Does it matter if black plus white equals black or multiracial?

Oct 10, 2008

"Is Barack Obama Black or Biracial?" a recent CNN.com headline asks. The question of whether Obama should be considered black or multiracial has been a concern of the media throughout the campaign.

Should such racial characterizations of people like Obama -- who have one black parent and one white parent -- really matter?

According to a new Northwestern University study, they do matter.

The findings suggest that the immediate response of non-black study participants is to categorize a racially ambiguous person as black when it was known that one of the person's parents was black and one was white.

In other words, when study participants knew of the person's black-white ancestry, in comparison to not knowing of the parentage, they quickly adhered to the simplistic characterization of biracial people as black, said Northwestern's Destiny Peery.

Social psychological research demonstrates a relationship between social categorizations and subsequent behavior. "It is possible that once multiracial individuals are categorized as black, for example, they may subsequently encounter stereotyping and prejudice consistent with this categorization," she said.

Peery, a graduate student in psychology and Galen V. Bodenhausen, professor of psychology and marketing at Northwestern, are co-investigators of "Black + White = Black: Hypodescent in Reflexive Categorization of Racially Ambiguous Faces." The article appeared in the October issue of the journal Psychological Science.

To address how black-white biracial people are commonly categorized, non-black study participants were asked to view a series of profiles of college students, with photos that depicted each one as black, white or racially ambiguous. Some of the racially ambiguous photos were accompanied with profiles indicating that one of the student's parents is black and the other is white.

Later when participants completed spontaneous or immediate racial categorization tasks, they were more likely to consider the racially ambiguous faces to be black when the person was known to have mixed-race ancestry, compared to not having that knowledge.

Upon more thoughtful reflection, however, study participants were more likely to categorize the same ambiguous faces with the known mixed-race parentage as "multiracial."

"Ironically, when judgments about the ambiguous faces were based on the first, immediate reaction, the explicit information about biracial ancestry increased black categorizations, whereas when the judgments were more deliberate, this same information increased multiracial categorizations," Peery said.

The study highlights the legacy of hypodescent in racial categorization in the U.S. According to hypodescent, a child of mixed-race ancestry is assigned to the race of what society considers the socially subordinate parent. Historically, mixed-race children in slave societies were most commonly assigned to the race of their non-Caucasian parent. In the most extreme manifestation of hypodescent in the United States, the one-drop rule holds that if a person has one drop of black blood, he or she is considered to be black.

"Progress in recognizing complex racial identities has been slow in coming," Peery noted. It was not until 2000 that people were allowed to identify with more than one race on U.S. Census forms.

Given the increased attention to multiracial people today and efforts to allow them to identify with all parts of their racial identity, many believe that hypodescent is an outdated rule in racial categorization.

"The question of how ordinary people categorize multiracial people remains a complicated and timely question," said Peery. "Our study suggests that knowledge of mixed-race ancestry may still serve, at a reflexive or automatic level, to highlight only one aspect of a multiracial person's identity -- the minority aspect."

Right or wrong, the automatic relegating of multiracial people to one racial category is very much a part of American history, Peery said.

"The good news," she says, "is that we can look to the increased awareness of a multiracial population in the U.S. as a sign of possible changes to come in racial categorization."

Source: Northwestern University

Explore further: Physicist creates ice cream that changes colors as it's licked

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Schools in US growing more separate and still unequal

May 19, 2014

(Phys.org) —Sixty years after the U.S. Supreme Court ended "separate but equal" in public schools, the UCLA Civil Rights Project/Proyecto Derechos Civiles released a report today showing the segregation ...

Census: Whites no longer a majority in US by 2043

Dec 12, 2012

White people will no longer make up a majority of Americans by 2043, according to new census projections. That's part of a historic shift that already is reshaping the nation's schools, workforce and electorate, and is redefining ...

The Obamas and the new politics of race

Jun 05, 2012

With the 2012 US presidential election campaign in full swing, the meaning and significance of Barack Obama and his presidency are once again in the spotlight. Has the election of Barack Obama served as the watershed moment ...

Racial identity is changing among Latinos

Dec 26, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- In a paper published in Social Science Research, USC Dornsife’s Amon Emeka and Jody Agius Vallejo look at why many people with Latin American ancestry are not identifying themselves as His ...

Recommended for you

Shrinking dinosaurs evolved into flying birds (w/ Video)

17 hours ago

A new study involving scientists from the University of Southampton has revealed how massive, meat-eating, ground-dwelling dinosaurs evolved into agile flying birds: they just kept shrinking and shrinking, ...

Congressional rift over environment influences public

21 hours ago

American citizens are increasingly divided over the issue of environmental protection and seem to be taking their cue primarily from Congress, finds new research led by a Michigan State University scholar.

Rural loss and ruin can be avoided

Jul 31, 2014

An Australian Reconstruction Development Board needs to be established to help avoid more needless forcing of Australian farmers from their land, a QUT economist has said.

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Mauricio
4 / 5 (1) Oct 10, 2008
This fact has been known long time ago, is called the "one drop" "theory". Supposedly one drop of black blood make you black (or any "inferior" race would do).

However, non-black Hispanics have rights that black Hispanics don't. For example, non-black Hispanics can graduate from any university program they want. Blacks Hispanics can't.

Humans in average are not very intelligent. People can't have many categories in their mind, it is too much to handle. That is why prejudice and stereotypes exist....
WillB
not rated yet Oct 10, 2008
They also exist because of survival traits. Living in an inner city where the majority of the crime is committed by a certain race. Some people learn to adapt and see all people that race as aggressive as a defense mechanism.

My personal way of telling if a person is black is by the color of their skin. :) And certain facial features.
bobwinners
3 / 5 (1) Oct 10, 2008
It is unfortunate that one of the traits we continue to inherit from our ancestors is our clanishness.
We differentiate at shallow levels not only by skin color, but by family, religion, location and and even profession.
Sad. Education is making a dent in this unfortunate trait, but it is slow and probably will never eliminate prejudice entirely.
By the way, prejudice is universal among human cultures. In fact, Americans are probably less prone to it than members of other societies.
jpg366
not rated yet Oct 11, 2008
What others call us is one thing. What we call ourselves is another. "Black" is currently a favored minority when considering government programs and affirmitive action. Tribalism is history and present. What I find interesting is newspaper and magazine photos. They can make someone appear as dark or as light as they wish. I wonder why they do this.