Study raises red flag over 'green' claims

Oct 26, 2010 By Wendy Koch

More than 95 percent of consumer products marketed as "green," including all toys surveyed, make misleading or inaccurate claims, says a report Tuesday.

The number of products claiming to be green increased 73 percent since 2009, according to a survey by TerraChoice, an Ottawa-based marketing firm owned mostly by Underwriters Laboratory of Canada. The UL network does independent product testing and certification.

"The biggest sin is making claims without any proof," says Scot Case of UL Environment, adding companies want consumers to "just trust them." The report finds "vagueness" is the second-leading problem (a claimed it was "mother-earth approved") in "greenwashing" -- a term that refers to misleading green claims.

The report comes as the is proposing stricter advertising rules. In updating its Green Guides, last revised in 1998, it warns companies not to make blanket claims such as "eco-friendly" or cite unqualified certifications (a paper towel product once claimed it "fights ").

"Consumers should look for more specificity," says James Kohm of FTC's Bureau of Consumer Protection. He says general claims are difficult to prove.

For its "Sins of Greenwashing" report, TerraChoice visited 34 stores in the U.S. and Canada from March to May and surveyed 5,296 products that make environmental claims. The products included toys, baby care items, building materials, housewares, consumer electronics and health goods.

A skyrocketing share of products claim to be free of phthalates, chemicals used to make plastics, and or bisphenol A, an estrogen-like chemical.

The report also found:

• A small but rising share of products make accurate green claims -- 4.5 percent this year, up from 2 percent in 2009 and 1 percent in 2007, when the first survey was done.

• "Big box" retailers are more apt to sell products with accurate claims than boutique stores. They may have more influence on their suppliers, Case says.

• Products such as building materials that have more experience in the green marketplace make fewer misleading claims than those such as toys and baby products that are new to it.

"Those in the environmental space for a while are learning from their mistakes," Case says.

The report shows progress, however slight, is occurring, says Thomas Lyon, director of the Erb Institute for Sustainable Enterprise at the University of Michigan.

Still, he says the growing green marketplace is tricky for consumers. "There are all these fake labels," Lyon says. "You still have to do your homework."

Explore further: Physicist creates ice cream that changes colors as it's licked

5 /5 (2 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

FDA cites claims on 2 green tea beverages

Sep 07, 2010

(AP) -- Federal health regulators have issued warnings to the makers of Canada Dry ginger ale and Lipton tea for making unsubstantiated nutritional claims about their green tea-flavored beverages.

FDA concerned about some STD medications

Mar 10, 2008

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has warned six companies to stop marketing unapproved drugs for treating and preventing sexually transmitted diseases.

Carbohydrate claims can mislead consumers

Sep 07, 2010

Food manufacturers advertise a variety of foods on grocery store shelves by using nutrient claims on the front of packaging. A study in the September/October issue of the Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior evaluates ...

Recommended for you

F1000Research brings static research figures to life

Jul 30, 2014

F1000Research today published new research from Bjorn Brembs, professor of neurogenetics at the Institute of Zoology, Universitaet Regensburg, in Germany, with a proof-of-concept figure allowing readers and reviewers to run ...

How science can beat the flawed metric that rules it

Jul 30, 2014

In order to improve something, we need to be able to measure its quality. This is true in public policy, in commercial industries, and also in science. Like other fields, science has a growing need for quantitative ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Quantum_Conundrum
not rated yet Oct 26, 2010
I wish there were much more stringent rules on all forms of advertisement regarding false claims, false references, and other gimmicks.

9 out of 10 doctors recommend Tylenol over it's competitors.
9 out of 10 doctors recommend Advil over it's competitors.
7 out of 10 doctors recommend Aleve over it's competitors.

"This is the best weight loss program ever!"
"Extenze is guaranteed to make a certain male organ grow."

People selling goods and services which do not live up to reasonable margins of error of what they are claiming should be prosecuted for fraud.

This goes for everything from computers, video games, car engine add-ons, exercise machines, food, medicine, and anything else.