Study shows red pen use by instructors leads to more negative response

Jan 23, 2013 by Bob Yirka report

(Phys.org)—Sociologists Richard Dukes and Heather Albanesi of the University of Colorado claim in a paper they've had published in The Social Science Journal that when teachers use a red pen to add comments to student papers, students perceive them more negatively than if they use another color pen.

Red pens have traditionally been used by teachers when grading papers – ostensibly to make their comments and markings stand out from the original work – but this new research suggests that the use of a red pen may convey unintentional .

To find out if markings in red had any measureable impact on students, the two researchers enlisted the assistance of 199 – each was given four versions of an already graded essay by an unknown instructor. The graded remarks were deemed as high or low in quality with some written in red, others in blue. The students were asked to read the essay and the remarks given by the instructor and then to rate how they felt about what the instructor had written and to suggest what grade they would have given the essay. They were also asked how they felt about the instructor that had written the original remarks. After they'd finished with their opinions, each was also given a designed to provide the researchers with more concrete data.

In analyzing their results, the researchers found that the student volunteers didn't seem to be impacted one way or another by pen color when they agreed with the instructor's comments and grade. But when they disagreed, there were definitely some differences – mainly negative. When the instructors' comments were written in red versus blue the volunteers judged them more harshly and as a result, rated them lower in "bedside manner." Overall, they say, the volunteers didn't seem to judge the quality of the comments any differently – their were aimed at the person that had written the remarks when they wrote in red ink.

Dukes and Heather theorize that red ink is akin to using all caps when writing e-mail or text messages – it's like shouting at a person and those on the other end quite naturally feel a little bit abused and respond by growing angry or sad, which, they note, doesn't really promote the learning process. They suggest instructors stop using red pens and go with a shade of blue instead.

Explore further: A two generation lens: Current state policies fail to support families with young children

More information: Richard L. Dukes, Heather Albanesi, Seeing red: Quality of an essay, color of the grading pen, and student reactions to the grading process, The Social Science Journal, Available online 23 October 2012, dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.soscij.2012.07.005

Abstract
Undergraduates read one of the four vignettes depicting a student essay on social stratification, comments by the instructor, and a grade. In a 2 × 2 factorial design we manipulate independent variables of quality of the essay and color of the grading pen. We test hypotheses that a higher quality essay and an aqua grading pen results in higher teaching evaluations. MANOVA show no statistically significant differences on two instrumental evaluation items: instructor is knowledgeable and organized. Statistically significant differences are observed for quality of the essay and color of the grading pen on three expressive items of instructor is nice, enthusiastic, and has rapport with students. Results suggest that instructors should use a grading pen of a neutral color.

Related Stories

Study: Seasoned profs prepare students for advanced learning

Jun 10, 2010

Highly credentialed and experienced professors are better at preparing students for long-term academic success than their less-experienced counterparts, but that ability isn't necessarily reflected in their students' teaching ...

Contracts in the classroom

Jan 13, 2012

While contracts are an indispensable tool in the modern workplace, a new study has found that they may also be very effective in contemporary classrooms. According to a new article published in SAGE Open, courses in which ...

I feel like a different person

Apr 14, 2009

Scientists have long been interested in the interplay of emotions and identity, and some have recently focused on cultural identity. One's heritage would seem to be especially stable and impervious to change, simply because ...

Toshiba announces new printer that uses erasable toner

Mar 09, 2012

(PhysOrg.com) -- Recognizing that the much heralded paperless office hasn’t really come about as many expected, Toshiba has taken a new approach to cutting costs, creating a system whereby regular printer ...

Recommended for you

Scholar tracks the changing world of gay sexuality

Sep 19, 2014

With same-sex marriage now legalized in 19 states and laws making it impossible to ban homosexuals from serving in the military, gay, lesbian and bisexual people are now enjoying more freedoms and rights than ever before.

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Cin5456
5 / 5 (2) Jan 23, 2013
This would seem obvious. When grading essays as a tutor I use a green or purple pen. Both are considered friendly colors and sometimes bring a smile from the students I tutor. Blue is too conventional to stand out and does not give emphasis to the grading process. Students will ignore marks or suggestions in blue more often because it is a color they themselves use. Suggestions need to stand out for them to be followed. The other part of written comments that needs to be of concern is legibility. As a student in grad school it was frequently difficult to decipher comments. I suspect readability is closely related to how many papers on which the teacher needs to comment. Larger classrooms means rushed comments and less legibility. In that case, it does not matter what is written or what color pen is used. They can't be read anyway, so the student will not correct the problem in future papers.
rwinners
not rated yet Jan 24, 2013
otoh, red is a violent color... and also the color of fresh blood.