Probing Question: Do we misunderstand French culture?

June 17, 2011 By Melissa Beattie-Moss, Pennsylvania State University

Reflecting on his 1879 sojourn in France, Mark Twain -- our most quintessentially American writer -- quipped, “In Paris they simply stared when I spoke to them in French; I never did succeed in making those idiots understand their own language.”

Twain is one in a long line of Americans who have found the French to be aloof, unfriendly and rude. Is there truth in the stereotypes or do we misunderstand the French character?

“To begin with,” said Willa Silverman, professor of French and Jewish studies in College of the Liberal Arts, “both the United States and France are diverse and pluralistic societies, so the notion of ‘national character’ is something of a mythical construction. This being said, I will offer that the French, whose society had rigid hierarchies for many centuries, place a greater, if subtle, emphasis on boundaries and distance -- between public and private space; between and among social and generational groups; and between strangers and intimates.”

For example, noted Silverman, it would be unheard of in France for a server in a restaurant to introduce him/herself to patrons, or for strangers to smile and greet each other in the street, “whereas this type of breezy informality is familiar to most Americans.”

Recalling her first trip to Paris when she was 16, Silverman said, “I mistakenly used the familiar form of address -- “tu” -- in a public place with a man I did not know. Looking on, my horrified hosts chided me about not respecting the social and gender codes regarding age and level of intimacy.”

"If we regard the French as snobby and too formal, the French often remark on Americans outsized, even slightly aggressive friendliness and disrespect for the personal space of others,” explained Silverman. Even the way we walk can reflect cultural differences, she added, pointing to “the loping gait of some Americans versus the more physically constrained walking style in France.”

Generally speaking, said Silverman, another area of cultural difference centers around work and leisure. The French “appear to place a higher value on ‘quality of life’ than do Americans, in terms of appreciation of food, leisure time and vacation. They will even strike to maintain these benefits!” she noted.

To Americans -- citizens of a nation founded on Puritan values of hard work, self-discipline and religious morality --  the French emphasis on joie de vivre is easy to interpret as lazy and self-indulgent.

Cultural misunderstandings flow both ways, reminded Silverman. “The French, I believe, have misread Americans’ championing of multiculturalism as an important ideal. For some French, the American desire to strive for multicultural classrooms and celebrate hyphenated identities  -- such as African-American or Italian-American -- clashes with the rather extreme form of egalitarianism derived from the French Revolution, which aimed to efface all visible differences among social orders, regions, and faiths.” Added Silverman, the French have, at times, misjudged us as “tyrannical champions of difference at all costs -- or conversely as naive conformists.”

The concept of American naïveté is at the heart of Mark Twain’s travel book -- and his bestselling work in his lifetime -- "The Innocents Abroad," in which the author finds comic fodder in the cultural collisions between his own tour group of American “pilgrims” and the European Old World.

(Wrote Twain in his travel journals, “France has neither winter nor summer nor morals -- apart from these drawbacks it is a fine country,” adding that “the objects of which Paris folks are fond” include “literature, art, medicine and adultery.”)

Surely we must have some cultural common ground with the country that gave us The Statue of Liberty and French fries, n’est-ce pas? “Absolument!” said Silverman. “As inheritors of the “Atlantic revolutions” of 1776 and 1789, Americans and French share a deep commitment to democratic values and individual liberties that draw our cultures together. Moreover, the enduring popularity of American popular in France and the generally favorable view of the Obama administration among the French may make this a propitious moment for the waning of traditional stereotypes on both sides of the Atlantic.”

Or as Twain put it, “Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry and narrow-mindedness.” Even about the French.

Explore further: As long as original version still available, tweaking Twain is OK, professor says

Related Stories

Responses shift when changing languages

November 3, 2010

The language we speak may influence not only our thoughts, but our implicit preferences as well. That's the finding of a study by Harvard psychologists, who found that bilingual individuals’ opinions of different ethnic ...

Modern society made up of all types

November 4, 2010

Modern society has an intense interest in classifying people into ‘types’, according to a University of Melbourne Cultural Historian, leading to potentially catastrophic life-changing outcomes for those typed – ...

Recommended for you

Insects took off when they evolved wings

January 23, 2018

The evolution of wings not only allowed ancient insects to become the first creatures on Earth to take to the skies, but also propelled their rise to become one of nature's great success stories, according to a new study.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (4) Jun 17, 2011
Enjoyed this article up to the flagrantry gratuitous promotion of the myth Obama. Such fawning adoration is best left to posts in the Daily Koss or Huffington Post. So give the propoganda a rest, please.
5 / 5 (3) Jun 17, 2011
Where exactly do you see "flagrantry gratuitous promotion" or "fawning adoration" of Obama in this article?

Is the mere mention of his name enough to make you start foaming at the mouth?
5 / 5 (2) Jun 17, 2011
Having been raised in the south of France and living most of my life in the US, I found the article humorous and true, for the most part. Much as a Southerner is different from someone living in the mid-west, France is all that and more.

As far as my city, Nice, we clearly claim we have only been "French" for 150 years of so and don't feel very French. Someone from Brittany will also have a very strong local culture. The same is true from all for corners of the country. What you coin "French culture" was imposed on the rest of the country and doesn't reflect it in its entirety.

The south is renowned for its warmth and inviting people, the West for its picturesque countryside, son on so forth but one thing is sure, wherever you go, an ounce of common sense and respect for local culture will greet you open armed. It's only when we go there without observing that we are reminded different strokes for different cultures.
not rated yet Jun 17, 2011
Didn't Napoleon have to teach his recruits to speak French?
France was a collection of 'states' with their own dialects and cultures at that time, no?
1 / 5 (1) Jun 17, 2011
The Americans' idea of the stereotypical obnoxious Frenchman, is pretty much the French stereotype of Parisians.

Also, French food is mostly overrated, except for that of Dijon and Burgundy in general. Actually, Belgium has better French cuisine than France, and cheaper, too. For that matter, California and Chile have better wine for the money, and French cheeses aren't better than other places. Their pro-intellectual culture is almost unique, though. The downside is that every Frenchman seems to consider himself an expert in virtually any subject that comes up.
4.3 / 5 (6) Jun 18, 2011
every Frenchman seems to consider himself an expert in virtually any subject that comes up.

So QuantumCondumdum is a Frenchman?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.