As e-voting comes of age, security fears mount

October 24, 2010 by Rob Lever
A man arrives to vote in Las Vegas on October 16. New technologies allowing voters to cast ballots via the Internet or other electronic means are catching on in the United States and elsewhere, even as fears mount about security of the systems.

New technologies allowing voters to cast ballots via the Internet or other electronic means are catching on in the United States and elsewhere, even as fears mount about security of the systems.

A total of 33 US states are allowing some email, fax or online ballots in 2010, according to the Verified Voting Foundation, a group that monitors of election systems.

These systems, which are also used in several other countries, can potentially increase voter participation but security remains a question mark, especially following one spectacular attack on an Internet vote pilot project.

The startling came in September, when a pilot Internet vote system for the city of Washington, DC, was put online for a test.

A team of from the University of Michigan had little trouble infiltrating the system, modifying ballots, changing the password and directing the system to play the university fight song.

"It was extremely easy. Within the first three hours or so of looking at the code we found the first open door and within 36 hours we had taken control of the system," said Alex Halderman, the Michigan professor who led the effort with his students.

To make matters worse, Halderman discovered that other hackers -- including from Iran and China -- were trying to do the same thing.

"I think these attacks would have succeeded given the weaknesses of the system," he told AFP.

Halderman and other computer experts say the penetration highlights flaws in online voting that cannot be fixed at present.

"After this, there can be no doubt that the burden of proof in the argument over the security of Internet voting systems has definitely shifted to those who claim that the systems can be made secure," says David Jefferson, a computer scientist at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and chairman of Verified Voting.

The development dealt a fresh blow ahead of the 2010 US elections to confidence in voting systems.

It follows the debacle in the 2000 presidential vote involving "hanging chads" from punch cards, and doubts about newer paperless vote machines that critics say leave no trail for a recount.

"I think Internet voting is the wave of the future, but as with any new system you have to have good testing and certification to be sure the public can trust the results," said Richard Soudriette, president emeritus of the International Foundation for Election Systems, which monitors elections and provides assistance worldwide.

Paul DeGregorio, chief of elections for the electronic voting firm Everyone Counts, says Internet systems currently in use in many locations including in Europe and Asia have withstood security challenges.

He said the critics of online voting "are well-meaning but they fail to take into account the context."

DeGregorio said electronic voting "empowers" voters including people with disabilities who cannot get to polling places, troops abroad and others living outside their home countries, including some six million Americans.

He said a return to paper and pencil "will disenfranchise many people," and fail to get out some younger, tech-savvy voters.

"Younger people are going to say, 'Why should I stand in line for half an hour to cast my ballot? Why can't I do it on my cell phone?" he said.

Pamela Smith, president of Verified Voting, said vulnerability questions remain, whether the systems accept votes directly online of by email or fax.

"I think these systems can be compromised," she said. "It might not happen this year, it might be in a close presidential election."

Susan Dzieduszycka-Suinat, president of the Overseas Foundation which helps Americans abroad in elections, said the group is not ready to endorse online voting.

"At this point, there really isn't any proven, safe ballot return over the Internet that has gone through any certification that is agreed upon," she said.

Explore further: India's electronic voting machines are vulnerable to attack (w/ Video)

Related Stories

Voters confused by e-voting technologies

January 28, 2008

A study led by the University of Maryland suggested that electronic U.S. voting technologies are efficient but too many voters ask for help too often.

Electronic voting system tested by Newcastle University

May 14, 2008

An electronic vote capture and counting system, designed to overcome the problems which have dogged computerised voting systems throughout the world, notably the touch screen voting machines in the US and pilot schemes run ...

Voting for online democracy

May 6, 2005

The Internet may be used to power elections in towns, cities, countries, and even across Europe thanks to the work of a recently completed project. It would mean voters could cast their ballots at home, in the street via ...

Recommended for you

Top takeaways from Consumers Electronics Show

January 13, 2018

The 2018 Consumer Electronics Show, which concluded Friday in Las Vegas, drew some 4,000 exhibitors from dozens of countries and more than 170,000 attendees, showcased some of the latest from the technology world.

Finnish firm detects new Intel security flaw

January 12, 2018

A new security flaw has been found in Intel hardware which could enable hackers to access corporate laptops remotely, Finnish cybersecurity specialist F-Secure said on Friday.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Oct 27, 2010
Nonetheless this move towards e-voting must be sustained. This will permit our societies to return to the true Democracy the one Athenians once enjoyed, where citizens can vote on issues rather than representatives that represent only themselves. The evolution to representative democracy was necessary due to the practical difficulties to make millions of people vote regularly. Now the internet provide us with a way to vote speedily hence a lot more often.
not rated yet Oct 30, 2010
I agree with AVROES. Also, Internet voting is now being done securely by West Virginia and Arizona, Canada, and Europe. Search Scary Stories Fail to Stop Internet Voting for facts. Twitter: wjkno1
Lets be friend on FB
William Kelleher

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.