No crystal ball necessary: Scientists can accurately predict leadership emergence

Oct 03, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Dutch scientists at VU University Amsterdam are able to quite accurately predict the emergence of leaders in domains such as politics and the military. They developed a model of leadership emergence based on the interaction between our biological properties and social environment.

The model suggests that being selected as a leader is for a large part dependent on a match between physical attributes (such as the face), the message the leader conveys, and the perceived situation requirements in which the leader has to make decisions. For instance, this model has shown that in times where the of threat is great, potential leaders with a masculine face emphasizing this threat in their message are most likely to be elected as leader. On the other hand, potential leaders with a feminine face may be better off profiling themselves as a peacemaker, and attempt to make the majority of perceive the need for in the social network – rather than conflict – as the most important and beneficial need.

Of the physical traits the face is particularly important. A masculine face has thick eyebrows, a broad nose and jaw, and small lips and small eyes and is associated with higher levels of testosterone. Likewise, higher levels of testosterone are generally associated with more dominant and aggressive behavior. Spisak: “This is potentially one reason why we associate masculine features with conflict and war and feminine features with cooperation and peace”.

In part funded by the United States Office of Naval Research Global (ONRG), the research was designed to investigate systematic methods for seeking peaceful cooperation with local people in conflict areas. “Our model shows that it’s best not to come out with an army vehicle packed with heavily armed soldiers,” says lead researcher Brian R. Spisak. “Instead, select a unit of individuals that display less hostile physical characteristics. If they also take off their helmets and lay their machineguns aside, the perceived level of threat by the local population will be reduced. This, in tandem with encouraging the emergence of more amicable leaders, can greatly increase the chance of peaceful cooperation.”

In collaboration with VU University colleague Alexei Sharpanskykh, Spisak developed an artificial intelligent model that shows when a leader can count on support. In fact, they were able to accurately mimic changing voter favorability ratings for the 2004 and 2008 US Presidential General Elections and predict the outcome of both elections within one percent. Spisak: “This way we could show why presidential candidate John McCain was more popular than Barack Obama for a short time around the anniversary of 9/11 regardless of the so-called ‘Palin bump’. The military image and more masculine physical traits of McCain perhaps matched with an acute feeling of a terrorist threat around the remembrance of 9/11. But a few weeks later this feeling likely decreased and the overall image of McCain no longer fit, and Obama regained his overall popularity with ‘Change’. With our model we could accurately predict who would win the elections.”

Explore further: College education not always about what you have

More information: The research results have been published in two papers:

1. Facing the situation: Testing a biosocial contingency model of leadership in intergroup relations using masculine and feminine faces (The Leadership Quarterly – special issue on the biology of leadership, in press, available online 10 September 2011).

2. An agent-based evolutionary model of leadership (Proceedings of the Third IEEE International Conference on Social Computing, 9-11 October 2011).

Provided by VU University Amsterdam

not rated yet
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Study finds 'masculine' women get more promotions at work

Jan 27, 2011

Women who demonstrate stereotypical masculine traits should be mindful of their behavior if they want to get ahead in the workplace. That is the finding of researchers at George Mason University and Stanford University who ...

How leaders explain unpopular decisions: study

Apr 05, 2011

When bad news needs to be shared, management scholars have shown that the response is influenced by how bad the news is, what is said, and who says it. New research by Terry Cobb, management associate professor in the Pamplin ...

Leadership success linked to social status

Feb 08, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- People tend to follow leaders they perceive as high-status individuals and typically reject the take-charge efforts of people considered lower-status or misfits, according to a research team that included ...

How leaders evolve

May 05, 2011

Researchers have developed a mathematical model that explores how leaders and followers emerge in different circumstances and predicts the most likely personality types of those leaders.

Testosterone levels dictate attraction

Sep 15, 2008

Women with higher levels of testosterone are more attracted to masculine looking men like celebrity beefcakes Russell Crowe and Daniel Craig.

Recommended for you

College education not always about what you have

13 hours ago

Students who have books and computers at home, who take extramural cultural classes, and whose parents give advice and take part in school activities are most likely to enroll for a four-year college degree. Also, more American ...

Are emotions and eating a marketer's dream?

21 hours ago

Both research and popular media tell us that emotions and eating are intrinsically related. How many times have we seen a character in a TV show reaching for the ice-cream tub when feeling particularly down ...

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

rwinners
not rated yet Oct 03, 2011
Our model shows that its best not to come out with an army vehicle packed with heavily armed soldiers, says lead researcher Brian R. Spisak. Instead, select a unit of individuals that display less hostile physical characteristics. If they also take off their helmets and lay their machineguns aside, the perceived level of threat by the local population will be reduced. This, in tandem with encouraging the emergence of more amicable leaders, can greatly increase the chance of peaceful cooperation.

The authors are free to volunteer for this duty.
Birger
not rated yet Oct 04, 2011
Our model shows that its best not to come out with an army vehicle packed with heavily armed soldiers, says lead researcher Brian R. Spisak. Instead, select a unit of individuals that display less hostile physical characteristics. If they also take off their helmets and lay their machineguns aside, the perceived level of threat by the local population will be reduced. This, in tandem with encouraging the emergence of more amicable leaders, can greatly increase the chance of peaceful cooperation.

The authors are free to volunteer for this duty.


The article is about choosing leaders, not about handling conflicts. Think before posting.