Drastic change needed to tackle China smog, experts say (Update)

January 15, 2013 by Neil Connor
A cyclist wearing a mask crosses a road in severe pollution in Beijing on January 12, 2013. China has cleaned up its air before but experts say that if it wants to avoid the kind of smog that choked the country this week, it must overhaul an economy fuelled by heavily polluting coal and car use.

China has cleaned up its air before but experts say that if it wants to avoid the kind of smog that choked the country this week, it must overhaul an economy fuelled by heavily polluting coal and car use.

Several days of hazardous air quality across large swathes of northern China triggered an emergency response which saw schoolchildren kept indoors, factories closed and government cars parked.

Experts are urging authorities to take firmer action to confront the consequences of China's rapid industrialisation—and the spending habits of the middle classes created by its economic boom.

The calls for cleaner air come after new Communist Party leader Xi Jinping said the government would strive to meet demands for "more comfortable living conditions, and a more beautiful environment".

China began releasing pollution data last year, a move which observers say triggered a huge backlash against the smog—both from a newly aware public who took to Internet message boards in droves, and from normally partisan state media.

As the noxious haze blanketed Beijing this week, driving sales of face masks and air purifiers through the roof, state news agency Xinhua said the party's promise to build a beautiful China was "in jeopardy".

"A country with a brown sky and hazardous air is obviously not beautiful," it said in a commentary.

When the eyes of the world were on Beijing for the 2008 Olympics, the city implemented strict measures for two months or more that reduced toxic emissions by 60 percent.

Car users could only drive every other day, construction work ceased and factories were shut down.

Such steps were "extreme resolutions which are not sustainable", said professor John Cai, director of the Centre for Healthcare Management and Policy at the China Europe International Business School in Shanghai.

"What needs to happen is for the government to take long-term action by centralising the heating systems, so that individual families in rural areas do not burn coal, and also cutting down on car use in the city," he told AFP.

China would face "short-term economic losses" from sweeping changes, Cai said, but the government should look to the long term.

A graphic showing air pollution readings in Beijing. China has cleaned up its air before but experts say that if it wants to avoid the kind of smog that choked the country this week, it must overhaul an economy fuelled by heavily polluting coal and car use.

Growing car use has been both an important driver of the economy and an overt symbol of China's mounting wealth.

But with five million vehicles already in Beijing and 20,000 more each month, Cai said addressing it was essential, suggesting owners be forced to pay high licence fees on each vehicle to reduce emissions.

Tackling coal use is even more problematic. While families might be encouraged onto a central heating system, 79 percent of China's electricity is generated by the fuel, according to the World Coal Association.

Much of that is the low-grade "dirty" kind rather than the "clean" coal now favoured in many Western markets.

"Beijing has taken emergency measures to tackle the current pollution, but in the long term we need a region-wide policy to cut coal use to make the air quality better," said Zhou Rong, climate and energy campaigner at Greenpeace.

A former senior official in the London mayor's office, John Ross, who is now a visiting professor at Jiaotong University in Shanghai, drew comparisons with the "Great Smog" of 1952 in the British capital.

The pollution was eventually cleared after legislation forced power stations out of the city and banned many smoke-emitting fuels.

"The lesson from London (is) industrial pollution can be eliminated but it takes strict laws, heavy investment and over 10 years," Ross said on his account on Sina Weibo, a version of Twitter.

Beijing said in May that it would get rid of 1,200 high-polluting enterprises by 2015. It has set up bicycle rental kiosks to try to ease congestion.

But implementing strict lasting controls requires firm political will from China's new leaders, Cai said.

Given Xi's professed stand in favour of an environmental clean-up, he anticipated "substantial, radical changes" within two years.

Premier-to-be Li Keqiang noted on Tuesday the need for at least some signs of progress.

"Solving the problem will also be a long-term process but we must see some achievements," China National Radio quoted him on its website as saying.

Li said tackling the issue required greater enforcement of environmental protections as well as increased public awareness.

Many ordinary people, however, did not seem optimistic.

"Air pollution is an emergency as severe as an earthquake, flood or chemical spill," said one Weibo poster.

"The government needs to mobilise all of society to solve this problem—not just its environmental protection department."

Explore further: Beijing air pollution 'hazardous': US embassy

Related Stories

Beijing air pollution 'hazardous': US embassy

October 31, 2011

Air pollution in Beijing reached "hazardous" levels on Monday, the US embassy said, as thick smog blanketed the city for the third day running, forcing the closure of highways and cancellation of flights.

Hundreds of flights cancelled due to Beijing smog

December 5, 2011

Beijing authorities cancelled hundreds of flights and shut motorways on Monday as thick smog descended on the Chinese capital, reducing visibility at one of the world's busiest airports.

Beijing to get rid of 1,200 polluting enterprises

May 9, 2012

Authorities in Beijing said Wednesday they plan to get rid of 1,200 high-polluting enterprises by 2015 to improve air quality in the Chinese capital, one of the world's most polluted cities.

Recommended for you

Rainfall's natural variation hides climate change signal

February 22, 2018

New research from The Australian National University (ANU) and ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science suggests natural rainfall variation is so great that it could take a human lifetime for significant climate ...

Seasonal patterns in the Amazon explained

February 22, 2018

Environmental scientists at the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Brookhaven National Laboratory have led an international collaboration to improve satellite observations of tropical forests.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jan 15, 2013
Maybe they need to send more people to Tibet. Better yet, annex another country and move the population there too.
not rated yet Jan 15, 2013
China would face "short-term economic losses" from sweeping changes, Cai said, but added the government should look to the long term.

That's a real bind they find themselve in.
China has been growing rapidly. But inflation has alsow been going up steadily. Currently they're almost dependent on big growth numbers.
So setting up regulations that would dampen growth without stopping inflation may backfire.
I hope they find a good middle road. But in the end it will certainly mean the end of cheap trinkets from China for us.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.