Carbonates make diamonds grow in the Earth's mantle

April 8, 2011 By Simone Ulmer, ETH Zurich
Short-lived splendour: Diamonds are caught up in a cycle of growth and decay in the Earth’s interior. Credit: paloetic/

Diamonds that no-one ever sees can form deep in the Earth’s interior. This is due to the chemical conditions controlling the associated carbon cycle. Swiss researchers used laboratory experiments to show how this happens.

Lava that is almost as free-flowing as water and, when it cools down, as pale as limestone: the Ol Doinyo Lengai in northern Tanzania is the only active volcano in the world that produces so-called carbonatite lava. Unlike conventional lava, the majority of this lava consists not of molten silicates but of molten carbonates. Volcanoes of this kind are found along rift valleys where the continental plates gradually break apart and new oceans are formed.

Diamond from lime and iron

These carbonate melts, among other things, form when limestones enter the Earth’s mantle. This occurs as a result of subduction, when old oceanic crust plunges down below an adjoining crustal plate. By means of high-pressure experiments in the laboratory, postdoc Arno Rohrbach and ETH Zurich Professor Max Schmidt from the Institute of Geochemistry and Petrology of ETH Zurich studied how the oxidised carbon contained in the carbonates behaves in the Earth’s mantle, and in so doing they made an exciting discovery: at a depth of more than 200 kilometres, the submerged carbonates of the oceanic crust reach their melting point, which is 300 to 400 degrees lower than that of silicates. A carbonatite melt is formed and migrates from the subducted oceanic crust into the surrounding mantle, where it causes partial melting therein. However, because the Earth’s mantle is strongly chemically reducing and contains elemental metallic iron, the CO2 in the carbonatite melt reacts with the elemental iron. This causes to form.

Earlier studies have already shown that carbonates in the Earth’s mantle cause the surrounding mantle to melt at relatively lower temperatures at pressure in excess of 2.5 gigapascals, but these studies focused exclusively on the oxidised state of the carbonates. However, the ETH Zurich researchers write in their study, which was recently published on-line in Nature, that in order to understand what happens in the significantly reduced deeper mantle of the Earth it is necessary to consider the redox equilibrium between oxidised carbonates and the reduced metal-containing deeper mantle.

Carbonates in subducting oceanic crusts melt and migrate into the adjacent mantle, where the carbonatite melts are reduced to diamond by a redox reaction with metallic iron. This redox reaction takes place in reverse in the upwelling mantle: the diamonds are converted back into carbonatite melts, which migrate upwards. Credit: ETH Zurich

“Minerals in the Earth’s mantle such as garnet and perovskite preferentially incorporate trivalent iron during their formation”, says Max Schmidt. Part of the otherwise doubly positively charged iron is oxidised for this purpose, while another part that is half the amount of the trivalent iron is simultaneously reduced to elemental iron. Because metallic iron and carbon dioxide are incompatible, the iron metal is oxidised and the carbon dioxide is reduced to pure carbon. Thus, diamonds crystallise out of the carbonate melt at a pressure of more than 10 gigapascals and temperatures of 1400 to 1700 degrees Celsius, consequently the carbonate melt solidifies. Thereafter only triply and doubly positively charged iron together with the diamonds remain in these mantle domains in the transition zone between the upper and lower mantle at a depth between about 410 and 660 kilometres.

The carbon cycle in the Earth’s interior is more complex

However, as a result of convection in the Earth’s mantle over hundreds of millions of years, the “agglomerates” of diamonds, which cover a distance of between one and ten centimetres per year, can be transported into the lower mantle down to a depth well in excess of 2000 kilometres, and can rise up again from there. During the uprise, the diamonds remain stable until they pass back through the transition zone from the lower to the upper mantle of the Earth, in which both the chemical equilibrium and the pressure and temperature conditions change again: here the minerals containing trivalent iron – perovskite and garnet – become unstable and release trivalent iron which then reacts with the diamonds. The carbon is re-oxidised in this process, the diamonds are destroyed and the trivalent iron is reduced to divalent iron. Carbonate melts can form again due to the presence of carbon dioxide, and the divalent iron is incorporated into the minerals olivine and pyroxene, which make up the majority of the upper mantle.

This enabled the researchers to show not only how and where carbonatite melts are formed in the Earth’s mantle. They also demonstrated how the carbon cycle from the Earth’s surface down to its interior functions: from carbon dioxide transported with carbonates into the interior, reduced to pure carbon and finally oxidised back to carbon dioxide as it rises. The resulting carbonatite melt, most of which is normally dissolved in a silicate melt at crustal pressures, ultimately brings the back to the surface of the Earth through active volcanoes such as the Ol Doinyo Lengai.

Explore further: An Inexhaustible Source of Energy from Methane in Deep Earth

More information: Rohrbach A &Schmidt M: Redox freezing and melting in the Earth’s deep mantle, Nature (2011), DOI:10.1038/nature09899, published online 23 March 2011.

Related Stories

An Inexhaustible Source of Energy from Methane in Deep Earth

September 15, 2004

Untapped reserves of methane, the main component in natural gas, may be found deep in Earth’s crust, according to a recently released report in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of ...

Tiny 3-D images shed light on origin of Earth's core

December 16, 2010

( -- A new method of capturing detailed, three-dimensional images of minute samples of material under extreme pressures is shedding light on the evolution of the Earth's interior. Early results suggest that the ...

When the Earth mantle finds its core

September 17, 2010

The Earth's mantle and its core mix at a distance of 2900 km under our feet in a mysterious zone. A team of geophysicists has just verified that the partial fusion of the mantle is possible in this area when the temperature ...

Recommended for you

Rainfall's natural variation hides climate change signal

February 22, 2018

New research from The Australian National University (ANU) and ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science suggests natural rainfall variation is so great that it could take a human lifetime for significant climate ...

Seasonal patterns in the Amazon explained

February 22, 2018

Environmental scientists at the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Brookhaven National Laboratory have led an international collaboration to improve satellite observations of tropical forests.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.