Strict labor market regulation increases global unemployment, study shows

Mar 17, 2009
Job Center
This is a picture of a job center in the UK. Credit: Image by Jason Cartwright, Flickr

Tight labour market regulation increases unemployment all over the world, finds a study of 73 countries by the University of Bath.

The study, published in the , is one of the first to cover not only but also developing and transition countries.

Based on data for the years 2000 to 2003, the findings suggest that if, for example, Italy (a typical country with strict regulation) had enjoyed the same flexibility in labour as the United States (a typical country with flexible regulation), its rate might have been 2.3 percentage points lower among the total , 3.4 percentage points lower among women and 5.6 percentage points lower among .

"The adverse labour market effects are probably due to lower investment by domestic firms as well as lower foreign direct investment inflows caused by stricter labour market regulation." said Dr Horst Feldmann, from the University's Department of Economics & International Development, who carried out the research.

One area of labour market regulation that appears to have particularly adverse effects on unemployment are stringent hiring and firing rules, the study finds.

While strict hiring rules restrict temporary work agencies and the use of fixed-term contracts, tight firing rules make it difficult and costly for employers to lay off workers.

According to the findings, these rules, as well as strict labour market regulation in general, have a particularly adverse impact on women and young people.

Dr Feldmann explained: "Women often take a career break to have children and later on try to get back into employment. Young people are just entering working life.

"Therefore, it is plausible that both groups are more strongly affected when employers are reluctant to hire staff due to stringent labour market regulation."

Another type of labour market regulation that appears to raise unemployment on a world-wide scale is military conscription, the study finds.

"A main reason may be that conscripts leaving the armed forces after the end of their service have difficulties finding a job because they did not gather the skills and work experience that employers are looking for." said Dr Feldmann.

"The longer the conscription period, the more severe this mismatch is likely to be. According to my findings, this effect is the strongest among young people. This is obviously because conscripts typically are in this age group.

"This is the first time the effects of military conscription on the labour market have been analysed."

Apart from the indicators that measure the strictness of hiring and firing regulation and the use of conscription, Dr Feldmann used indicators that measure the strictness of minimum wage laws, the centralisation of wage bargaining and the generosity of unemployment benefits.

His aggregate indicator measuring the overall strictness of labour market regulation is the average of these five individual indicators.

On average over the years 2000-2003, Italy's flexibility of labour market regulation (as measured by the aggregate indicator) was rated 3.6 out of 10 - while the United States was rated 7.2 and the United Kingdom was rated 6.8.

Dr Feldmann said: "The research suggests that the UK's fairly flexible labour market regulation is likely to strengthen the economy's resilience to weather the current crisis.

"Although unemployment is going to rise sharply for some time, countries with more flexible regulation will probably experience a faster and more pronounced fall in unemployment once the crisis is overcome."

Source: University of Bath

Explore further: Over-identifying restrictions in economic analysis

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

How young adults cope with employment uncertainty

May 23, 2007

Young adults don’t necessarily have ‘identity crises’ when it comes to flexible labour markets and job insecurity, concludes a new study published by Bristol University. The study, Constructing coherence: young adu ...

Pain-free childbirth? Get real!

Mar 14, 2008

A pain-free and drug-free labour may be many expectant mothers’ dream but a review in the open access journal BMC Medicine reveals that reality hits hard. Most women's labour experiences differ markedly from their expect ...

Is HIV testing during labor feasible?

Feb 27, 2009

Cameroon is a sub-Saharan African country with high HIV rates yet many pregnant women do not know their HIV status. Research published in the open access journal BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth has shown that HIV testing during ...

Recommended for you

Over-identifying restrictions in economic analysis

6 hours ago

The analysis of empirical economics has long made use of a tool called the generalized method of moments (GMM). This method is used as a generic way of estimating parameters in an empirical model where the ...

Tracking Chinese aid to Africa

Nov 24, 2014

Is a fancy new school in an African government official's hometown a coincidence, or evidence of systematic favouritism in the distribution of aid?

When shareholders exacerbate their own banks' crisis

Nov 21, 2014

Banks are increasingly issuing 'CoCo' bonds to boost the levels of equity they hold. In a crisis situation, bondholders are forced to convert these bonds into a bank's equity. To date, such bonds have been ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.