Researchers find 'structure' in black hole accretion disk

Researchers find “structure” in black hole accretion disk
Simulation of the X-ray binary system Swift J1357.2-0933. In this view, the dips produced by the vertical structure are maxima. Credit: Gabriel Perez Diaz, Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias (Servicio MultiMedia)
(—A team of researchers working at the Astrophysical Institute of the Canary Islands has found evidence of a previously unknown structure in the accretion disk of a black hole that is part of an X-ray binary system. The structure, as they describe in their paper published in the journal Science, presents itself with a wave like movement through the disk, moving outward.

A binary system, is of course, one made of two components—sometimes two stars, others times as with Swift J1357.2, a star and a black hole—the remnant of a star that exploded. In the latter case, the binary is known as an X-ray because the accretion disk that develops between the two occasionally emits X-rays. The accretion disk is a mass of material that has been pulled from the star by the black hole. In this new research, the team has found evidence of a structure on the outer portion of the accretion disk that causes a dimming of the system—one that cannot be explained by the ' orbit around the system's , which in this case, is one of the shortest ever seen, just 2.8 hours. The dimming, the researchers report occurs sometimes as often as every few seconds.

Video showing a different point of view of the X-ray binary system. Credit: Gabriel Perez Diaz, Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias (Servicio MultiMedia)

The researchers don't know what the structure is, but have found that it does not demonstrate periodic variation, an indication that it's vertical, and that it is capable of hiding the black hole from view. They report also that it behaves like a wave, moving through the disk in an outward direction, which accounts for the rapid dimming.

Simulation of the X-ray binary system Swift J1357.2-0933. The system is formed by a "normal" star which is transferring material (through an accretion disc) into a black hole. The simulation starts with a top view of the system and then moves to perspective of the system as seen from Earth. The system has a large inclination which allowed the team to observe an obscuring vertical structure in the accretion disc. This structure produces eclipses or dips to the light coming from the inner parts of the disc (close to the black hole). In the top-left panel we see these dips. Moreover, the vertical structure moves outward with the days which produces an increase in the dip recurrence period as shown in the top-right panel. Credit: Gabriel Perez Diaz, Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias (Servicio MultiMedia)

That the structure appears capable of hiding the black hole from view is important because space researchers have been baffled by the apparent lack of that should be evident in observations made from Earth. After a half century of study and analysis, only 18 have been confirmed to exist in the and none of those have an eclipse that would cause X-ray emissions to be blocked. Scientists have theorized that many black holes cannot be seen due to the angle at which they exist relative to us—this new research suggests it could also be due to structures similar to the one observed in the of Swift J1357.2, blocking their X-ray emissions.

Explore further

Computer model shows strong magnetic fields may alter alignment of black hole accretion disks and plasma jets

More information: A Black Hole Nova Obscured by an Inner Disk Torus, Science, 1 March 2013: Vol. 339 no. 6123 pp. 1048-1051. DOI: 10.1126/science.1228222

Stellar-mass black holes (BHs) are mostly found in x-ray transients, a subclass of x-ray binaries that exhibit violent outbursts. None of the 50 galactic BHs known show eclipses, which is surprising for a random distribution of inclinations. Swift J1357.2−093313 is a very faint x-ray transient detected in 2011. On the basis of spectroscopic evidence, we show that it contains a BH in a 2.8-hour orbital period. Further, high–time-resolution optical light curves display profound dips without x-ray counterparts. The observed properties are best explained by the presence of an obscuring toroidal structure moving outward in the inner disk, seen at very high inclination. This observational feature should play a key role in models of inner accretion flows and jet collimation mechanisms in stellar-mass BHs.

Journal information: Science

© 2013

Citation: Researchers find 'structure' in black hole accretion disk (2013, March 1) retrieved 26 May 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Mar 01, 2013
maybe its geodesic warping of space due the spin of the black hole that moves like a wave throught the disc from the inside out, the combination of angular speed of the black hole and certain width the disc could produce a set of periodicities/phase modulation that lead to a standing wave on the edge of the disc, expect more ripplings in discs to be discovered soon, and invert relationships to be found to establish the size and the shape of the disc.

Mar 01, 2013
While speculation in this article abounds, I can add my own: that the grey hole is in an active state, ejecting new matter in a non-periodic manner, until it reaches a new thermal equilibrium. Presumably, such ejections would have a large radial component, as suggested in the article.

Mar 01, 2013
That video speaks a thousand words - I love it when a visual so exactly describes the observation measurements and the theory as to why that is. Great job!

Amazing video. It makes total sense.

Mar 01, 2013
Videos no longer work.

Mar 01, 2013
Notice the similarities, um damn near identical? to side-on views of "Spiral Galaxies".

Citation: Sombrero Galaxy.

Mar 03, 2013
A version of the Corral-Santana et al paper published in Science has been posted here:

Mar 07, 2013
Notice the similarities, um damn near identical? to side-on views of "Spiral Galaxies".

Citation: Sombrero Galaxy.

There's this thing called gravity...

Mar 08, 2013
Apparently the Researchers haven't read the important Dark Star research by Korben Dallas.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more