Voter registration policy may depress minority participation in electoral politics

March 12, 2012

An article released by Social Forces indicates that voter identification requirements have a substantially negative impact on the voting of all groups except for Asians. Particularly strong negative effects are seen for Blacks and Hispanics: a decrease in voting by 18 percent and 22 percent respectively. Even Whites show dampened turnout associated with voter ID policies. Yet for Asians, strikingly, voter ID has the opposite effect, boosting turnout by nearly 30 percent. This is an intriguing instance in which Asian participation patterns markedly differ from that of other groups.

The authors of the article, Brown University Professor of Sociology, John R. Logan, Jennifer Darrah and Sookhee Oh, use data in federal election years from 1996 through 2004 for this study to examine voter registration and voting. It shows that racial/ in socio-economic resources and rootedness in the community do not explain overall group differences in electoral participation. It contradicts the expectation from an assimilation perspective that low levels of Latino participation are partly attributable to the large share of immigrants among . In fact net differences show higher average Latino participation than previously reported. This research was sponsored by the Russell Sage Foundation.

The authors have shown that all else equal, Blacks register and vote at higher rates than Whites. Among the largely with lower levels of participation, Latinos register and vote at higher rates than . Unexpectedly, though, they showed that these group differences are conditional on nativity, because among immigrants Latinos participate more than either Whites or Asians and almost as much as Blacks. The study indicates that, "Although there has been speculation that the high share of immigrants in the voting-eligible Latino and Asian populations could help to explain their lower political participation, the impact of nativity is not uniform across groups and does not account for the differences between groups in participation . . . Race, Hispanic origin and immigration status apparently combine to produce distinctive collective influences on people's understanding of the political system and their engagement in it." Their results confirm that Latino and White participation were boosted, but only for registration and surprisingly with the opposite effect on voting. Minority political representation (our measure of co-ethnic public officials in the metropolitan region) is a related factor, and they found strong positive effects for Blacks along with some evidence that there may be an effect also for Latinos. Although the direction of causality in this finding is not certain and the Asian results run in the opposite direction, these findings should encourage further efforts to bring measures of group-based organizational activity into analysis of individual political behavior.

State voting rules are especially important because these are amenable to change, so the authors examined a wide range of these policies. There is a consistent effect for voter ID requirements. Some states have recently introduced new identification requirements and others are considering it. The evidence here suggests that this policy will depress White, Black and Latino participation in electoral politics—and the effect could be especially strong for Blacks and Latinos. On the other hand liberal absentee voting policies lead to higher voter turnout except, surprisingly, for Blacks. Finally there is some evidence that a stronger immigrant service safety net is associated with greater political participation—an effect which is particularly clear for Asians for both registration and voting—but again not for Blacks.

This study shows that group differences are not solely a function of the resources and rootedness of group members or a consequence of the high proportion of immigrants among Latinos and Asians. The authors suggest that attention now needs to be focused on the contexts of participation faced by each group, and how their participation is facilitated or discouraged by their shared conditions in the communities where they live.

Explore further: Voter I.D. requirements reduce political participation, study finds

More information:

Related Stories

English language ads better reach Latino audience

August 19, 2011

English language ads have a greater impact in mobilizing Latino voters than Spanish language ads, according to a study recently published in American Political Research, a SAGE journal.

Recommended for you

Study on prehistoric violence published

February 20, 2017

A longtime Cal Poly Pomona anthropology professor who studies violence among prehistoric people in California has been published in a prestigious journal.

'Tully monster' mystery is far from solved, group argues

February 20, 2017

Last year, headlines in The New York Times, The Atlantic, Scientific American and other outlets declared that a decades-old paleontological mystery had been solved. The "Tully monster," an ancient animal that had long defied ...

Mathematical models predict how we wait in line, traffic

February 17, 2017

As New Jersey drivers approach the George Washington Bridge to enter New York City, a digital sign flashes overhead with estimates of the delays on the upper and lower levels of the bridge. Most drivers choose the level with ...

Remembering the need to forget

February 17, 2017

We are built to forget – it is a psychological necessity. But in a social media world that captures – and, more importantly, remembers – everything we say and do, forgetting is becoming a thing of the past. If we lose ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3 / 5 (6) Mar 12, 2012
I'm guessing this shows that you are less likely to show up and present your ID to officials when there is a warrent out for your arrest.
3 / 5 (4) Mar 12, 2012
I'm guessing this shows that you are less likely to show up and present your ID to officials when there is a warrent out for your arrest.

I guess you won't be showing then?
2.6 / 5 (5) Mar 12, 2012
I do wish that the leftie-progs understood the roots of democracy. For instance the pinakion and kleroterion. The former being the Athenian voter ID and the latter the election machine. They put their pinakion in the kleroterion, the lever was pulled and the elected officials pinakia popped out - 2500 years ago.
3.4 / 5 (5) Mar 13, 2012
Lets ban ID at airports and border crossings, its unfair to not let poor people fly or travel to foreign countries.
3 / 5 (4) Mar 13, 2012
if you don't have an ID in this day & age you are likely to be illegal. it is not too much to ask to require ID when voting. no one scwabbles about the necessity of ID for drivers, heavy equipment operators, doctors, nurses among many professions. how are they going to cash their paycheck, welfare check, social security check, unemployment check, etc without ID?
3 / 5 (4) Mar 13, 2012
I understand the viewpoint that having a drivers license should not be a requisite for voting. That's not the issue here. The issue here isn't that Democrats are worried that people are being coerced to do something (they are usually on the opposite side of that argument). They're concerned because illegals generally vote for them...period.
3 / 5 (4) Mar 13, 2012
"If you don't have an ID in this day & age you are likely to be illegal. it is not too much to ask to require ID when voting." - Kellarlln

It is fun to watch Conservative Americans implementing the same kind of personal restrictions that made the Soviet Union great.
1.7 / 5 (6) Mar 13, 2012
Lots of right wing nut jobs would like to curtail voting rights. Only the privileged rich are worthy of voting. Oh, and if the result isn't what you want take to the right wing activist judges the supreme court has been stuffed with.
3.7 / 5 (3) Mar 13, 2012
"If you don't have an ID in this day & age you are likely to be illegal. it is not too much to ask to require ID when voting." - Kellarlln

It is fun to watch Conservative Americans implementing the same kind of personal restrictions that made the Soviet Union great.

LMFAO indeed. Hypocrisy abounds, what I left out of my previous unforgivable oversight...was that Republicans aren't concerned with illegals in the country further than they tend NOT to vote for them.

Let's just have some honesty about the issue on both sides here...
3 / 5 (2) Mar 13, 2012
Everyone who is a citizen of the U.S. is and should be required to have a picture I.D. The ID is not to inconvenience the bearer. Just imagine for a moment a murder victim who had no ID, never had fingerprints recorded anywhere, no dental records, no nothing. How would the authorities contact the victim's family or friends? When I go to vote, I appreciate being asked for my picture ID so that nobody else votes in my stead, pretending to be me. The same with opening a bank account, or cashing a check. There are too many ways an identity thief can ruin someone's credit rating and life without that picture ID. I don't see what all the fuss is about with these minorities who think that obtaining a picture ID means that they[re giving up something precious. They're not giving up anything, the same as me and everyone else.
Carrying your own picture ID is not a personal restriction. It's insurance that you will not be mistaken for someone else, or they mistaken for you. It's not a big deal.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.