Chandra finds nearest pair of supermassive black holes

Chandra Finds Nearest Pair of Supermassive Black Holes
Credit: X-ray: NASA/CXC/SAO/G.Fabbiano et al; Optical: NASA/STScI
( -- Astronomers have used NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory to discover the first pair of supermassive black holes in a spiral galaxy similar to the Milky Way. At a distance of 160 million light years, it is also the nearest known pair of supermassive black holes.

The black holes are located near the center of the NGC 3393. Separated by only 490 , the black holes are likely the remnant of a merger of two of unequal mass a billion or more years ago.

"If this galaxy wasn't so close we'd have no chance of separating the two black holes in the way we have here," said Pepi Fabbiano of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (CfA) in Cambridge, Mass., who led the study that appears in this week's electronic issue of the journal Nature. "Since this galaxy was right under our noses by cosmic standards, it makes us wonder how many of these black hole pairs we've been missing."

Previous observations in X-rays and at other wavelengths indicated that a single supermassive black hole existed in the center of NGC 3393. However, a long look by Chandra allowed the researchers to detect and separate the dual black holes.

Both black holes are actively growing, generating X-ray emission as gas falls towards the black holes and becomes hotter.

When two equal-sized spiral galaxies merge, astronomers think it should result in the formation of a black hole pair and a galaxy with a disrupted appearance and intense . A well-known example is the pair of supermassive black holes in NGC 6240 located about 330 million light years from Earth. However, NGC 3393 is a well-organized spiral galaxy and its central bulge is dominated by old stars. These are unusual properties for a galaxy containing a pair of black holes.

Instead, NGC 3393 may be the first known instance where the merger of a large galaxy and a much smaller one, dubbed a "minor merger" by scientists, has resulted in the formation of a pair of supermassive black holes. In fact, some theories say that minor mergers should be the most common way for black hole pairs to form, but good candidates have been difficult to find because the merged galaxy is expected to look so typical.

"The two galaxies have merged without a trace of the earlier collision, apart from the two black holes," said co-author Junfeng Wang, also from CfA. "If there was a mismatch in size between the two galaxies it wouldn't be a surprise for the bigger one to survive unscathed."

If this was a minor merger, the black hole in the smaller galaxy should have had a smaller mass than the other black hole before their host galaxies started to collide. Good estimates of the masses of both black holes are not yet available to test this idea, although the observations do show that both black holes are more massive than about a million suns. Assuming a minor merger occurred, the black holes should eventually merge after about a billion years.

Both of the supermassive black holes are heavily obscured by dust and gas, which makes them difficult to observe in optical light. Because X-rays are more energetic, they can penetrate this obscuring material. Chandra's X-ray spectra, the distribution of the amount of X-rays with energy, show clear signatures of a pair of supermassive black holes.

The NGC 3393 discovery has some similarities to a possible pair of supermassive black holes found recently by Julia Comerford of the University of Texas at Austin, also using Chandra data. Two X-ray sources, which may be due to supermassive black holes in a galaxy about two billion light years from Earth, are separated by about 6,500 light years. As in NGC 3393, the host galaxy shows no signs of disturbance or extreme amounts of star formation. However, no structure of any sort, including spiral features, is seen in the galaxy. Also, one of the sources could be explained by a jet, implying only one is located in the galaxy.

"Collisions and mergers are one of the most important ways for galaxies and to grow," said co-author Guido Risaliti, from CfA and the National Institute for Astrophysics in Florence, Italy. "Finding a black hole pair in a spiral galaxy is an important clue in our quest to learn how this happens."

Explore further

Black Holes Go 'Mano a Mano'

Citation: Chandra finds nearest pair of supermassive black holes (2011, August 31) retrieved 26 June 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Aug 31, 2011
Space is cool

Aug 31, 2011
NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory is great, but neutron repulsion [1-5] likely prevents the formation of black holes.

1. "Attraction and repulsion of nucleons: Sources of stellar energy"
Journal of Fusion Energy 19, 93-98 (2001)

2. "Neutron repulsion confirmed as energy source",
Journal of Fusion Energy 20, 197-201 (2002)


3. "Standard solar model vs experimental observations"
IOP Proceedings, 307-316 (2003)

4. Is the Universe Expanding?", The Journal of Cosmology 13, 4187-4190 (2011)


5. "Neutron Repulsion", The APEIRON Journal, in press (2011)

With kind regards,
Oliver K. Manuel
Former NASA Principal
Investigator for Apollo

Sep 01, 2011
NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory is great, but neutron repulsion [1-5] likely prevents the formation of black holes.

Science is great, but Oliver's reality repulsion [1->infinity] likely prevents the formation of rational thought.

"Attraction and repulsion of nucleons: Sources of stellar energy"

"Attraction and repulsion of logic: Sources of mental lethargy"

"Neutron repulsion confirmed as energy source"

Neural dementia confirmed as confusion source.

Is the Universe Expanding?", The Journal of Cosmology

"Is Oliver's delusion state expanding?", The Journal of Cosmoquackery.

"Neutron Repulsion", The APEIRON Journal

"Neutron Repulsion", The APPARITION Journal of Cranks.

With Kind Regards,

Sep 01, 2011
Oops wrong thread.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more