Biomass tax credits stabilized wood prices, fueled economic benefits

December 19, 2011

The first full year of Oregon's tax credits given to biomass collectors and producers — as administered by the Oregon Department of Energy — helped stabilize prices for wood-based fuel, supported as many as 73 jobs and created economic benefits that exceeded the program's cost, researchers report.

The biomass tax-credit program in 2010, as applied to , created "an average of about five jobs, nearly $250,000 in wages and benefits, and over $850,000 in total economic activity per 10,000 BDT [bone dry ton]," concluded the five-member research team. The overall wood-fuels market, according to the report, "likely supported about 300 jobs, more than $14 million in wages and benefits, and more than $50 million in economic activity in Oregon."

The findings were published in a working paper titled "Impacts of the Biomass Producer or Collector Tax Credit on Oregon's wood fuels market and economy." The Ecosystem Workforce Program of the University of Oregon's Institute for a Sustainable Environment prepared the report for the state Department of Energy.

The focus of the report was aimed specifically at one segment of the wood-fuels market — forest biomass, made up of logging debris, known as slash, and small-diameter materials generated from thinning and other forest-health projects.

Because of the state's economic conditions, including a downturn in lumber produced by mills as housing starts dropped off, "the tax credit helped this market stay competitive at a time when it likely would have not been able to do so," said lead author Max Nielsen-Pincus, a faculty research associate in the Ecosystem Workforce Program.

The video will load shortly.
AUDIO: Nielsen-Pincus provides a brief overview of the findings

Researchers examined data related to those who operate certified wood-to-energy facilities and those who collected, transported and delivered the materials to the facilities. The credit was created in 2007 by the Oregon Legislature and was originally administered by the Oregon Department of Revenue. Collectors of forest biomass could get $10 for each BDT of forest biomass they delivered to a bioenergy facility. About 85 percent of the $6.6 million of tax credits had been awarded to forest-biomass collectors.

These collectors hauled biomass materials an average of 103 miles to facilities that, in turn, paid from $30 to $45 per BDT, with the higher payments coming from facilities in Washington and northwest Oregon.

Economic activity generated from the forest biomass tax-credit incentive likely ranged from 1.0 to 2.4 times the cost in foregone tax revenues. This is based on a statistical model used to generate scenarios to predict wood fuel prices and capture uncertainties related to forest biomass entering in marketplace. The most-conservative model generated results that concluded the economic impact to the state matched dollar for dollar what it cost the state in forgone tax revenue.

"We hope to continue this study to determine the results of the tax credit in 2011," said study co-author Matt Krumenauer, a senior policy analyst at the Oregon Department of Energy, which funded the research.

In 2010, the USDA Biomass Crop Assistance Program and the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act allowed the Forest Service, Bureau of Land Management and private landowners to subsidize the transfer of biomass off some lands. The federal programs were mostly phased out in 2011.

"We hope that this report will contribute to policy conversations about how to best foster renewable energy development and valued-added wood products in Oregon," said Cassandra Moseley, co-author and director of the Ecosystem Workforce Program at the UO.

"Between the state and federal programs, it looks like we're creating an economic lever that's causing more material to get out of the forests and into the renewable energy sector," Nielsen-Pincus said at a meeting in Portland, Ore., where the results were first unveiled. "In all cases you create some jobs and economic activity, more than the program costs, mostly by turning logging slash into an energy source."

A fourth co-author on the working paper was Katherine MacFarland, a former EWP research assistant who now is a presidential management fellow focusing on biomass policy with the USDA Forest Service.

The working paper and abbreviated summary document (both in PDF format) are available at the Ecosystem Workforce Program (EWP) website.

Explore further: Report provides new analysis of carbon accounting, biomass use, and climate benefits

Related Stories

First renewable energy exchange opens in Amsterdam

November 3, 2011

Dutch-Belgian energy market provider APX-Endex launched a "biomass exchange" Thursday specialising in trading wood pellets as a source of renewable energy, a venture it said was a world first.

Idle Farmlands Could Become Profitable Carbon Storage Banks

October 23, 2008

( -- Michigan's recently enacted renewable energy portfolio legislation sets new requirements for green energy production in the State. Michigan policymakers believe energy plantations could be a major source ...

New studies sully reputation of biomass as clean and green

March 28, 2011

Simpson Tacoma Kraft would seem like one of the greener power plants. It boils water by burning sawdust, bark and wood shavings from saw mills and pulp mills, funneling the resulting high-pressure steam into a turbine to ...

Recommended for you

New paper answers causation conundrum

November 17, 2017

In a new paper published in a special issue of the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A, SFI Professor Jessica Flack offers a practical answer to one of the most significant, and most confused questions in evolutionary ...

Chance discovery of forgotten 1960s 'preprint' experiment

November 16, 2017

For years, scientists have complained that it can take months or even years for a scientific discovery to be published, because of the slowness of peer review. To cut through this problem, researchers in physics and mathematics ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.