Banning plastic bags-does it make a difference?
This week the Toronto city council revisits the citys plastic bag surcharge, which requires retailers to charge customers five cents per bag. We originally spoke to Professor Douglas Stephan of Chemistry in August 2009 about the then-new law. This interview has been updated.
How bad are plastic bags for the environment?
The issue is that the vast majority of plastic bagsexcept for the paint, the coatings that are on them for the brandingwill not biodegrade. These are polyethylene bags for the most part. Polyethylene is basically a solid form of oilits made from the by-products of oil refineries. The process takes small ethylene molecules, which are two-carbon chains, and links them together into a big long chain. So you have these long chains of carbon atoms that basically are chemically inert, with the exception of under extreme conditionsthey are flammable. Theyre not going to age well. There are no bugs that will consume plastic. Theyre going to be around a long, long time. Thats the problem.
The other side of that question, as I understand it at least, is simply the sheer numbers. Five hundred billion bags are used worldwide each year. Ontarians use 7 million plastic bags a day.
So laws like this potentially have an impact.
Absolutely. The other thing they do is bring to the forefront a green mentality. They make people think about ways they can avoid needless use of stuff. At the same time it would be nice if they could address the packaging industry, but thats a tougher one. I notice an inordinate amount of cardboard and packaging when I take out the recycling. An awful lot of it could be avoided.
Ive done a lot of traveling to Europe. It is routine there for people to carry bags to the store. They have been doing this for ten years or more. In some sense, North America is behind.
What do you think of the proposal to repeal the surcharge?
First, why would you repeal a law that addressed a critical recycling and landfill problem when people have accepted it without much in the way of complaints? On the other hand, why arent the retailers who collect this tax required to use it to benefit the environment?
Despite the politics, I am afraid the bottom line is that the chemistry does not change. Plastic bags that end in the landfill will be there for hundreds of years.
Is biodegradable plastic on the horizon?
There are people working on biodegradable plastic. But the target application is probably not grocery bags. There are already polymers that will biodegrade over a relatively short period of time. For example, sometimes when you get stitches, they are made from a polymer holds your skin together while it heals. Gradually it will degrade and the stitches eventually dissolve. These kinds of medical applications are perhaps a more critical use of new materials than applications like plastic bags.
Are we moving toward abandoning plastic?
We are not going to abandon plastics. Synthetic materials are a very important part of our material worldbut were not talking here about bags, about the gratuitous use of plastic. For example, plastic is used in all kinds of electronics. The notion of going to a paperless society is based on supporting materialflexible electronics on very readily available polymers. There are all kinds of applications for new polymers.
What is your research about?
We are targeting new technologies to produce polymers. Were focused on the technology for production more than the actual material that ends up being produced, but we work in concert with polymer chemists.