Battle lines emerge in bluefin tuna battle

Nearly 80 percent of each year's bluefin catch is shipped to Japan, where it is eaten raw as gourmet sushi and sashimi
A sushi selection made from bluefin tuna. A meeting on the fate of the Atlantic bluefin tuna got into its stride on Thursday as Europe mulled a call for a modest cut in catches and Japan said it would propose a fishing ban on nations that cheat.

A meeting on the fate of the Atlantic bluefin tuna got into its stride on Thursday as Europe mulled a call for a modest cut in catches and Japan said it would propose a fishing ban on nations that cheat.

At stake is the viability of billion-dollar fishery for the open-water predator and perhaps even the species' long-term survival, say .

Industrial-scale fishing using huge trap-nets during spawning season has drastically reduced stocks in the Mediterranean over the last three decades.

Nearly 80 percent of each year's catch is shipped to Japan, where it is a hallowed part of the national diet, eaten raw as gourmet sushi and sashimi.

The 48-member International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT), meeting in Paris until November 27, sets the rules and quotas for Atlantic and monitors compliance.

European Union (EU) nations, overcoming internal divisions, agreed late Wednesday to push for a "stable or partially reduced quota".

European fisheries commissioner Maria Damanaki, backed in particular by Britain, called last month for slashing yearly quotas to 6,000 tonnes.

This is less than half of the 13,500 tonnes extracted from the eastern Atlantic and Mediterranean in 2010.

countries led by France -- including Spain, Italy and Malta -- had called for rolling over the current quotas for at least another year.

Eventually, though, all 27 member nations agreed on a proposal to "negotiate the bluefin quota between its current level of 13,500 tonnes and a partial reduction", a European diplomat told AFP.

Another diplomat said the EU 27 were ready to accept a reduction of 2,000 tonnes.

Japan, meanwhile, said it would table a proposal by which countries that cheat on their quotas would be banned from fishing the following year unless they improved monitoring and enforcement measures, the daily Asahi Shimbun reported.

"Japan will take leadership in the meeting to ensure the recovery of the stock," Masanori Miyahara, the head of the Japanese delegation, told NHK television in Paris.

VIDEO: Bluefin tuna showdown pits industry against ecology. Duration: 01:51
VIDEO - Economy clashed with ecology as dozens of nations met in Paris Wednesday to set catch quotas for diminished stocks of Atlantic bluefin tuna, a mainstay of gourmet sushi and sashimi in Japan. Duration: 01:51.

The United States has in the past pushed for "zero" quotas, but is under pressure from its own domestic industry, centered in Massachusetts, to ease up on restrictions to boost employment.

Going into the meeting, ICCAT Chairman Fabio Hazin said that a proposal favoured by four major green groups to suspend industrial fishing in the Mediterranean in favour of more traditional methods was under consideration.

"That is a realistic scenario," he said. "One of the things being discussed is the possible suspension of purse-seine fishing and the caging activities."

ICCAT scientists are cautious about quota numbers, saying that they could be skewed by high uncertainty about fish populations and the true tonnage of catches.

A single can fetch more than 100,000 dollars in wholesale markets in Japan.

There, the fish is known as "kuro maguro" (black tuna) and prized by sushi connoisseurs as the "black diamond" because of its scarcity.

Bluefin make up less than one percent of the global tuna catch, which includes five species.

Explore further

Japan leading charge against bluefin ban

(c) 2010 AFP

Citation: Battle lines emerge in bluefin tuna battle (2010, November 18) retrieved 19 August 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Nov 18, 2010
Oh, the irony. Japan threatens fishing bans on any country that "cheats" in cutting down Atlantic bluefin tuna catching. Meanwhile, Japan shows extreme contempt for the rest of the world's ban on whale hunting, and there's even a TV show that regularly observes them doing so.

Nov 18, 2010
Japan should ban consumption of whale meat and bluefin tuna.

Problem solved.

Nov 19, 2010
I am beginning to think that all efforts to stop things like this, including climate change, should be stopped. Maybe we would be better off letting all the fools have their way instead of prolonging the destruction. Let them destroy a species quicker and maybe the message will be driven home that will save others. Driving many species to extinction slowly or changing the climate slowly doesn't seem to bother enough people, as a species it seems we only have short term memory.

One of our greatest traits, the fact that we can get used to and adapt to almost anything, may be one of our greatest Achille's heels. The problem is there are some things we shouldn't adapt to.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more