Review: Software for recording now, playing later

September 29, 2011 By RACHEL METZ , AP Technology Writer
This screen shot provided by MediaMall Technologies Inc., shows the computer software Photo/MediaMall Technologies Inc.)

(AP) -- If the idea of being stuck on a plane for hours without access to the movies in your Netflix queue fills you with dread, software that lets you record streaming videos from the Web and watch them later on your laptop may be an appealing solution.

That's the idea behind PlayLater, which bills itself as "the for online videos." It can record content from a number of different online sources - including Hulu, YouTube and Netflix - and save it to your computer. It costs $5 per month, or $50 per year. New users can try it free for two weeks before paying.

If you buy or rent more than a couple of digital videos from Inc. or Apple Inc.'s Store every month, PlayLater could sound like a money-saver. And while it's a potentially useful product, it needs a lot of improvement before I'd be willing to shell out for it.

There's also a possibility that websites like Netflix will find a way to block PlayLater. They'd probably want to, since it doesn't jibe with the way they do business. In general, streaming movies are sold for less than ones available for download, so both websites and studios stand to lose from PlayLater. Websites don't want you to skip their commercials, either.

It's unlikely that websites and studios would have legal recourse against PlayLater and its MediaMall Technologies Inc., since it's been established that digital video recorders (like TiVos) are legal, but you never know. A spokeswoman for MediaMall said PlayLater is affiliated with some companies whose content it streams.

Basically, the software works like this: When you click on a video within the PlayLater application to save it onto your computer, it plays the video in a hidden Internet browser window and copies it from there.

This means it copies streaming video in real time, so you'll have to allow a full 93 minutes to record the pilot of David Lynch's early `90s TV drama "Twin Peaks." If you're saving a video that includes commercials, they'll be in there, too, but you'll be able to skip past them when viewing.

The software, which for now only works on PCs running Microsoft's Windows, is simple to download from the website and install. It works with 30 sites, or "channels," ranging from the aforementioned Netflix, YouTube and Hulu to Cartoon Network, ESPN, Comedy Central and Internet radio service Pandora. For password-protected sites like Netflix, you'll have to enter your login info.

The software is not hard to navigate, but it's ugly and cumbersome with lots of text and few images. You typically have to click through several levels of tabs to find the video clip, movie or TV show you want. Fortunately, some of the channels have a search bar, and when available I found it was usually easier to just use this to find what I wanted.

The resulting videos, which I played back through the Windows Media Player, were somewhat fuzzy and colors are noticeably bland - probably a result of the software copying already-compressed streaming video and then compressing it again. The recordings looked decent when viewed in a smaller window, but weren't sharp in full-screen mode. The recording technology is only a tad better than pointing a video camera at a TV screen, and it shows.

And don't expect to watch these videos on a tablet computer or smartphone just yet; they're saved in a proprietary file format that can only be played on a computer running the software. This is intentional - the company doesn't want you to spread your recorded videos around. But later this year the company hopes to allow playback on the iPad.

And while MediaMall also offers software called PlayNow that can be used to view your recordings elsewhere, such as on a smartphone or tablet computer, it requires an Internet connection and costs several dollars more per month (MediaMall is offering the two for $8 per month or $70 per year).

Watching PlayLater videos my PC, I had a number of issues, perhaps indicating my laptop was too taxed to handle playing, recording and using other programs simultaneously. Several times when I tried to watch a while recording another one I could hear the audio but only saw a bright pink screen. And my computer crashed three times while using the program and others at the same time. Installation failed on one Windows 7 computer, and on another, Netflix recording failed.

There were problems with recording, too. Several times PlayLater indicated it recorded an entire TV show when it actually hadn't. In one instance, it recorded just a portion of an episode of the teen drama "Awkward." from MTV. Another time the acted as though it had recorded a whole episode of "Glee" from Hulu, but it couldn't have because the show was only available to paid subscribers to Hulu's premium Hulu Plus service.

As much as I like being able to watch movies offline and fast-forward through commercials, PlayLater isn't the right tool in its current state. For things I can't watch now, I'll stick to paid downloads for playing later.

Explore further: Annoyed consumers have alternatives to Netflix


Related Stories

Annoyed consumers have alternatives to Netflix

September 28, 2011

If you're ticked off at Netflix because of its recent price increases and service changes, the good news is you've got plenty of options for streaming video. The bad news is that none offers exactly what you get from Netflix.

Roku teams with Amazon to stream videos

March 4, 2009

Roku, maker of a $100 box that delivers streaming Netflix videos to consumers' TVs, is teaming with to vastly increase the number of movies and TV episodes consumers can watch through the device. lets you legally watch premium video content

February 27, 2009

Most of us don't watch television the way we did just a few short years ago. Back then, we had to watch TV shows when they were aired, a slave to the broadcasting schedule whim of the networks.

Recommended for you

New method analyzes corn kernel characteristics

November 17, 2017

An ear of corn averages about 800 kernels. A traditional field method to estimate the number of kernels on the ear is to manually count the number of rows and multiply by the number of kernels in one length of the ear. With ...

Optically tunable microwave antennas for 5G applications

November 16, 2017

Multiband tunable antennas are a critical part of many communication and radar systems. New research by engineers at the University of Bristol has shown significant advances in antennas by using optically induced plasmas ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Sep 29, 2011
How is this news?

The firefox extension called download helper works beautifully for this.
1 / 5 (1) Sep 29, 2011
This is just an advertisement for something you can get for free elsewhere...
not rated yet Sep 29, 2011
Better than software DVR is online TV where you can watch everything whenever you want - not just shows you recorded. I watch some of these shows online through the TVDevo website. It makes finding shows as simple as browsing the net.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.