China sets pace for smoggy Hong Kong: think-tank

January 15, 2012 by Stephen Coates
Measurements in some Hong Kong districts indicate that pollution levels are 10 times worse than in 2005
Choking smog is seen engulfing the skyline of Hong Kong. Beijing's decision to come clean on its dirty air has embarrassed Hong Kong, where smog kills hundreds of people a year, hurts business and drives away talent, according to a think-tank.

Beijing's decision to come clean on its dirty air has embarrassed Hong Kong, where smog kills hundreds of people a year, hurts business and drives away talent, a think-tank has said.

Mike Kilburn, head of environmental strategy at non-profit group Civic Exchange, said Hong Kong Chief Executive Donald Tsang's failure to fix the city's could have far-reaching consequences for its competitiveness.

"The Hong Kong government must introduce new air quality objectives immediately, especially now that China has put out its own air quality objective," he told AFP.

"Hong Kong is in a highly embarrassing position now that China has introduced new measures."

Beijing last week bowed to a vocal online campaign for a change in the way air quality is measured and pledged to start publishing figures showing the smallest, most dangerous .

The Chinese capital currently bases its air quality information on particles of 10 micrometres or larger, known as PM10, and does not take into account the smaller particulates that experts say are most harmful to human health.

The Beijing Environmental Bureau said it would provide hourly updates of measurements of particles of 2.5 micrometres or less, known as PM2.5, ahead of the Lunar New Year on January 23.

The mainland authorities' move came after Hong Kong's Environmental Protection Department said roadside pollution levels in the southern financial hub were the worst ever last year.

Measurements in the Central, Causeway Bay and Mong Kok districts indicated that were 10 times worse than in 2005 on more than one day out of every five.

A recent ranking of cities by the (WHO) in respect of PM2.5 placed Hong Kong -- which competes with Singapore as Asia's banking powerhouse -- at 559th out of 566 cities.

Smog in Hong Kong kills hundreds of people a year
Members of the Clean Air Network (CAN) stage a 'flash mob' calling for better air quality in Hong Kong, last June. A recent ranking of cities by the World Health Organisation (WHO) in respect of PM2.5 measurements placed Hong Kong -- which competes with Singapore as Asia's banking powerhouse -- at 559th out of 566 cities.

That dire outcome sparked searching questions to Environment Secretary Edward Yau in the legislative council last week.

Lawmaker Kam Nai-wai asked whether the government would "assume political responsibility" for failing to live up to promises to update Hong Kong's air quality objectives (AQOs), set in 1987, to meet modern health standards.

Yau responded that PM2.5 samplers would be operational in all monitoring stations in Hong Kong by the first quarter of 2012, and laid much of the blame for the small-particle pollution on "regions outside Hong Kong".

"The government is now working on the final proposal to update the AQOs for submission to the Legislative Council for deliberation as soon as possible," he said.

Yau said clean-air measures had to be "generally supported by the community", a likely reference to public opposition to higher transport costs and resistance from business owners to tighter environmental controls.

A report by Civic Action released Thursday said ageing diesel commercial vehicles, LPG-powered taxis and minibuses were the main sources of pollution in the city's "street canyons" of office towers and apartment buildings.

Air quality is not only damaging residents' health, it is also eroding the city's competitiveness as a regional centre for business and finance, it said.

The report cited pollution-related questions over infrastructure projects including the Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau (HKZM) bridge and a planned third runway at Hong Kong airport.

An official study last year found that the runway would have to operate at less than half capacity if new air quality standards were implemented.

Surveys showed that "air pollution is driving those who form the base of Hong Kong’s knowledge and finance-based economy -- the wealthiest and best educated -- to leave," it said.

"The challenges to the HKZM Bridge and the third runway represent a dramatic escalation in the scale of the problem. The business community is beginning to appreciate the seriousness of this threat," it said.

Tsang's seven-year rule, which is due to end in March, can be measured in terms of the more than 7,200 smog-related deaths recorded since he took power in 2005, Kilburn said.

The figures are backed up by the Hedley Environmental Index run by the medical faculty at the University of Hong Kong.

"It's a shockingly high number. What we are concerned about is the lack of urgency," he said Friday, when a pall of toxic airborne particles made it it barely possible to see across the city's Victoria Harbour.

The think-tank's air quality "report card" said the government had implemented various measures to control pollution, but these had been ineffective in the absence of a coordinated clean-air policy.

"Without tight standards, polluting businesses in Hong Kong, especially vehicle and vessel owners and operators, have been permitted to remain unregulated for the last two decades," it said.

Explore further: Hong Kong told to revamp air pollution rules

Related Stories

Hong Kong told to revamp air pollution rules

May 8, 2011

The Hong Kong government has been told to hammer out a timetable for new air quality rules amid increasingly vocal criticism of pollution in the global financial hub, a green group said Sunday.

Hong Kong air pollution hits record levels

March 22, 2010

Hong Kong's air pollution soared to record levels Monday, the Environmental Protection Department said, warning that a toxic stew enveloping the city was a danger to the public.

Hong Kong air pollution equals record high

October 24, 2009

Hong Kong air pollution has equalled a record high registered in 2000, triggering a warning for people with heart or respiratory illnesses, according to the Environmental Protection Department.

Hong Kong moves to restrict mainland babies

April 7, 2011

Hong Kong says it will restrict the number of mainland Chinese women allowed to give birth in the city's hospitals which are struggling to cope with the tens of thousands who arrive each year.

Recommended for you

Study finds pollution is deadlier than war, disaster, hunger

October 20, 2017

Environmental pollution—from filthy air to contaminated water—is killing more people every year than all war and violence in the world. More than smoking, hunger or natural disasters. More than AIDS, tuberculosis and ...

Carbon coating gives biochar its garden-greening power

October 20, 2017

For more than 100 years, biochar, a carbon-rich, charcoal-like substance made from oxygen-deprived plant or other organic matter, has both delighted and puzzled scientists. As a soil additive, biochar can store carbon and ...

Cool roofs have water saving benefits too

October 20, 2017

The energy and climate benefits of cool roofs have been well established: By reflecting rather than absorbing the sun's energy, light-colored roofs keep buildings, cities, and even the entire planet cooler. Now a new study ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jan 15, 2012
The air quality in Hong Kong would improve if Chinese pollutuion was reduced, since most of the pollution comes from over the border anyway. If you think Hong Kong pollution is bad you try should try to see through Guang Zhou pollution where the view across one city block is greyed out.

The whole of eastern China is an environmental disaster where blue sky can seldom be seen.

In the photo you can see sharp shadows indicating pollution really was not as bad as you would get further inland.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.