The new paradox: Mobile but sedentary

June 2, 2014
The new paradox: Mobile but sedentary

The distance people travel for professional purposes is increasing. Scientists are taking a closer look at these 21st century nomads, uncovering the reasons behind the long kilometers and the consequences on commuters' lives.

It's the crack of dawn and they're already behind the wheel, in the train or at the airport. Some spend several nights a week in a furnished studio in another city or a suburban hotel. These heavy business travelers ("grands mobiles" in French) are the21st century's western nomads. They are often quite attached to their homes, but have been uprooted professionally, sometimes by choice, sometimes not.

Based on a European study conducted in 2007 and 2011, EPFL researchers have sketched the profiles of these travelers: people who spend more than two hours a day commuting and bi-residents who spend more than 60 nights a year away from their primary residence.

These kinds of commuters are not outliers any more: about a quarter of the European population falls into this description. Almost half of those working on the continent experience a period of heavy professional travel during the course of their careers. Improvements in transport availability, tight job markets, rising land values, and regional disparities are all factors that have played a role in the growth of this phenomenon.

Mobility is spatial rather than relational

Other factors not associated with work also play a role in choosing these kinds of commuting solutions. "Heavy commuters are often very sedentary; they're spatially mobile, but not socially mobile," explains Stéphanie Vincent-Geslin, who led the research study with Emmanuel Ravalet in EPFL's Urban Sociology Laboratory. "Moving to a new place, that's a huge change. When you live somewhere, you develop a network that you don't necessarily want to leave. These roots play a big part in the choices these commuters make."

Long distance commuting touches every socio-professional category, city and country dwellers alike. But it doesn't affect them all in the same way, according to research funded by the Forum Vies Mobiles, a think tank of the French National Railway system (SNCF). These differences depend on individuals' so-called "motility," or their potential for mobility. Can I manage—materially, financially, practically – a long-distance commute? To what extent can I deal with the unexpected, organize the commute, and spend my time productively while commuting? "Those who do best in this situation are those who have the most possibility to stop doing it," says Ravalet.

The new normal

Reflecting the growing uncertainties in society, heavy commuting is becoming more and more accepted – but not without social consequences. Women are choosing to wait to start a family, and when they do take the plunge, they have fewer children. Single parents are often forced into long commutes just to make ends meet. Singles start commuting and then, habituated, have a strong inclination to continue this kind of lifestyle. And finally, couples in which one partner is regularly absent run almost twice the risk of separating. "Heavy commuting goes way beyond the issue of transport," conclude the researchers. This fall they will be publishing a short book highlighting the portraits of six fictitious .

Explore further: Work commutes getting longer and gender differences persist

Related Stories

Work commutes getting longer and gender differences persist

October 30, 2013

On average, Swedish men and women have different commuting habits. Despite an increasingly gender-equal society, traditional household patterns are changing very slowly. The regional enlargement in many parts of the country ...

Longer commutes disadvantage African-American workers

February 15, 2014

African-Americans spend more time than any other group getting to work and in some cases spend about 15 minutes more a day than whites commuting, according to research by Virginia Parks, associate professor at the University ...

New study gives insight into crowd-sourced commuting

December 11, 2012

The New Cities Foundation today unveiled the results of its Connected Commuting Task Force, charged with helping cities all over the world better understand how real-time social networking among commuters can enhance the ...

Commuting - bad for your health?

October 31, 2011

A mobile workforce can help improve a country's economy but the effects of commuting on the health of commuters and on the costs to industry in terms of sick days is largely unknown. From a commuter's point of view, the advantages ...

Recommended for you

Averaging the wisdom of crowds

December 12, 2017

The best decisions are made on the basis of the average of various estimates, as confirmed by the research of Dennie van Dolder and Martijn van den Assem, scientists at VU Amsterdam. Using data from Holland Casino promotional ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.