel will be based around the Metro tile interface, except in the case of the desktop/laptop user who chooses to configure their system otherwise.

The Windows approach contrasts with the way Apple has kept its Mac OS, iOS and Apple TV recognisably different, though Apple achieve a degree of cross platform integration by means of services like iTunes and iCloud.

What do people really want?

Ultimately, what most computer users want is a system that is intuitive and well adapted to their needs, something that works seamlessly, something that allows them do their work and have their fun without unduly drawing attention to itself or wasting their time.

Some versions of Windows manage to approach this goal. Other versions fall short – and that is not okay for a company with the resources of Microsoft.

When you own such a large share of the market you owe it to your paying customers to give them the best possible experience, every time. Here's hoping Windows 9 manages that.

Explore further: China rules out Windows 8 for government computers

Related Stories

Windows 'Blue' set to preview June 26

May 14, 2013

The tweaked version of Microsoft's operating system nicknamed Windows Blue will be previewed on June 26 and will be a free update for users as Windows 8.1, the company said Tuesday.

Windows 8.1 set for October 18 release

August 14, 2013

A tweaked version of Microsoft's Windows operating system which restores the "Start" button missed by users and updates other features will be available on October 18, the company said Wednesday.

Recommended for you

New method analyzes corn kernel characteristics

November 17, 2017

An ear of corn averages about 800 kernels. A traditional field method to estimate the number of kernels on the ear is to manually count the number of rows and multiply by the number of kernels in one length of the ear. With ...

Optically tunable microwave antennas for 5G applications

November 16, 2017

Multiband tunable antennas are a critical part of many communication and radar systems. New research by engineers at the University of Bristol has shown significant advances in antennas by using optically induced plasmas ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

4.7 / 5 (3) Jul 11, 2014
Yeah, I'll wait and see. The only reason that I use windows now is that my family also uses this PC and my last attempt to get them into the Linux world led to a dual boot scenario and a lot of complaining. I refuse to use Win 8 of any flavor and also refuse to use Apple because **** Apple.
5 / 5 (3) Jul 11, 2014
The next time I upgrade a PC, Windows will be out the door. Between Ubuntu and Chrome, I see no reason to keep paying a company that has no concept of software secure by design, and won't address security issues in a comprehensive and thorough manner.

I've tracked the patches and fixes for Windows XP and Server 2003R2 since they came out. "Security Patches" have replaced more than half of the original dlls, and new bugs are still surfacing. Windows 7 isn't much better, and it's been out for half the time.
5 / 5 (3) Jul 11, 2014
ROFL !! So Microsoft are going to do with 9 what they should have done with 8.0 ? Set a 'look and feel' option to match the environment ??

Ooh, that was difficult...

I wonder what they're going to do about their focus groups who fawned on 'Metro', and completely ignored the traditional 'desktop' environment...

FWIW, while I was wandering around a well-known PC superstore today, an assistant tried to interest me in a nice new Surface Tablet they had. 'Uh, is that KitKat ?' No, it is Windows 8.'

Well, I now know why 'Cloud Computing Is The New Black' for the portable Windows' platform-- With Windows on board, there's no room for serious application programs.

Really, it has come full circle from eg Win95, when most PCs lacked enough RAM to run big appplication programs in 'main memory', so spent 2/3 of time thrashing their diminutive hard drive. Ony, for the Surface, it will be thrashing your WiFi Cloud connection...

Cue major take-up of those rechargeable, wireless hard-drives...
4 / 5 (2) Jul 12, 2014
In the best of all worlds, users wouldn't even care what operating system was driving their device, because it would never do anything that would cause it to be noticed. As a user I should care about the apps I use, not the operating system. Of course that view is antithetical to Microsoft's business model.

Ditto separating the UI (GUI) from the underlying kernel. Microsoft could uncouple them; it chooses instead to make them monolithic. Outside of changing the GUI, I wonder what they do to "improve" their next versions of Windows that could not be similarly done by merely updating libraries (DLLs).

I recognize it would be hard to make revenue of either of these otherwise pragmatic actions. Thus we users get this periodic extortion to upgrade the whole OS.
Jul 12, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
not rated yet Jul 13, 2014
I will wait a year after 9 is released before I decide (whether) to upgrade my 7.
However, MS should realize that these are not "the good old days" - I also use Linux and Android and will not be replacing either with MS.
not rated yet Jul 13, 2014
While they're reverting the trad desk-top for us multi-screen, power users, perhaps they could fix that stupid, beige 'folder thumbnail' that half-hides your designated folder image ?

Worse, you must fire up IrfanView (or equivalent) and flip half your folder images because they are accented left instead of right. And then Windows refuses to notice you've done so...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.