Climate Change Triggered Dwarfism in Soil-Dwelling Creatures of the Past

October 6, 2009
Thick red rocks mark an ancient time in the Bighorn Basin near Worland, Wyoming. Credit: Steve Hasiotis and Jon Smith

( -- Ancient soil-inhabiting creatures decreased in body size by nearly half in response to a period of boosted carbon dioxide levels and higher temperatures, scientists have discovered.

The researchers' findings are published in the October 5, 2009, early online edition of the journal (PNAS).

Jon Smith, a scientist at the Kansas Geological Survey, and Stephen Hasiotis, a geologist at the University of Kansas, have demonstrated that soil-inhabiting creatures contracted in size by 30-46 percent during the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM).

The PETM was a short interval 55 million years ago marked by a spike in the atmosphere's carbon dioxide levels and global temperatures, conditions being repeated on Earth now.

The study is the first to establish that soil biota experienced a loss in size similar to mammals, which were reduced in size by as much as 50 percent during the PETM.

"The discovery that up to 50 percent of the body size reduction during the PETM was not just restricted to mammals, but also affected soil-dwelling organisms, has broad implications that may be very significant to understanding modern and its impending effect on life," said H. Richard Lane. Lane is a program director in the National Science Foundation (NSF)'s Division of Earth Sciences, which funded the research by Hasiotis and colleague Mary Kraus at the University of Colorado.

"In our initial hypothesis, we thought that there would be no response to climate change, that the animals would be protected because they're underground," said Hasiotis.

"We also proposed that there would be minimal and protracted change or some sort of a delayed response. Instead, we find that they did experience the same kind of change as vertebrates living during the same period."

The soil-dwelling organisms examined by Smith and Hasiotis are ancient relatives of modern ants, cicadas, dung beetles, earthworms and crayfish.

A fossil crayfish is shown next to a modern crayfish. Credit: Steve Hasiotis and Jon Smith

To establish their findings, the researchers examined trace fossils, or the burrows, nests, tracks, trails and borings of organisms preserved within the Willwood Formation, a thick sequence of mudstones and sandstones in Wyoming's Bighorn Basin.

They found that diameters of burrows and other traces were smaller during the PETM, suggesting that the soil-inhabiting organisms that had created the traces were correspondingly lesser in size.

The scientists say that their results foreshadow biological outcomes that may result due to the planet's current jump in carbon dioxide concentration and temperatures.

They suggest that museum collections of insects compiled over the last few hundred years should be studied to determine whether body sizes of modern insects are indeed getting smaller.

"The PETM is seen as a good analog for modern climate change because it's occurring at roughly the same speed and magnitude," said Smith.

"The take-home lesson is that there can be cascading effects that ripple through an ecosystem when you change just one aspect. Modern can have many effects that aren't going to be as immediately visible as sea-level change.

"We could be changing soil conditions over vast portions of the world and affecting the soil organisms themselves--and that will impact our own agriculture."

The researchers attribute dwarfism in soil-dwelling creatures to faster rates of development in individuals, along with decreasing life spans.

"The soil biota evolved for certain soil temperatures and conditions--and for this geologically brief period of time, those conditions were changed," Hasiotis said. "They probably were adapting to those warmer conditions by having a smaller body size."

During their time in the Bighorn Basin, a typical day in the field for the researchers involved digging shoulder-width trenches that were a meter or so deep and several meters tall, then searching the soil for specific geometric shapes indicating ancient nests, cocoons and burrows.

"For each individual trace fossil, we'd measure the diameter," said Smith. "We'd compare like trace fossils from rocks that occurred before the PETM event, within the event, and after the event. Then we'd look for changes in those diameters through time."

"We were surprised to find that they were in fact smaller through the PETM."

Provided by NSF

Explore further: From Mississippi to Wyoming, Plants Once Danced to Fast-Changing Climate Tune

Related Stories

Global warming: Our best guess is likely wrong

July 14, 2009

No one knows exactly how much Earth's climate will warm due to carbon emissions, but a new study this week suggests scientists' best predictions about global warming might be incorrect.

Researcher seeks 'missing piece' in climate change models

February 13, 2007

To most people, soil is just dirt. But to microbiologists, it is a veritable zoo of bacteria, fungi and nematodes. It's also a vast carbon dioxide factory. As these microorganisms consume carbon-based materials found in soil, ...

Geobiologists Discover Unique 'Magnetic Death Star' Fossil

October 21, 2008

( -- An international team of scientists has discovered microscopic, magnetic fossils resembling spears and spindles, unlike anything previously seen, among sediment layers deposited during an ancient global-warming ...

Recommended for you

Lifting barriers to citizenship for low-income immigrants

January 15, 2018

Taking the Oath of Allegiance at a naturalization ceremony is an emotional moment for many immigrants, and for good reason: it is the culmination of an often arduous process and many years of striving. Citizenship also opens ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (2) Oct 06, 2009
So, they are claiming the climate change associated with the PETM caused the dwarfing of ALL life that occurred during that period. Nice how they try to sneak in an AGW message here.

There are other instances in biology where we see dwarfing. This of course being islands. A macro species finds itself on an island for whatever reason and, due to reduced availability of resources, shrinks.

As far as I know, all theories as to the cause(s) of the PETM involve catastrophic and/or otherwise earth changing events (massive volcanic activity, comets, permanent global oceanic current shifts, solar/orbital forcing). Part of what is known is that there were massive oceanic extinctions and that all major species shrunk, while many of today's predominant species began to proliferate.

The pairing of dwarfing and CO2 levels/climate change here is completely scientifically disingenuous. They are just sticking a known trend of the PETM with a know result, with no evidence for direct causation.
1 / 5 (2) Oct 06, 2009
It is far more likely that whatever events precipitated the PETM were hard on all life on earth. So hard that everyone's resources were knocked back from the ground up (and down, here apparent) so everything shrank due to reduced caloric availability.

More data supports that CO2 rose as the temperature did, not that the CO2 caused the temperature rise of the PETM. Climate change does not cause life to shrink in and of itself, there is no precedent or even logical connection to this, the reduction in the availability of resources does, there is abundant precedent for this.

So, did the climate change then cause the reduction of resource availability? Absolutely not. Again there is no logical causation here. It is more likely that whatever events caused the PETM were accompanied by some other change, like increased SO2 levels in the atmosphere or the like that caused a reduction in resources at the base levels of the food chain.

What a bunch of crap this article was.
not rated yet Oct 07, 2009
Any intelligent response barakn or brianweymes or are you just going to down rank for absolutely no reason as per usual?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.