Teacher-designed performance pay programs offer smaller incentives to more teachers

Apr 06, 2009

Performance pay programs designed by teachers, for teachers, tend to offer small incentives to a large number of teachers, new research indicates.

"We found that when design performance pay programs they tend to be egalitarian, offering everyone a little bit of money," Matthew Springer, director of the National Center on Performance Incentives at Vanderbilt University and a co-author of the new research, said.

The study drew data from Texas public schools participating in the Governor's Educator Excellence Grants Program, or GEEG. GEEG was a three-year program that distributed $10 million per year in non-competitive federal grants to 99 high-performing campuses serving low-income students. It was the nation's largest state-funded performance pay program when it was launched in 2005.

Under GEEG, participating schools were required to design their own incentive pay plans, using broad guidelines set by the Texas Education Agency.

"Because the guidelines required that teachers play a significant role in the design and implementation of their school's plan, the GEEG program represented a unique opportunity to explore optimal incentives from the employer and the employee's perspectives," Lori Taylor, assistant professor at the Bush School of Government and Public Service at Texas A&M University and a co-author of the new research, said. "The evidence strongly suggests that employees - the teachers - prefer relatively weak incentives."

In most participating schools, over 80 percent of teachers received some sort of bonus.

"The GEEG incentive plans systematically offered smaller awards to a higher proportion of teachers than was obviously intended by the state education agency," Taylor said. "Intriguingly, weak incentives were more common in situations where one would think stronger incentives would be more effective at changing behavior."

The researchers also found that even weak incentives had a positive impact on teacher retention. Teachers who received no award were more likely to leave their jobs than those who received an award, while awards of $3,000 reduced turnover among the recipients to roughly half the rate observed before the GEEG program.

"If we assume that award recipients were more effective in the classroom than non-recipients - which might be a relatively strong assumption - then the evidence suggests that even weak incentives achieved the objectives of employers," Springer and Taylor said. "The GEEG program increased retention of those teachers that schools particularly wished to retain."

Source: Vanderbilt University

Explore further: When it comes to how pizza looks, cheese matters

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Performance pay is a good lesson for education, expert finds

Mar 13, 2009

Tuesday, President Barack Obama announced a new education reform, calling for a merit-pay system for teachers in hopes of improving student performance. As the nation's public schools spend $187 billion in salaries, based ...

Teachers admit to bullying students

Jun 29, 2006

U.S. researchers in Topeka, Kan., say nearly half of elementary school teachers surveyed about bullying in schools admitted to bullying students.

Shortage of physics teachers in the UK worse than ever

Nov 21, 2005

An independent report published today directly links the steep decline in the number of students taking A-level physics to the shortage of expert physics teachers. With over 30% of physics teachers due to retire in the next ...

NASA sends teachers to Chile

Jun 20, 2006

A NASA expedition to Chile this week is part of its Spaceward Bound pilot program to challenge U.S. teachers to design and implement real field research.

Recommended for you

When it comes to how pizza looks, cheese matters

5 hours ago

Most consumers have an idea what they want their pizza slice to look like. Golden cheese with that dark toasted-cheese color scattered in distinct blistery patches across the surface with a bit of oil glistening in the valleys. ...

Freedom and responsibility of science

11 hours ago

Yesterday, the German Research Foundation (DFG) and the Leopoldina National Academy of Sciences presented their recommendations for "The Freedom and Responsibility of Science" in Berlin. Both research organizations appeal ...

What I learned from debating science with trolls

Aug 20, 2014

I often like to discuss science online and I'm also rather partial to topics that promote lively discussion, such as climate change, crime statistics and (perhaps surprisingly) the big bang. This inevitably ...

Activists urge EU to scrap science advisor job

Aug 19, 2014

Nine major charities urged the European Commission on Tuesday to scrap a science advisor position it says puts too much power over sensitive policy into the hands of one person.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

COCO
not rated yet Apr 07, 2009
come to Kanada - where teachers start at @$100 K - (@ 75K U$) and have unions to protect them from working or performing - NO TEACHER LEFT BEHIND - CCCP