Just in time for Halloween: Michigan Tech students solve the mystery of the Paulding light

October 28, 2010 By Marcia Goodrich, Michigan Technological University
This Google Earth image shows the line of sight between the Paulding Light viewing area and US 45. USDA Farm Service Agency/Jeremy Bos image

(PhysOrg.com) -- Cue the bats and spooky music. We are about to delve into one of Michigan's most alluring mysteries. It's so alluring, in fact, that it draws a steady stream of pilgrims of the paranormal to the dot-in-the-road town of Paulding all summer long, and into the winter too, just to hang out on the edge of the woods to watch and wait.

They come to catch a glimpse of the Paulding , and they are rarely disappointed. The light (or lights; sometimes they come in groups) appears in a valley near Robins Pond Road. It was even featured this year on the SyFy television show “Fact or Faked: Paranormal Files.”

The lights are definitely not faked, says Jeremy Bos, a PhD candidate student in electrical engineering at Michigan Technological University. But neither are they ghostly lanterns of a railroad brakeman killed trying to stop an oncoming train, as one of the many legends goes.

Bos organized the investigation of the Paulding Light mystery, working with students in the University’s student chapter of SPIE, a professional society devoted to the study of optics and photonics. Last May, the group was looking for a project that would be both fun and educational. “I thought, ‘What about the Paulding Light?’” Bos said.

Everyone thought it was a great idea. The first step was a road trip out to the site to view the light, which appeared as anticipated. On their next trip, they brought a telescope. Again the light appeared, and through the scope, the students saw . . .

Caution: If you really, really want to believe the Paulding Light is the ghost of a murdered railroad engineer, you might want to quit reading right about now.

. . . headlights. On a car. Traveling down a highway.

That was all very well and good, and a non-scientist might simply conclude that the Paulding Light was no more mysterious than a 1998 pickup truck and call it a day. But the SPIE students wanted to do more. So they sought out the stretch of highway where the light originates.

That turned out to be relatively easy, since they were able to spot an Adopt-a-Highway sign in their scope and track it down via Google Maps.

Next, the group sent team member Bill Norkus out to that spot on US-45. He recorded when vehicles passed the spot they’d seen in the telescope. Meanwhile, other students stayed in Paulding, logging light appearances. Sure enough, every time the Paulding Light appeared, a car drove by the spot.

Then, they created the light themselves, when a SPIE member drove his vehicle along US-45. Its passage correlated exactly with Paulding Light appearances. “Bill put on his hazards, and we saw flashing yellow lights,” said Bos. The students will also use a spectrograph to characterize the light from both the headlights and the Paulding Light. Based on the evidence so far, they expect them to be identical.

As if that weren’t enough, the group is also conducting atmospheric modeling along US-45. Heat rising off the pavement may sometimes contribute to the light’s distortion, he says. On the flip side, an inversion layer in the line of sight between the road and the Paulding Light viewing spot may also create very stable air, which could account for the light’s visibility about four and a half miles from US-45.

But what about the impressive, multicolored lights that are sometimes reported? And why does the light seem to move around?

“I think that the occasional spectacular lights happen when a cop pulls someone over,” says Bos. He attributes the perceived movement to an optical illusion: without a frame of reference, objects often seem to drift about the horizon. In addition, that section of US-45 is on a hill; the lights rise, fall and stop as vehicles go up and down the hill; they change in intensity as drivers brighten and dim their headlights.

Finally, Bos notes that the first Paulding Light sightings were reported shortly after that particular stretch of highway was rerouted. Visitors to Robins Pond Road, a popular make-out spot, started talking about the lights in the 1960s.

The students plan to present their work at an upcoming SPIE meeting.. But no matter how airtight their explanations, Bos has discovered that some people prefer not to be confronted with the evidence.

“We’ve been told we haven’t seen the real Paulding Light. I’ve been out there 15 times, hours at a time, in the heat, the cold, and the rain. It’s always the same,” said Bos. “We were there Monday with a man who saw the headlights with a man who saw the headlights on our computer, and he refused to believe it.”

Bos gets a little irritated with people who should know better who repeat the Paulding Light is “unexplained.” “We’re not the first people who have come to this conclusion,” he notes. “A paranormal investigation team came here in the 1980s and showed it was headlights.”

Debunking the Paulding Light may not seem like the typical scholarly endeavor. However, the project has given the undergraduates a chance to try their hand at a variety of experimental and analytical techniques and report on their findings. Plus, it has provided them a sobering insight into human nature.

“No matter what, some people will believe what they want to believe,” Bos sighs.

The project advisors are Christopher Middlebrook and Michael Roggemann, faculty members in Michigan Tech's Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering. Undergraduates Doug Sims and Mike Mauer have also contributed to the investigation.

Explore further: A miracle diet for brake rotors: High-strength, high-temp aluminum

Related Stories

Making decisions is the third way we learn, research shows

October 11, 2010

Experts have long believed there are two main ways our brains work: cognition, which is thinking or processing information, and affect, which is feeling or emotion. However, a new breakthrough was just made in regard to a ...

Consumer confidence hits five-year high in Michigan

October 27, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Despite Michigan’s continued economic malaise, residents’ optimism about the future is at its highest in nearly five years, according to Michigan State University’s latest State of the State ...

CSIRO 'hot rods' old telescope

October 13, 2010

CSIRO has helped transform the University of Sydney's radio telescope into a world-class instrument, and along the way has learned lessons for its own ASKAP (Australian SKA Pathfinder) telescope.

Bones restored with dried plum in aging mice

October 6, 2010

A diet supplemented with powdered dried plum restored bone lost by mice during the course of normal aging, in a study led by a researcher at the San Francisco VA Medical Center.

Figuring out suicidal behavior

October 13, 2010

Matthew Nock is the son of an auto mechanic, a Harley-Davidson aficionado, and the first member of his family to graduate from college. He’s now also a tenured member of the Harvard faculty.

Recommended for you

Crowds within crowd found to outperform 'wisdom of the crowd'

January 18, 2018

A team of researchers affiliated with institutions in Argentina, the U.S. and Germany has found that there is a way to improve on the "wisdom of the crowd"—separate the people in a given crowd into smaller groups and let ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Oct 28, 2010
I invite the students to North Carolina to study the Brown Mountain lights. Some have tried to explain them away as car headlights or, in the 1800s, a locomotive headlight. Trouble is, they've been reported well before cars or even locomotives were invented. They've been called swamp gas. No swamps around. Every explanation so far has had fatal problems. They were known by the Native Americans when white men first came to the area. They've been investigated many times, but no explanation has been found.
1 / 5 (2) Oct 28, 2010
Not to say that there is anything "spooky" going on here, but what they have shown is a correllation, and not an explanation.
I'd be itersted to see them give a real explanation of how these lights are atmospherically lensed to a remote loaction.
that would be a true explanation.
I've seen similar phenomena at Watersmeet MI, under varying atmospheric conditions, so something interesting is still to be discovered.
not rated yet Oct 29, 2010
atmospherically lensed ... that would be a true explanation
Refraction, mirage.

Natural history is narrative and prescriptive, not falsifiable and not science.
not rated yet Oct 29, 2010
Where I live-- on the Great Plains of the central United States, 3000 feet above sea level, I have many times seen mirages of the most incredible sort. Farms and towns which I know in fact are well over the horizon float mysteriously in the sky above, often quite large, and in some cases hugely magnified and inverted.

Scroll down to "Mirages in Western Kansas" to read about some here-- http://www.kshs.o...aths.htm
And here-- http://skyways.li...age.html

I have a book which describes early settlers seeing herds of wild horses, each animal hundreds of feet tall, racing across the sky.

These mirages occur early in the morning or late in the afternoon when the rising/setting sun creates ground temperatures drastically different from that of the air above. The sky becomes a great lense onto which things and places many miles away are visible if you are lucky enough to be in the right place at the right time.
not rated yet Oct 29, 2010
He's right. People will believe what they want as shown numerous times by The Amazing Randi and his demonstrations!
not rated yet Nov 11, 2010
LOL....remind me to NOT go to MI tech for an education

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.