Cracks found in shuttle fuel tank, not just foam (Update)

Nov 10, 2010 By MARCIA DUNN , AP Aerospace Writer
In this picture made available by NASA, a technician examines the area of the space shuttle Discovery's external tank where foam was removed to study the source a cracks on the tank in Cape Canaveral, Fla. on Wednesday, Nov. 10, 2010. (AP Photo/NASA, Troy Cryder)

(AP) -- NASA discovered cracks in Discovery's fuel tank Wednesday, an added problem that will complicate trying to launch the space shuttle on its final voyage this year.

The two cracks - each 9 inches long - were found on the exterior of the aluminum tank, beneath a larger crack in the insulating foam that covers the 15-story tank. The cracks are in an area that holds instruments, not fuel.

NASA spokesman Allard Beutel said engineers believe the tank can be repaired at the launch pad, although it's never been tried before. It's unclear, though, whether the work can be done in time to meet a Nov. 30 launch attempt.

Discovery was grounded Friday by a hydrogen gas leak that cropped up during fueling Friday. It was the latest in a weeklong string of technical and weather postponements. A 20-inch crack in the foam was discovered soon after the last countdown was halted.

NASA managers said at the time they did not know if the foam crack itself would have postponed liftoff. But on Wednesday, officials said they will not attempt another launch until the foam and tank are patched.

The space agency has been cautious about fuel-tank foam ever since a slab broke off during Columbia's 2003 launch and pierced the left wing. The shuttle was destroyed during re-entry.

Discovery - NASA's oldest and most-traveled shuttle - must be flying by Dec. 6 or so, otherwise the flight to the International Space Station will be off until approximately February. That's because the Russians need to launch a new station crew in mid-December, creating a blackout period for a visiting shuttle. Then early next year, there is a series of unmanned supply ships, as well as a span of unacceptable solar angles.

The cracks in the ribbed section of the tank - the so-called central intertank region - were discovered as workers removed pieces of the damaged foam for analysis. This region joins the upper oxygen and lower hydrogen chambers that make up the rust-colored tank.

Since that section contains only instruments, no explosive fuel would have leaked, had the shuttle launched with the defects.

Beutel said it's possible NASA may have unknowingly launched shuttles in the past with these type of cracks in the tank. If it wasn't for the cracks traveling up to the surface of the foam this time, they would have gone unnoticed, he noted. The tank is discarded once a shuttle reaches orbit and breaks up while plunging back through the atmosphere.

Similar cracks have been fixed before at the tank production facility in New Orleans, Beutel said. But the work has never been attempted at Kennedy Space Center, least of all on the launch pad. He said engineers are looking at what it would take to fix the tank at the pad.

Repair work is continuing, meanwhile, on the unrelated hydrogen gas leak. The leak occurred on the tank, at the connection point for the vent arm. Workers are replacing seals and other parts at this location.

The flight by Discovery is currently the next-to-last for the shuttle program, winding down after nearly 30 years. One other mission remains on the official lineup, by Endeavour at the end of February. That final mission almost certainly would be delayed if Discovery is bumped into 2010.

Explore further: Spacecraft closing in on Pluto hits speed bump, but recovers

More information: NASA:


Related Stories

NASA: progress studying shuttle tank foam

Oct 17, 2005

NASA engineers say they are closer to resolving the problem of large chunks of foam insulation falling off space shuttle external fuel tanks during launch.

Shuttle launch planned for next month

Jun 09, 2006

The U.S. space agency plans to launch the shuttle Discovery next month, but some engineers feel it should wait until all safety concerns have been resolved.

NASA still plans May shuttle launch

Mar 01, 2006

NASA officials say they hope to launch the next space shuttle in May but admit a major technical problem might delay lift-off.

NASA's Statement on Foam Shedding From External Tank

Jul 28, 2005

NASA engineers are evaluating the loss of a large piece of insulation foam from the Space Shuttle Discovery’s external fuel tank during Tuesday's launch. Based on initial assessments, the foam -- which appears to measure ...

Space shuttle foam problem is studied

Aug 10, 2005

The fate of the space shuttle program reportedly rests with engineers and scientists studying problems encountered during the recent Discovery mission.

Recommended for you

What is the newest planet?

13 hours ago

With astronomers discovering new planets and other celestial objects all the time, you may be wondering what the newest planet to be discovered is. Well, that depends on your frame of reference. If we are ...

Catching Earth at aphelion

13 hours ago

Do you feel a little… distant today? The day after the 4th of July weekend brings with it the promise of barbecue leftovers and discount fireworks. It also sees our fair planet at aphelion, or its farthest ...

Opportunity's 7th Mars winter to include new study area

14 hours ago

Operators of NASA's Mars Exploration Rover Opportunity plan to drive the rover into a valley this month where Opportunity will be active through the long-lived rover's seventh Martian winter, examining outcrops ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Nov 10, 2010
That's a scary find !!

But better now than during launch...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.