Law prof's book probes 'whys' behind Big Apple crime decline

January 3, 2012 By Andrew Cohen, University of California - Berkeley

While the jaw-dropping decline in New York City’s crime rate is welcome news, it comes with a surprising corollary. “Most of the prevailing assumptions that have long driven U.S. crime and drug policy appear to be untrue,” said Berkeley Law professor and renowned criminologist, Franklin Zimring.

In his new book, The City That Became Safe, Zimring conducts a probing investigation of New York’s more than 80-percent drop in from 1990 to 2009. His findings—that police strategy played a key role in crime reduction, and that crime plummeted even as prison populations decreased—overturn decades of conventional wisdom.

As a result of his buzz-generating book, Zimring is in high demand. He’s been a regular guest on news shows; interviewed by national media, including The New Yorker; presented his findings at a national crime symposium; and published op-eds in prominent papers.

America’s 40-percent drop in crime from 1991 to 2000 remains largely an unsolved mystery, while ’s drop—twice as long and twice as large—is the greatest U.S. crime decline on record. According to Zimring, a revamped tactical approach by New York police paid giant dividends.

“The NYPD targeted hotspots where crime was most prevalent and persistent, and made a concerted effort to shut down public drug markets,” he said. “Both strategies were extremely effective. The department also increased its manpower and allowed officers to be more aggressive.”

Zimring’s research presents a powerful argument that the factors driving crime are more situational and contingent than previously thought. Criminologists had long assumed that if police camped out in a high-crime area, criminals would simply take their activities elsewhere.

“But it turns out that’s not the case,” Zimring said. “One less robbery on 125th Street doesn’t mean one more robbery on 140th Street; it just means one less robbery in New York that year.”

Local Impact

Zimring’s research caught the eye of local Oakland activists, who invited him to speak at a community forum on crime. Oakland Mayor Jean Quan recently unveiled a plan to restore safety to what she says are 100 of the city's most violent blocks. But Zimring believes a 100-block strategy is too vast for Oakland’s short-staffed and under-funded police department. He also says Quan’s plan fails to identify what services police will de-emphasize in order to focus more heavily on the targeted blocks.

Traditional theorists say that cities can’t reduce crime without winning the war on drugs. But Zimring’s book shows otherwise, describing how New York’s targeted harm-reduction strategies drastically decreased drug-related violence—even as illegal drug use remained high.

“New York’s drug overdose death rate is down 15 to 20 percent, but drug killings are down 90 percent,” Zimring said. “When you see that, you realize drug violence and illegal drug use may be two different problems.”

The City That Became Safe also puts a significant dent into the popular theory that imprisoning criminals is essential to lowering crime. While the U.S. incarceration rate increased 65 percent from 1990 to 2009, New York’s dropped 28 percent.

“It shows that you don’t need a mega-imprisonment policy to achieve a substantial reduction in crime,” Zimring said. “What happened in New York also indicates that, contrary to what many had believed, epidemic levels of violent crime aren’t hard-wired into the populations or cultures of urban America.”

Explore further: Study finds increased education lowers crime

Related Stories

Study finds increased education lowers crime

December 6, 2011

New research from The CIBC Centre for Human Capital and Productivity at The University of Western Ontario shows that education, and related education-based initiatives, can reduce crime rates, improve health, lower mortality ...

An inside-out approach to solving more gun crime

March 25, 2011

A 30-year law enforcement veteran told police, prosecutors, public defenders and federal agents Wednesday that “balancing people, processes and technology” is the best way to overcoming obstacles and gaps during ...

The benefits of marriage

September 26, 2011

Marriage can potentially help reduce crime by enabling people to develop greater self-control, according to a new study examining changes in marital status, self-control and marijuana use between late adolescence and early ...

The kids are alright

May 26, 2011

Children should be seen and not heard... who says? A Philosophy academic at The University of Nottingham is challenging the adage by teaching primary school children to argue properly.

Interpol pledges war on environmental crime

November 8, 2010

Interpol on Monday adopted a resolution unanimously pledging support to back the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) and to fight environmental crime.

Recommended for you

Crowds within crowd found to outperform 'wisdom of the crowd'

January 18, 2018

A team of researchers affiliated with institutions in Argentina, the U.S. and Germany has found that there is a way to improve on the "wisdom of the crowd"—separate the people in a given crowd into smaller groups and let ...

Study sheds new light on ancient human-turkey relationship

January 17, 2018

For the first time, research has uncovered the origins of the earliest domestic turkeys in ancient Mexico. The study also suggests turkeys weren't only prized for their meat—with demand for the birds soaring with the Mayans ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (2) Jan 03, 2012
An interesting summary.
As someone who has lived in NY, I would take issue with one aspect of the article / book - that of criminal incarceration.
Crime has dropped by 80% and in the corresponding period, incarceration has dropped by 28%, therefore the rate of incarceration per crime committed has risen significantly.
5 / 5 (1) Jan 03, 2012
One wonders how the well established link between lead exposure and violent crime has been accounted for.
Many forget that this cause-and-effect relationship was one of the reasons why leaded gas was discontinued in the 70's. Since then the decision has been reinforced by many studies showing the connection holds true from the grossest statistical level (in country after country crime drops roughly 20 years after outlawing leaded gas) to the most individual bio-chemical cause and effect level (lead induced brain changes).
3 / 5 (2) Jan 03, 2012
is the definition of a crime the same now as it was before? What about the reporting procedures? Have they changed?
5 / 5 (1) Jan 03, 2012
No wonder, during the same time the displacement of the population was & is growing in favor of the well-off for the same % about.
not rated yet Jan 03, 2012
in addition to the above:

1. credit cards (less cash on person)
2. cell phones (a major deterrent; the NYC police CAN respond quickly; they simply couldn't back when a victim or bystander had to find a phone booth and have dime or quarter)

BTW, what 'anao' wrote in code translates into "fewer black people".
not rated yet Jan 03, 2012
Also the digital camera (personal video recorder, surveillance camera, etc.) A suite of HUGE technological deterrents.
1 / 5 (12) Jan 04, 2012
Is it worth it, the NYPD being a national leader in civil rights violations and paramilitarization?
not rated yet Jan 05, 2012
Whatever the reason NY crime has dropped, visitors now feel safe. This generates more business. I am British and this change in the feel of security is talked about over here as a positive benefit when visiting NY.
not rated yet Jan 08, 2012
Has there been an investigation if crimes are being reported at the same rate?

Hypothesis: A drop in crime statistics may simply be a drop in people reporting crime - due to the perception that
a) the cops aren't going to do anything about it/are seen as inept
b) even if someone gets caught they won't get sentenced anyways given today's legal system and the ability of lawyers to twist it (as evinced in televised high profile cases like the OJ Simpson trial).

It's hard to judge how the number of unreported cases has changed.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.