Fairy wrens: Accountants of the animal kingdom

Fairy wrens: Accountants of the animal kingdom
Image credit: Australian Wildlife.

A puzzling example of altruism in nature has been debunked with researchers showing that purple-crowned fairy wrens are in reality cunningly planning for their own future when they assist in raising other birds' young by balancing the amount of assistance they give with the benefits they expect to receive in the future.

Dr Anne Peters, of the Monash University School of Biological Sciences, together with co-authors Sjouke Kingma from the Max Planck Institute for and Michelle L. Hall of the Australian National University, have conducted a long term study of the cooperative breeding behaviour of fairy-wrens in tropical Australia.

The results, published in the prestigious journal The , show that helpers are not motivated by kindness.

"The study showed that the seemingly selfless little helpers are in fact carefully calculating accountants" said Dr Peters, senior author of the study.

Cooperative breeding, where birds apparently selflessly raise others' offspring, has long perplexed biologists as this behaviour runs counter to Darwin's theory of natural selection, which predicts that individuals invest only in their own reproduction.

Fairy-wrens are habitual cooperative breeders. The helpers are generally older silblings or half-siblings of the current nestlings, and their behaviour is likely explained by an instinctive desire to see more of their shared genes entering the .

Purple-crowned fairy-wrens extend this assistance to unrelated nestlings.

Dr Peters' study shows that these apparently altruistic helpers are actually playing a selfish game: they help when their chances of inheriting the current breeding territory are greater, and they are thus helping to raise their own future assistants.

"Ours is the first study to show that helpers at the nest adjust their behaviour precisely according to multiple potential rewards: they provide food to kin, and to unrelated nestlings to produce future helpers of their own," Dr Peters said.

"However, we suspect once more researchers look at their study species in this dual light, more cases will be found of helpers that can do their sums so precisely."


Explore further

Mother's little helpers

Provided by Monash University
Citation: Fairy wrens: Accountants of the animal kingdom (2011, March 18) retrieved 23 April 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2011-03-fairy-wrens-accountants-animal-kingdom.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
0 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Mar 18, 2011
What i've been saying all along: Altruism is a form of egotism. this doesn't mean that it's bad (quite the contrary) but that it's not some life-defying, beatific personality trait. It's just a roundabout way of being beneficial to the individual by creating a stable environment/society in which the individual can expect that others will help it when the need arises (and where the amount of hard competitors decreases)

Revel in your altruism!

Mar 19, 2011
I can't agree with the study. How did they show those birds are actively planning for their future?
I would speculate they are just instinctively altruistic, the same way we are, because altruism begets more altruism and thus altruism begets better survival potentiality. And thus the trait of altruism lives on.

Mar 19, 2011
Human altruists're invariably poorly rewarded for their efforts, to the point of often being physically abused if they dare pay attention to anyone else's problems, (see any hospital A&E department on a Saturday night).

To prove this theory they'd need to demonstrate one or more continuous lineages over many generations received their 'just rewards'.

They'd also need to keep the 'linking' generations in such lineages in isolation not only from the general community but each other to preclude the possibility it's a tendency acquired by demonstration/observation.

Mar 21, 2011
I can't agree with the study. How did they show those birds are actively planning for their future?


They found spreadsheets on their IPads.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more