Failing the sniff test: Researchers find new way to spot fraud

November 9, 2009

Companies that commit fraud can find innovative ways to fudge the numbers, making it hard to tell something is wrong by just looking at their financial statements. But research from North Carolina State University unveils a new warning system that sees through accounting tricks by evaluating things that are easily verifiable, such as the number of employees or the square footage that a company owns. If a company says that its profits are up, but these nonfinancial measures (NFMs) are down, that's a sign something is probably wrong.

"Some companies commit financial statement , and a good portion of those overstate their revenue," says Dr. Joe Brazel, an assistant professor of accounting at NC State and co-author of the research. "They're able to do that because they can manipulate the accounting. But there are NFMs that can't be manipulated as easily." These NFMs include the number of employees, as well as industry-specific measures, such as the square footage of facilities in the manufacturing sector, the number of retail outlets in the retail sector or the number of hospital visits in the hospital industry.

Brazel explains that companies may fraudulently claim inflated revenues in order to meet and maintain, or improve, their - as well as protecting company management from criticism.

But, Brazel says, "when these firms commit fraud, we found a huge gap between their reported revenue growth and related NFMs - their revenue was up, but the NFMs were either flat or declining. And when you looked at their competitors, you see revenue growth and NFMs closely correlated. So when you see that gap, it's a red flag - you need to take a closer look."

For example, Brazel says that researchers found a difference of approximately 4 percent between revenue growth and employee growth in companies that did not commit fraud. The difference between revenue growth and employee growth in fraudulent companies was 20 percent. "It's pretty obvious, when you look at it," Brazel says.

Furthermore, the NFM data are easy to find. Brazel explains that each company's NFMs and revenue numbers are disclosed in the same financial filings, which the company is required to submit each year to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.

The researchers evaluated 220 companies when evaluating employee growth versus revenue growth - 110 companies that were known to have committed fraud between 1994 and 2002, and 110 that had not. Similarly, they looked at 100 companies when evaluating other NFMs, 50 fraudulent and 50 that had not committed fraud.

The researchers are now in the process of developing an online tool that will perform the NFM analysis, as well as conducting experimental studies with auditors to help detect fraud and with investors to help make wise investment decisions.

More information: The paper, "Using Nonfinancial Measures to Assess Fraud Risk," was co-authored by Brazel, Dr. Keith Jones of George Mason University and Dr. Mark Zimbelman of Brigham Young University. The work will be published in the Journal of Accounting Research later this year.

Source: North Carolina State University (news : web)

Explore further: New accounting rules mean boost to Apple, others (Update)

Related Stories

New accounting rules mean boost to Apple, others (Update)

September 23, 2009

(AP) -- Regulators approved changes to accounting rules Wednesday that in the short term will make sales and profits seem higher at technology companies selling certain gadgets that blend hardware and software.

Family firms better than other businesses

June 21, 2006

A Texas A&M University study has become one of the first to examine the competitiveness and stability of family businesses and finds both factors good.

Global telecom growth expected 2006

December 17, 2005

Worldwide telecom-industry growth is expected in 2006, a new industry study reported Friday. Global telecommunications industry revenue will reach $1.2 trillion by the close of 2006, with continued strong growth in wireless ...

Recommended for you

Ancient parrot fossil found in Siberia

October 26, 2016

(—A Russian paleontologist has discovered a parrot fossil uncovered in Siberia several years ago—the first evidence of parrots living in Asia. In his paper published in Biology Letters, Nikita Zelenkov describes ...

Ancient burials suggestive of blood feuds

October 24, 2016

There is significant variation in how different cultures over time have dealt with the dead. Yet, at a very basic level, funerals in the Sonoran Desert thousands of years ago were similar to what they are today. Bodies of ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Nov 09, 2009
Many years ago In had a local competitor that seemed to be going great guns. He was getting bank loans and growing like crazy. Turned out to be a fraud - he was telling the banks he had much more income than he really had.

I had read newspaper stories about his growth and they just didn't make sense. It was a computer service business and every employee would have had to be billing six figures to be making the money he claimed. This was early '80's: you'd need to have every employing working 80 hours a week - it just didn't track, so I wasn't surprised when it all collapsed.
not rated yet Nov 10, 2009
cool. Even if they (fraudsters) know they're being watched on this variable it would be a easy and cost effective way to de-incentivize the fraud by making the cost of fraudulent activity more expensive and less rewarding.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.