The conceptual framework for measuring the emergence of life

March 10, 2014 by Johnny Bontemps
On early Earth, day and night cycles may have jump-started the evolution of prebiotic chemical networks. Credit: Don Dixon/

The story of life's origin is one of the great unsolved mysteries of science. The puzzle boils down to bridging the gap between two worlds—chemistry and biology. We know how molecules behave, and we know how cells work. But we still don't know how a soup of lifeless molecules could have given rise to the first living cells.

"It's a really tough problem," says Sara Walker, an astrobiologist at Arizona State University. But she thinks it can be cracked. In fact, she believes there may be a way to measure the transition from non-life to life.

Last month, Dr. Walker presented the inaugural lecture for the NASA Astrobiology NPP seminar series. In a talk titled "Information Hierarchies, Chemical Evolution and the Transition from Non-Living to Living Matter," she described some of the models she developed as a NASA postdoctoral fellow.

These models set up the conceptual framework for measuring the emergence of life, a goal she's now pursuing as an assistant professor at the School of Earth and Space Science and the Beyond Center for Fundamental Concepts in Science at ASU.

She began her talk with a quote from the Harvard chemist George Whitesides, which captured nicely the gap she is trying to bridge: "How remarkable is life?" he asked. "The answer is: very. Those of us who deal in networks of chemical reactions know nothing like it."

If it succeeds, Walker's approach could broaden our view of what life is, and help us figure out whether its emergence on Earth is merely a fluke or the product of some universal laws.

Getting to "Almost Life"

The first step is to jumpstart chemical evolution, and get a pool of lifeless molecules to form a basic chemical network. While at Georgia Tech, Walker and her colleagues developed a new model for chemical evolution based on the environment on early Earth.

"The idea is that the day and night cycles on early Earth may have driven the process," she explains.

The model starts out with monomers—or loose building blocks—and turns them into polymers. Bonds form during the day (during the dry phase) and break at night (during the wet phase). So the system goes over a constant process of building and destroying new chains of molecules.

Living systems are unique in the way they handle information. Genes determine the nature of proteins, but proteins and higher levels of organization also control gene expression. This two-ways flow of information is a hallmark of life. Credit: Jonathan Bailey, NHGRI

Over time, some of the chains may have a useful function. And because they benefit the system, they stay and are replicated by that cycling, serving as template for the formation of other polymers. Eventually, clusters of polymers begin to grow and interact with each other, until they give rise to a very basic chemical network. Eventually, that network evolves to a state Walker calls "almost life."

The Tipping Point

But how do we bridge the gap between lifeless chemical network and living biological system? "One of the things that's most distinctive about living systems is the way they handle information, and the way it's distributed in the system," Walker says.

According to her, the mystery of life's origins lies in the way these rudimentary chemical networks begin to process information. With that framework in mind, the transition to life becomes a well-defined event: a reversal in information flow.

Life is built upon a hierarchy of systems. At the bottom we have genes. Genes then code for proteins. Proteins direct the working of cells. Cells form tissues, which add up to organs, until we reach the level of the organism.

A hallmark of life is the way information flows between different levels of organization. In non-living systems, information flows from the bottom up—the properties of the individual parts determine the fate of the system.

But with living systems, that flow goes both ways. Not only genes dictate the nature of proteins which in turn affect the functioning of cells, tissues and organisms, but the behavior of proteins, cells, and organisms also control gene expression. This is what Walker calls "top-down control" or "top-down causation."

And to Walker, this transition—from information seeping upward only to information flowing both up and down—is the key to understanding life's origins. Put differently, the blueprint for building an organism isn't stored in its DNA only, but it's distributed in the state of the entire system.

And when it comes to basic chemical networks, Walker thinks, that distribution is something we could potentially measure.

Information in Formation

A potential candidate is a measure called "integrated information." Dr. Giulio Tononi, a neuroscientist at the University of Wisconsin, has shown that it's possible to calculate how much integrated information there is in a network, a quantity he has dubbed 'phi'.

Tononi is working on developing a theory of consciousness based on mathematics and information theory. But to Walker, the origin of life and the origin of consciousness are two related problems.

"The measure should apply equally to understanding the emergence of life from chemistry and to understanding the emergence of consciousness from neural networks," she says. "It's about the way the network is structured, and how it can use information to control its own dynamic."

"A thought you're having in your brain can control all the atoms in your body, and make you get up from a chair and move across the room. In the same way, a bacterial cell can respond to an environmental stimuli and organize all its chemistry accordingly to go after a food source."

The goal is to take these insights and apply them to the puzzle of life's origin. In the end, Walker's approach could broaden our understanding of what is, and of how unique—or common—it might be in the universe.

Explore further: Researchers propose new way to look at the dawn of life

Related Stories

New Study Brings Scientists Closer to the Origin of RNA

December 24, 2013

( —One of the biggest questions in science is how life arose from the chemical soup that existed on early Earth. One theory is that RNA, a close relative of DNA, was the first genetic molecule to arise around 4 ...

First plastic cell with working organelle

January 15, 2014

For the first time, chemists have successfully produced an artificial cell containing organelles capable of carrying out the various steps of a chemical reaction. This was done at the Institute for Molecules and Materials ...

Cytoskeletons get a closer look

March 6, 2014

( —Rice University researchers have developed a theoretical approach to analyze the process by which protein building blocks form the biopolymer skeletons of living cells.

Recommended for you

Astronomers search for signs of life on Wolf 1061 exoplanet

January 19, 2017

Is there anybody out there? The question of whether Earthlings are alone in the universe has puzzled everyone from biologists and physicists to philosophers and filmmakers. It's also the driving force behind San Francisco ...

A catalog of habitable zone exoplanets

January 18, 2017

The last two decades have seen an explosion of detections of exoplanets, as the sensitivity to smaller planets has dramatically improved thanks especially to the Kepler mission. These discoveries have found that the frequency ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 16, 2014
Thermodynamics, within the framework of applicability, explains everything that happens in the world. To understand the origin of life and its evolution we should use the hierarchical thermodynamics and principle of substance stability. Interactions between different hierarchical levels of organization is defined by the thermodynamic "principle of substance stability" http://ru.scribd....-11-2011
Whydening Gyre
4 / 5 (1) Mar 16, 2014
This is the most crucial statement in the entire article.

And to Walker, this transition—from information seeping upward only to information flowing both up and down—is the key to understanding life's origins. Put differently, the blueprint for building an organism isn't stored in its DNA only, but it's distributed in the state of the entire system.

not rated yet Mar 27, 2014
Hierarchical thermodynamics solves the puzzle of life. The role of catalysis
not rated yet Mar 27, 2014
Origin of life and biological evolution
Molecules - "blocks of life" (nucleobases, amino acids, sugars, phosphates and other compounds) are produced as a result of chemical evolution in appropriate conditions in the various parts of the universe. These molecules are initial components in the synthesis of nucleic acids (DNA and RNA), proteins, biopolymers and other metabolites. Thermodynamic "principle of substance stability" is the driving force behind the selection of the most stable supramolecular structures in the presence of water. Thermodynamics provides a common code of life in the universe. Thermodynamics directs the chemical and the prebiotic (transitional) evolution. And then begins the Darwin's evolution. It (as well as the prebiotic evolution) is governed by the laws of hierarchical thermodynamics and the principle of substance stability. Generalized Gibbs equation at quasi-approximation can be applied to all hierarchical levels of living matter.
Int. J. Mol. Sci. 2006, 7, 98-110 http://www.mdpi.o...0098.pdf http://www.statem...ladyshev The role of catalysis:
Apr 04, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
not rated yet Apr 24, 2014
Life arises and exists where there are the appropriate conditions of the environment and the cyclic exchange of matter and energy.][/url]
During the formation of the most thermodynamically stable supramolecular structures in evolution, in accordance with the second law, Nature spontaneously uses predominantly the least thermodynamically stable molecules. http://gladysheve...ability/
Life: The simplest forms of life can occur in the water cycle on the planet.][/url]

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.