Learned, not innate human intuition: Study finds twist to the story of the number line

Apr 25, 2012
This image shows a person confirming a Yupno participant's understanding of numbers. Credit: Courtesy of Embodied Cognition Lab, UC San Diego.

Tape measures. Rulers. Graphs. The gas gauge in your car, and the icon on your favorite digital device showing battery power. The number line and its cousins – notations that map numbers onto space and often represent magnitude – are everywhere. Most adults in industrialized societies are so fluent at using the concept, we hardly think about it. We don't stop to wonder: Is it "natural"? Is it cultural?

Now, challenging a mainstream scholarly position that the number-line concept is innate, a study suggests it is learned.

The study, published in April 25, is based on experiments with an indigenous group in Papua New Guinea. It was led by Rafael Nunez, director of the Embodied Cognition Lab and associate professor of cognitive science in the UC San Diego Division of Social Sciences.

"Influential scholars have advanced the thesis that many of the building blocks of mathematics are 'hard-wired' in the human mind through millions of years of evolution. And a number of different sources of evidence do suggest that humans naturally associate numbers with space," said Nunez, coauthor of "Where Mathematics Comes From" and co-director of the newly established Fields Cognitive Science Network at the Fields Institute for Research in Mathematical Sciences.

"Our study shows, for the first time, that the number-line concept is not a 'universal intuition' but a particular cultural tool that requires training and education to master," Nunez said. "Also, we document that precise number concepts can exist independently of linear or other metric-driven spatial representations."

Nunez and the research team, which includes UC San Diego cognitive science doctoral alumnus Kensy Cooperrider, now at Case Western Reserve University, and Jurg Wassmann, an anthropologist at the University of Heidelberg who has studied the indigenous group for 25 years, traveled to a remote area of the Finisterre Range of Papua New Guinea to conduct the study.

The upper Yupno valley, like much of Papua New Guinea, has no roads. The research team flew in on a four-seat plane and hiked in the rest of the way, armed with solar-powered equipment, since the valley has no electricity.

The indigenous Yupno in this area number some 5,000, spread over many small villages. They are subsistence farmers. Most have little formal schooling, if any at all. While there is no native writing system, there is a native counting system, with precise number concepts and specific words for numbers greater than 20. But there doesn't seem to be any evidence of measurement of any sort, Nunez said, "not with numbers, or feet or elbows."

Neither Hard-Wired nor "Out There"

Nunez and colleagues asked Yupno adults of the village of Gua to complete a task that has been used widely by researchers interested in basic mathematical intuitions and where they come from. In the original task, people are shown a line and are asked to place numbers onto the line according to their size, with "1" going on the left endpoint and "10" (or sometimes "100" or "1000") going on the right endpoint. Since many in the study group were illiterate, Nunez and colleagues followed previous studies and adapted the task using groups of one to 10 dots, tones and the spoken words instead of written numbers.

After confirming the Yupno participants' understanding of numbers with piles of oranges, the researchers gave the number-line task to 14 adults with no schooling and six adults with some degree of formal schooling. There was also a control group of participants in California.

The researchers found that unschooled Yupno adults placed numbers on the line (or mapped numbers onto space), but they did it in a categorical manner, using systematically only the endpoints: putting small numbers on the left endpoint and the mid-size and large numbers on the right, ignoring the extension of the line — an essential component of the number-line concept. Schooled Yupno adults used the line's extension but not quite as evenly as adults in California.

"Mathematics all over the world – from Europe to Asia to the Americas – is largely taught dogmatically, as objective fact, black and white, right/wrong," Nunez said. "But our work shows that there are meaningful human ideas in math, ingenious solutions and designs that have been mediated by writing and notational devices, like the number line. Perhaps we should think about bringing the human saga to the subject – instead of continuing to treat it romantically, as the 'universal language' it's not. Mathematics is neither hardwired, nor 'out there.'"

Out-of-Body Time

The researchers ran several experiments while in Gua, Papua New Guinea, including those that examine another fundamental concept: time.

When talking about past, present and future, people all over the world show a tendency to conceive of these notions spatially, Nunez said. The most common spatial pattern is the one found in the English-speaking world, in which people talk about the future as being in front of them and the past behind, encapsulated, for example, in expressions such as the "week ahead" and "way back when." (In earlier research, Nunez found that the Aymara of the Andes seem to do the reverse, placing the past in front and the future behind.)

In their time study with the Yupno, now in press at the journal Cognition, Nunez and colleagues find that the Yupno don't use their bodies as reference points for time – but rather their valley's slope and terrain. Analysis of their gestures suggests they co-locate the present with themselves, as do all previously studied groups. (Picture for a moment how you probably point down at the ground when you talk about "now.") But, regardless of which way they are facing at the moment, the Yupno point uphill when talking about the future and downhill when talking about the past.

Interestingly and also very unusually, Nunez said, the Yupno seem to think of past and future not as being arranged on a line, such as the familiar "time line" we have in many Western cultures, but as having a three-dimensional bent shape that reflects the valley's terrain.

"These findings suggest that how we think about abstract concepts is even more flexible than previously thought and is profoundly affected by language, culture and environment," said Nunez.

"Our familiar notions on 'fundamental' concepts such as time and are so deeply ingrained that they feel natural to us, as though they couldn't be any other way," added former graduate student Cooperrider. "When confronted with radically different ways of construing experience, we can no longer take for granted our own. Ultimately, no way is more or less 'natural' than the Yupno way."

Explore further: 'Moral victories' might spare you from losing again

More information: Nunez R, Cooperrider K, Wassmann J (2012) Number Concepts without Number Lines in an Indigenous Group of Papua New Guinea. PLoS ONE 7(4):e35662. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0035662 . dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0035662

Related Stories

Child's 'mental number line' affects memory for numbers

Sep 09, 2010

As children in Western cultures grow, they learn to place numbers on a mental number line, with smaller numbers to the left and spaced further apart than the larger numbers on the right. Then the number line changes to become ...

You can't do the math without the words

Feb 21, 2012

Most people learn to count when they are children. Yet surprisingly, not all languages have words for numbers. A recent study published in the journal of Cognitive Science shows that a few tongues lack number words and as ...

'Time' not necessarily deeply rooted in our brains

May 20, 2011

(Medical Xpress) -- Hidden away in the Amazonian rainforest a small tribe have successfully managed what so many dream of being able to do – to ignore the pressures of time so successfully that they don’t ...

Recommended for you

A word in your ear, but make it snappy

10 hours ago

To most, crocodiles conjure images of sharp teeth, powerful jaws and ferocious, predatory displays – but they are certainly not famous for their hearing abilities. However, this could all change, as new ...

Understanding the economics of human trafficking

11 hours ago

Although Europe is one of the strictest regions in the world when it comes to guaranteeing the respect of human rights, the number of people trafficked to or within the EU still amounts to several hundred ...

User comments : 9

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Tangent2
2.3 / 5 (3) Apr 25, 2012
"Perhaps we should think about bringing the human saga to the subject instead of continuing to treat it romantically, as the 'universal language' it's not. "

Mathematics is far more prevalent throughout societies rather than not, this is why it would be considered the 'universal language'.
marraco
2.3 / 5 (3) Apr 25, 2012
What puzzles me is how complex numbers describe 2D space so perfectly, but there is no 3D version of a complex number.
Terriva
1 / 5 (2) Apr 25, 2012
Primitive nations have no idea about higher numbers or right angled geometry - I presume, it illustrates the actual intuitiveness and/or cultural dependency of these concepts sufficiently.
but there is no 3D version of a complex number
It is
Deathclock
2 / 5 (5) Apr 25, 2012
Of course it is learned almost everything is learned
Smashin_Z_1885
1 / 5 (2) Apr 26, 2012
Marraco, what are you trying to convey here? When you say there is no 3D version of a complex number, I am confused. Because of course 3 dimensional geometry can EASILY be represented. So I'm not entirely sure what you are trying to say there.
Vendicar_Decarian
0.2 / 5 (36) Apr 26, 2012
Innumeracy, illiteracy and stagnation is what you get without Government to set standards and expectations for the people.
88HUX88
not rated yet Apr 26, 2012
The Chinese use up and down, for last week (shang = up) and for next week (xia = down)
Lurker2358
1 / 5 (2) Apr 29, 2012
While there is no native writing system, there is a native counting system, with precise number concepts and specific words for numbers greater than 20. But there doesn't seem to be any evidence of measurement of any sort, Nunez said, "not with numbers, or feet or elbows."


Yeah, that puts them about half a step above the Aymara, and still nowhere near smart enough to have built Puma Punku, or even the younger monuments around it. Not even on the same continent, just saying, don't try to fool us into thinking these people could have made ancient monuments.

It's possible the surviving Aymara are just left-over tribal survivors from the conquistadors invasions. Think about it, if you were a child or a teen and your country was invaded, just about the time the civilization had writing and some form of geometry, but you weren't fully educated, and you end up in the woods just you and a few scattered family members, well, you'd lose whatever knowledge and technology there was.
Lurker2358
1 / 5 (2) Apr 29, 2012
The only real way to help these backwards cultures is to pretty much adopt their children and give them a real education and upbringing, or else marry into it, in which case you'd have to be filthy rich, since you'll be spending the next half of your life educating your spouse.

The past couple hundred years shows that pathetic attempts by missionary groups and even non-religious charity groups to help these people reform and improve themselves has all failed.

Not only that, in many cases, the anthropologists take a "hands off" approach, and would prefer to study them "objectively" like animals, rather than to use their skills to help train them to better themselves.

This entire screwed up situation is a sadistic joke played on these peoples by the modern world, which sits by and watches them like a novelty or a pet in a zoo. It's as bad as the Stanford Prison Experiment.