Despite oil, baby turtles being released to Gulf

Jul 24, 2010 By RAMIT PLUSHNICK-MASTI , Associated Press Writer
Five Kemp's ridley sea turtle hatchlings leave the beach at Padre Island National Seashore in this Sunday, June 17, 2007 file photo near Corpus Christi, Texas. Wildlife officials plan to release a large group of hatchlings early next week. (AP Photo/The Caller-Times, Todd Yates, FILE)

(AP) -- Federal biologists are releasing thousands of endangered baby sea turtles into the western Gulf of Mexico, betting that by the time the silver dollar-sized swimmers make it to the oil-fouled waters of the eastern Gulf, BP will have cleaned up its goopy mess.

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and National Park Service are proceeding with the annual release of Kemp's ridley turtle hatchlings off Padre Island National Seashore because Texas has not been significantly impacted by the oil spill. For years, scientists have incubated and hatched the turtles to give the endangered creatures a boost.

The risks of holding turtles in captivity at a critical stage in their life cycles could be worse than the dangers of oil more than 400 miles away, the plan's supporters say.

Hundreds of days-old hatchlings have been freed on Texas beaches since the June 8 decision. Another large group is expected to be released early next week.

The decision, however, has stirred controversy among some scientists, environmentalists and turtle lovers.

Supporters say there should only be intervention with animals directly in the oil's path, like loggerhead turtles in Florida. In 1979, after a rig blowout in the Mexican Gulf, authorities airlifted Kemp's ridleys to oil-free waters.

Critics argue the decision to free vulnerable hatchlings doesn't adequately account for hurricanes, storms or a seasonal change in current, all of which could bring the oil west and directly into their path. Nesting mothers, they say, are also at risk because many deposit their eggs in northern Mexico or south Texas and head for heavily impacted areas.

"We have raised them in captivity and learned the hard way that there are also a lot of negative potential from that," said Deborah Crouse, a sea turtle biologist in the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's Endangered Species Recovery Program.

However, Crouse acknowledged the release does present a risk of oil exposure. It took a team of 14 experts days to decide whether to release the Kemp's ridleys.

"It was a balancing act between the danger of holding them in captivity vs. the damage that could be done to them by the oil," Crouse said. "That's why it was not an easy decision."

The U.S. said that as of Wednesday, 167 visibly oiled of various species had been collected alive. At least 482 have been found dead, but no oiled turtles have been found in Texas.

Carole Allen, director of the Sea Turtle Restoration Project's Gulf office in Houston, is a vocal critic of the hatchlings' release in Texas. At least some of the babies and nesting mothers should be kept in captivity until the oil is cleaned, she said.

"Don't just send them out to the Gulf to die cause they're going to get oiled eventually," Allen said.

Andre Landry, a sea turtle expert at Texas A&M University in Galveston, said baby turtles swim out and attach themselves to algae mats or other floating habitats. It's possible those habitats are oiled, he said.

In Florida, because of the proximity to the oil, loggerhead turtle nests are being collected and incubated. Hatchlings are being released on the state's eastern coast, far from the oil.

"That goes in direct opposition to what's been decided with the Kemp's ridleys," Landry said.

The Kemp's ridleys have been on the endangered list since 1973 after their population was depleted from years of hunting their eggs and trapping the animals in fishing nets. They are among the smallest sea turtles, and live mostly in warmer Gulf of Mexico waters.

Their population numbers have slowly recovered. This year, there were nearly 13,000 nests - or about 4,300 nesting turtles - in Mexico and Texas, down from last year when there were about 22,000. Scientists attribute the slip to natural variation and an unusually cold winter.

Still, scientists were so encouraged in March by the Kemp's ridleys recovery they believed they might see 10,000 nesting females within five to 10 years. That would upgrade the species from endangered to threatened, allowing them to still be protected by some federal laws.

While it won't be clear until next year whether the oil spill damaged the turtles' progress, it has put upgrade hopes at risk.

Donna Shaver, chief of the Division of Sea Turtle Science and Recovery at Padre Island National Seashore has been monitoring the Kemp's ridleys for 30 years. She collects their nests from Texas beaches, incubates them and watches them hatch. Finally, she releases the babies at the precise moment when they enter a "frenzy" of activity and have extra energy from the yolk they've ingested, allowing them to get past the surf and float on the currents to their new homes.

Federal agencies have long maintained a policy that collected wildlife should be released, Shaver said.

"Any time you release hatchlings, you realize it's a perilous situation for them," Shaver said. "They can fall victim to fish, they can fall victim to birds. Only a fraction of them survive into adulthood. And this year, this is another risk they face, so it's frustrating."

Allowing the Kemp's ridleys to remain in captivity, however, creates other risks.

Early efforts aimed at recovering the species taught scientists that prolonged captivity can mess with the turtles' navigation and foraging skills, putting long-term survival in danger, said David Godfrey, executive director of the Sea Turtle Conservancy in Gainesville, Fla.

He supports the loggerhead program in Florida, but thinks the Kemp's ridleys should be released so long as Texas is oil-free.

"Everybody who is critical of that decision has a right to be critical because it's not a black or white decision," Godfrey said. "If oil comes into Texas with a hurricane, nobody knows what would happen. Is it absolutely foolproof, 100 percent, signed, sealed, delivered? I don't know. Nobody knows."

Explore further: Dwindling wind may tip predator-prey balance

3.2 /5 (6 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Sea turtles rescued from Gulf spill released

Jul 16, 2010

(AP) -- The first group of sea turtles that are part of a sweeping effort to save threatened and endangered hatchlings from death in the oily Gulf of Mexico have been released into the Atlantic Ocean.

Endangered turtles make a comeback

May 14, 2006

Kemp's ridley sea turtles almost became extinct, but 50 nestings have been recorded in Texas and more than 4,000 eggs recovered for incubation this year.

Many endangered turtles dying on Texas Gulf Coast

Apr 30, 2010

(AP) -- Flies buzz everywhere and the stench is overwhelming as biologist Lyndsey Howell stops to analyze the remains of yet another endangered sea turtle washed up from the Gulf of Mexico.

Some 70,000 turtle eggs to be whisked far from oil

Jun 30, 2010

(AP) -- An effort to save thousands of sea turtle hatchlings from dying in the oily Gulf of Mexico will begin in the coming weeks in a desperate attempt to keep an entire generation of threatened species ...

Turtle eggs to be rescued from Gulf of Mexico spill

Jul 02, 2010

In an ambitious and unprecedented plan to save wildlife, volunteers in coming weeks will move tens of thousands of turtle eggs from oil-soaked Gulf of Mexico beaches to safety on Florida's Atlantic coast.

Recommended for you

Dwindling wind may tip predator-prey balance

Sep 19, 2014

Bent and tossed by the wind, a field of soybean plants presents a challenge for an Asian lady beetle on the hunt for aphids. But what if the air—and the soybeans—were still?

Asian stars enlisted to fight African rhino poaching

Sep 19, 2014

Increasingly desperate South African conversationists are turning to a multi-national team of "rhino ambassadors" to try to end the scourge of poaching—and Vietnamese pop diva Hong Nhung has been recruited ...

Tropical fish a threat to Mediterranean Sea ecosystems

Sep 18, 2014

The tropical rabbitfish which have devastated algal forests in the eastern Mediterranean Sea pose a major threat to the entire Mediterranean basin if their distribution continues to expand as the climate ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Shootist
1 / 5 (5) Jul 24, 2010
Well let's see, they (turtles) have survived the K-T extinction, the bolide swarm at 35My, the Deccan Traps, the Siberian Traps, Yellowstone, Thera, Tambora, Ice Ages and Hot House Earth.

I suspect they will survive a little bit (compared to the above all the oil in Saudi Arabia is a little bit) of oil in their bathwater.
trekgeek1
3 / 5 (2) Jul 25, 2010
Oil covered turtles, now I'm hungry.

As for surviving natural disasters, these animals probably haven't encountered something "unnatural". That is to say, it's not often that this amount of crude oil spills into the ocean. This is an event brought about by engineering feats not seen by these animals. You could make the argument that we are natural denizens of this planet and therefore any action we take is "natural".
HealingMindN
5 / 5 (2) Jul 25, 2010
therefore, we've forgotten all about the corexit and its effects? Here are a few more titbits:

BP accused of trying to silence science on spill - The head of the American Association of Professors accused BP Friday of trying to buy the silence of scientists and academics to protect itself after the Gulf oil spill, in a BBC interview. A copy of a contract offered to scientists by BP, which the BBC said it had obtained, said scientists are not allowed to publish the research they do for the oil giant. (PhysOrg; July 23, 2010)

Experts: Health Hazards in Gulf Warrant Evacuations - Marine toxicologist Riki Ott said that if she lived in the Gulf with children she would leave immediately. Some people in the Gulf are experiencing symptoms like headaches, dizziness, sore throats, burning eyes, rashes and blisters that are do deep, they're leaving scars. (TruthOut; July 22, 2010)