Pakistan's 'cyberwar' for control of the web

September 12, 2013 by Guillaume Lavallee
Pakistani computer users browse YouTube at an office in Quetta on December 29, 2012. In a dingy Internet cafe, Abdullah gets round the censors with one click and logs onto YouTube, officially banned for a year and at the heart of Pakistan's cyberwar for control of the web.

In a dingy Internet cafe, Abdullah gets round the censors with one click and logs onto YouTube, officially banned for a year and at the heart of Pakistan's cyberwar for control of the web.

On September 17, 2012 Islamabad blocked access to the popular after it aired a trailer for a low-budget American film deemed offensive to Islam and the Prophet Mohammed.

Pakistan summoned the most senior US diplomat in the country to protest against the "Innocence of Muslims", demanding that the film be removed and action taken against its producers.

A year later, the film is barely mentioned but YouTube, whose parent company is US multinational Google Inc, is still banned in Pakistan, as it is in China and Iran.

Pakistan is no stranger to censorship. Foreign television programmes deemed offensive are blocked. Films shown at cinemas are stripped of scenes considered too daring.

But the YouTube ban is in name only.

Internet users like Abdullah Raheem, a university student in Pakistan's cultural capital Lahore, can easily access the site through a simple proxy or Virtual Private Network (VPN).

"Most people who go to school or university know how to access YouTube, but not the rest of the population," says Abdullah.

Only 10 percent of Pakistan's estimated 180 million people have access to the Internet, one of the lowest rates in the world.

"This ban has no impact," says Abdullah, who still feels bad about logging onto YouTube. "As a Muslim, I'm ashamed... because the 'Innocence of Muslims' defiled Islam."

Pakistan blocked the site only after Google was unable to block access to the film because it has no antenna in the country.

Although Google's executive chairman Eric Schmidt defended hosting the film, the company did have the technology to block access to it in countries such as Egypt, India and Saudi Arabia.

Pakistani student Abdullah Raheem browsing YouTube at a internet cafe in Lahore on September 9, 2013. In a dingy Internet cafe, Abdullah gets round the censors with one click and logs onto YouTube, officially banned for a year and at the heart of Pakistan's cyberwar for control of the web.

But the Pakistani government didn't stop there. It then ordered that websites be monitored for "anti-Islam content".

The Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto, which specialises in Internet censorship, says Pakistan has used Canadian company Netsweeper to filter websites relating to human rights, sensitive religious topics and independent media.

The researchers say that pornographic content and political websites from Baluchistan, Pakistan's southwestern province gripped by separatist insurgency, are among those blocked.

Shortly after Pakistan's former military ruler Pervez Musharraf was arrested in April, Pakistan shut down access to a satirical song posted on YouTube's rival Vimeo that poked fun at the army.

But the song "Dhinak Dhinak" performed by the Beygairat Brigade, which is Urdu for Shameless Brigade, quickly went viral as Pakistani Internet users went through proxy VPNs to watch it.

"It is still creating waves. So I think they helped our popularity by banning that song," said the Brigade's lead singer Ali Aftab Saeed, 29.

Saeed believes that the authorities are bent on a wider campaign of Internet censorship, not just restricting access to items considered blasphemous in the conservative Muslim nation.

"We thought that they would try to ban just the link to that particular video ('Innocence of Muslims') but they instead banned the whole website (YouTube) and then they extended it to satire and people who discuss the role of military groups.

"So yes, it is a worrying situation," he told AFP.

Shahzad Ahmad, director of Internet rights campaign group, Bytes For All, also says that online censorship serves a wider political agenda than just shutting down blasphemous content.

A Pakistani cell phone user browses YouTube on his mobile phone in Quetta on December 29, 2012. In a dingy Internet cafe, Abdullah gets round the censors with one click and logs onto YouTube, officially banned for a year and at the heart of Pakistan's cyberwar for control of the web.
"The government is trying to curtail, limit and curb citizen freedom of expression," Ahmad told AFP.

He says citizens are waging a "" against Pakistani institutions who are blocking and filtering the Internet.

"There is a very clear defiance from users, particularly from the youth on government filtering," he told AFP.

Bytes For All has gone to court in Lahore, demanding an end to "illegal and illegitimate" censorship of the Internet.

The fight is vital to stop the government developing tools of censorship that threaten "the security and private live" of individuals, says Farieha Aziz, a member of the Bolo Bhi advocacy group that is closely following the case, which encompasses the YouTube ban.

Software surveillance FinFisher, developed by British company Gamma and able to access content on personal computers, has been detected recently on Pakistani servers.

Although it is unclear whether it has been deployed by Pakistan's own intelligence agencies or foreigners, the NSA scandal in the United States has heightened suspicions.

In Pakistan, the cyberwar has only just begun.

Explore further: Pakistan expected to unblock YouTube

Related Stories

Pakistan expected to unblock YouTube

December 29, 2012

Pakistan is expected to unblock access to the popular video sharing website YouTube on Saturday after taking measures to filter blasphemous material and pornography, a cabinet minister said.

Pakistan blocks Twitter over contentious tweets

May 20, 2012

(AP) -- Pakistan blocked the social networking website Twitter for much of Sunday because it refused to remove tweets considered offensive to Islam, said one of the country's top telecommunications officials.

YouTube extends film curb to Saudi Arabia

September 19, 2012

YouTube said Wednesday it extended its restrictions on a video sparking unrest in the Islamic world to Saudi Arabia, saying it is among countries where the film is considered illegal.

Pakistan lifts Facebook ban after page removed

May 31, 2010

(AP) -- Pakistan lifted a ban on Facebook on Monday after officials from the social networking site apologized for a page deemed offensive to Muslims and removed its contents, a top information technology official said.

Wanted: Censor for Pakistan's Internet

March 8, 2012

(AP) -- Pakistan is advertising for companies to install an Internet filtering system that could block up to 50 million Web addresses, alarming free speech activists who fear current censorship could become much more widespread.

Egypt court orders YouTube blocked for a month

February 9, 2013

A Cairo court on Saturday ordered the government to block access to the video-sharing website YouTube for 30 days for carrying an anti-Islam film that caused deadly riots across the world.

Recommended for you

Technology near for real-time TV political fact checks

January 18, 2019

A Duke University team expects to have a product available for election year that will allow television networks to offer real-time fact checks onscreen when a politician makes a questionable claim during a speech or debate.

Privacy becomes a selling point at tech show

January 7, 2019

Apple is not among the exhibitors at the 2019 Consumer Electronics Show, but that didn't prevent the iPhone maker from sending a message to attendees on a large billboard.

China's Huawei unveils chip for global big data market

January 7, 2019

Huawei Technologies Ltd. showed off a new processor chip for data centers and cloud computing Monday, expanding into new and growing markets despite Western warnings the company might be a security risk.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (6) Sep 15, 2013
The thought nazis rule religion...

Especially when it suits them.

I saw the blasphemous video - and thought, "What a crock of silly shit to wind yourself up over."

Only a bunch of complete fuckwit fundamentalists would react to that.....

And so they did - not only declaring THAT vid to be satans anus - but also chopping off access to the 999 million other silly to sublime videos on Youtube.

Religion is for shit heads - REALLY - they cause more problems than anything - the islam nazis fight with the non islams, the jew nazis fight with the non jews and the christian nazis fight with the non christians - and all the islam nazis, jew nazis and christian nazis fight with each other.

Shoot the lot of them.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.