Dark matter packs a punch: Milky Way's spiral arms formed by intergalactic collision

September 14, 2011
Incoming third impact of the Sagittarius Dwarf galaxy (blue stream of stars) with our Milky Way Galaxy (multicolored disk) was simulated by supercomputer and rendered by Erik Tollerud against a background of galaxies seen in the Hubble Deep Field. Note the simulated disk's ring-like spiral extensions in the outer Milky Way (upper left), which strongly resemble actual streams found at low latitudes with respect to the disk plane, in the nearby region of the Milky Way viewed from the Earth in the opposite direction from the center of the Galaxy. Those spiral arms began to emerge after the initial impact of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy nearly two billion years ago; they have been amplified until the present day, into the many spiral arms observed in the Milky Way. Credit: Chris Purcell/HI-PACC

The signature spiral arms of the Milky Way galaxy were likely formed by an epic collision between the Milky Way and the Sagittarius Dwarf galaxy, according to a University of Pittsburgh researcher and his collaborators, published today in the prestigious British journal Nature.

Supercomputer simulations by Christopher W. Purcell, postdoctoral research associate in the Department of Physics and Astronomy in Pitt's School of Arts and Sciences, and colleagues report their findings in a paper titled "The Sagittarius Impact as an Architect of Spirality and Outer Rings in the Milky Way."

This paper is the first to identify Sagittarius as the architect of spiral structure in our Milky Way. "It presents a new and somewhat unexpected way of thinking about why the galaxy we live in looks the way it does," says Purcell.

"Cosmologically speaking, it demonstrates the idea that relatively small impacts like this can have a dramatic impact on the structure of galaxies throughout the universe," he adds. This idea had been assumed theoretically, but never demonstrated.

Purcell's collaborators include University of California High-Performance AstroComputing Center (UC-HIPACC)-affiliates James S. Bullock, Erik J. Tollerud, and Miguel Rocha, all at the University of California at Irvine. The fifth coauthor is Sukanya Chakrabarti at Florida Atlantic University.

In the field of cosmology, supercomputer simulations are the only laboratories for scientific experimentation. With supercomputers, astronomers can recreate a small-scale simulation or model of distant, violent events that occurred over billions of years, and observe that model in sped-up time, in order to make predictions that can be tested by actual observations of the universe.

Purcell's findings are based on supercomputer simulations he conducted for his PhD at the University of California, Irvine, and in the lab of Pitt professor of physics and astronomy Andrew Zentner.

Interestingly, Purcell's simulations revealed that even more important than the stars of the Sagittarius Dwarf was its halo of invisible "dark matter"—equal in mass to all the stars in the Milky Way.

Visible matter makes up less than five percent of the universe, while nearly a quarter of the universe is made of transparent dark matter. Its existence is felt only through its gravitational influence. It is now known that every galaxy, including the Sagittarius Dwarf (precollision) and our own Milky Way, resides at the center of a giant halo of dark matter several times larger in radius and many times greater in mass.

"When all the dark matter smacked into the Milky Way, 80 to 90 percent of it was stripped off," Purcell says. That first impact—more than two billion years ago—produced instabilities that were quickly amplified, eventually forming the spiral arms and ring structures in the outskirts of our own galaxy.

In his dissertation, Purcell focused on the question: What effects have the repeated collisions with the Sagittarius Dwarf had on the Milky Way?

Throughout the past few decades, conventional wisdom has been that the Milky Way was relatively unperturbed for the past several million years. Whatever spiral structure exists, these arms, were just a result of the Milky Way disc evolving in isolation.

Since the Sagittarius Dwarf was discovered, astronomers have tried to match up debris from that galaxy to what they saw in the universe. In 2003, infrared telescopes and supercomputers that traced the orbital motions of its stars has revealed that the Sagittarius Dwarf had actually collided with the Milky Way twice—once 1.9 billion years ago and again 0.9 billion years ago.

Computer simulations visualized the disk of the Milky Way Galaxy for three cases: no impact with a dwarf galaxy, impact with a Sgr dwarf galaxy of lower mass, and impact with a Sgr dwarf galaxy of higher mass. Our Galaxy is shown both edge-on and face-on in the inset panels, and the sun's location is marked as a yellow dot, and the present location of the Sagittarius dwarf's remnant core is marked as a pink dot, as shown after more than two billion years of isolated evolution. Shown in the background is a global rendering of the "light Sgr" tidal debris and the Milky Way disk. Credit: Chris Purcell/HI-PACC

"But what those collisions did to the Milky Way hadn't been simulated at all," says Purcell. "Ours was the first ever to try to do that."

Researchers found that the collision set up instabilities—fluctuations in density of stars—in the flat disk of the rotating Milky Way. Our galaxy rotates faster toward its center than toward its edges, so those instabilities were stretched and sheared, leading to the formation of spiral arms.

The simulations also revealed that the impact gave rise to ring-like structures found at the edges of our galaxy.

The second impact affected the Milky Way less, giving rise to only milder, less dense spiral-creating waves, because the Sagittarius Dwarf had by then lost most of its dark matter mass.

Without the dark matter to hold the dwarf galaxy together, its visible stars began to be pulled apart by the Milky Way's huge gravitational field and tidal forces.

"The dominant cosmology in astrophysics is one that's very violent on small scales. Galaxies like the Milky Way are constantly being bombarded by these small dwarf galaxies. It had not been appreciated prior to our work just how dramatic those impacts could be on the stellar disc itself," says Purcell. "We expected to find some more subtle signatures of an impact like this—a flare in the outer disc, like bell-bottom jeans. We expected to see some mild morphological changes to the Milky Way. But we did not expect to see a spiral structure begin to emerge as a result of these impacts. That was something we didn't foresee."

Indeed, Purcell and collaborators delayed publication for several months while they made sure they understood why they were seeing these results. "We had to convince ourselves that we weren't crazy," he jokes.

Today, long streamers of stars from the dismembered dwarf galaxy arch over and around the Milky Way, and "right now, billions and billions of dark matter particles from the Sagittarius Dwarf are raining down onto the Earth," said Purcell. "Meantime, the Sun itself is revolving around the center of the Milky Way Galaxy, in a complex and still-evolving system of multiple spiral arms."

We're just a few million years short of a third impact, Purcell says. But how can the researchers tell?

"We can tell when we look toward the center of the Milky Way," says Purcell. "Immediately on the opposite side of us, we can see this blob of stars crashing into the southern face of the disc from beneath. We can measure the velocities of these stars. We know that the dwarf galaxy is just about to smash the disc—in only another 10 million years."

Explore further: Astrophysicists map the Milky Way's 4 spiral arms

Related Stories

Astrophysicists map the Milky Way's 4 spiral arms

January 5, 2009

Iowa State University's Martin Pohl is part of a research team that has developed the first complete map of the Milky Way galaxy's spiral arms. The map shows the inner part of the Milky Way has two prominent, symmetric spiral ...

Milky Way A Field Of Streams

May 9, 2006

A new map of stars in the Milky Way Galaxy reveals a night sky criss-crossed with streams of stars, left behind by smaller satellite galaxies and star clusters ripped apart by the parent galaxy's gravity.

A new, distant arm of the Milky Way galaxy

June 13, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Our Milky Way galaxy, like other spiral galaxies, has a disk with sweeping arms of stars, gas, and dust that curve around the galaxy like the arms of a huge pinwheel.

The Milky Way's tiny but tough galactic neighbor

October 14, 2009

In the new ESO image, Barnard's Galaxy glows beneath a sea of foreground stars in the direction of the constellation of Sagittarius (the Archer). At the relatively close distance of about 1.6 million light-years, Barnard's ...

Recommended for you

Freeze-dried food and 1 bathroom: 6 simulate Mars in dome

January 20, 2017

Crammed into a dome with one bathroom, six scientists will spend eight months munching on mostly freeze-dried foods—with a rare treat of Spam—and have only their small sleeping quarters to retreat to for solace.

Image: Wavemaker moon Daphnis

January 20, 2017

The wavemaker moon, Daphnis, is featured in this view, taken as NASA's Cassini spacecraft made one of its ring-grazing passes over the outer edges of Saturn's rings on Jan. 16, 2017. This is the closest view of the small ...

Video: A colorful 'landing' on Pluto

January 20, 2017

What would it be like to actually land on Pluto? This movie was made from more than 100 images taken by NASA's New Horizons spacecraft over six weeks of approach and close flyby in the summer of 2015. The video offers a trip ...

The evolution of massive galaxy clusters

January 20, 2017

Galaxy clusters have long been recognized as important laboratories for the study of galaxy formation and evolution. The advent of the new generation of millimeter and submillimeter wave survey telescopes, like the South ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (3) Sep 14, 2011
Sounds like a plausible idea, especially in light of the known stripping of the Sagittarius Dwarf Galaxy, producing the Sagittarius Stream, literally a stream of old stars and a few clusters ripped from the dwarf as it orbits the Milky Way. The abstract in Nature (and several diagrams) can be found here: http://www.nature...417.html
not rated yet Sep 14, 2011
Does it imply, all arms of spiral galaxies were formed with mutual collisions? If not - why just the Milky Way should be an exception here?
5 / 5 (2) Sep 14, 2011
"Does it imply, all arms of spiral galaxies were formed with mutual collisions? If not - why just the Milky Way should be an exception here?"

I don't think this implies ALL spiral arms in ALL galaxies were formed by interactions with other systems. Other examples of arm formation from galaxy interactions have been identified and studied, both by observation and theory. One well known example: http://en.wikiped...l_Galaxy


Btw, New Scientist has a short animation of the proposed interaction with the Milky Way: http://www.newsci...als.html
1.8 / 5 (8) Sep 14, 2011
It proves that with a powerful enough computer and a creative enough mind that any end condition can be simulated and
"proven" starting with any start point.
4 / 5 (6) Sep 14, 2011
Then, jonnyboy, you should enlighten the rest of the world with *your* well-conceived, well-modeled, well-researched explanation of How Gravity Really Works. Go for it.
1 / 5 (1) Sep 25, 2011
Supercomputer simulations (not observations) published in the (once) prestigious British journal Nature.

Are another reminder of the demise of our space science program since Big Brother started manipulating government science in ~1971 to unite nations against an imaginary threat of global climate change. See:

1. Video summary as "Big Brother" took control of science (1961-2011)

2. Professor Ian Pilmer's new book, "How to get expelled from school"


One of few politicians who understands the serious danger facing our formerly free society today, Václav Klaus, President of the Czech Republic wrote the Foreword.

With kind regards,
Oliver K. Manuel
Former NASA Principal
Investigator for Apollo

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.