Time travel is possible – but only if you have an object with infinite mass

December 13, 2018 by Gaurav Khanna, The Conversation
The Doctor used the this time machine, called the TARDIS, to travel through space and time on the BBC television show Dr. Who. Credit: Babbel1996 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA

The concept of time travel has always captured the imagination of physicists and laypersons alike. But is it really possible? Of course it is. We're doing it right now, aren't we? We are all traveling into the future one second at a time.

But that was not what you were thinking. Can we much further into the future? Absolutely. If we could travel close to the speed of light, or in the proximity of a black hole, would slow down enabling us to travel arbitrarily far into the future. The really interesting question is whether we can travel back into the past.

I am a physics professor at the University of Massachusetts, Dartmouth, and first heard about the notion of time travel when I was 7, from a 1980 episode of Carl Sagan's classic TV series, "Cosmos." I decided right then that someday, I was going to pursue a deep study of the theory that underlies such creative and remarkable ideas: Einstein's relativity. Twenty years later, I emerged with a Ph.D. in the field and have been an active researcher in the theory ever since.

Now, one of my doctoral students has just published a paper in the journal Classical and Quantum Gravity that describes how to build a time machine using a very simple construction.

Closed time-like curves

Einstein's general theory of relativity allows for the possibility of warping time to such a high degree that it actually folds upon itself, resulting in a time loop. Imagine you're traveling along this loop; that means that at some point, you'd end up at a moment in the past and begin experiencing the same moments since, all over again – a bit like deja vu, except you wouldn't realize it. Such constructs are often referred to as "closed time-like curves" or CTCs in the research literature, and popularly referred to as "time machines." Time machines are a byproduct of effective faster-than-light travel schemes and understanding them can improve our understanding of how the universe works.

Here we see a time loop. Green shows the short way through wormhole. Red shows the long way through normal space. Since the travel time on the green path could be very small compared to the red, a wormhole can allow for the possibility of time travel. Credit: Panzi, CC BY-SA

Over the past few decades well-known physicists like Kip Thorne and Stephen Hawking produced seminal work on models related to time machines.

The general conclusion that has emerged from previous research, including Thorne's and Hawking's, is that nature forbids time loops. This is perhaps best explained in Hawking's "Chronology Protection Conjecture," which essentially says that nature doesn't allow for changes to its past history, thus sparing us from the paradoxes that can emerge if time travel were possible.

Perhaps the most well-known amongst these paradoxes that emerge due to time travel into the past is the so-called "grandfather paradox" in which a traveler goes back into the past and murders his own grandfather. This alters the course of history in a way that a contradiction emerges: The traveler was never born and therefore cannot exist. There have been many movie and novel plots based on the paradoxes that result from – perhaps some of the most popular ones being the "Back to the Future" movies and "Groundhog Day."

Exotic matter

Depending on the details, different physical phenomena may intervene to prevent closed time-like curves from developing in physical systems. The most common is the requirement for a particular type of "exotic" matter that must be present in order for a time loop to exist. Loosely speaking, exotic matter is matter that has negative mass. The problem is negative mass is not known to exist in nature.

An animation shows how Mallary’s time loop works. As the spacecraft enters the time loop, its future self appears as well, and one can trace back the positions of both at every moment afterwards. This animation is from the perspective of an external observer, who is watching the spacecraft enter and emerge from the time loop.

Caroline Mallary, a doctoral student at the University of Massachusetts Dartmouth has published a new model for a time machine in the journal Classical & Quantum Gravity. This new model does not require any negative mass exotic material and offers a very simple design.

Mallary's model consists of two super long cars – built of material that is not exotic, and have positive mass – parked in parallel. One car moves forward rapidly, leaving the other parked. Mallary was able to show that in such a setup, a time loop can be found in the space between the cars.

So can you build this in your backyard?

If you suspect there is a catch, you are correct. Mallary's model requires that the center of each car has infinite density. That means they contain objects – called singularities – with an infinite density, temperature and pressure. Moreover, unlike singularities that are present in the interior of black holes, which makes them totally inaccessible from the outside, the singularities in Mallary's model are completely bare and observable, and therefore have true physical effects.

Physicists don't expect such peculiar objects to exist in nature either. So, unfortunately a is not going to be available anytime soon. However, this work shows that physicists may have to refine their ideas about why closed time-like curves are forbidden.

Explore further: Stephen Hawking's final book suggests time travel may one day be possible – here's what to make of it

Related Stories

Time travel theory avoids grandfather paradox

July 21, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- The possibility of going back in time only to kill your ancestors and prevent your own birth has posed a serious problem for potential time travelers, not even considering the technical details of building ...

Recommended for you

Researchers capture an image of negative capacitance in action

January 21, 2019

For the first time ever, an international team of researchers imaged the microscopic state of negative capacitance. This novel result provides researchers with fundamental, atomistic insight into the physics of negative capacitance, ...

Toward ultrafast spintronics

January 21, 2019

Electronics have advanced through continuous improvements in microprocessor technology since the 1960s. However, this process of refinement is projected to stall in the near future due to constraints imposed by the laws of ...

Classic double-slit experiment in a new light

January 18, 2019

An international research team led by physicists from the University of Cologne has implemented a new variant of the basic double-slit experiment using resonant inelastic X-ray scattering at the European Synchrotron ESRF ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Dec 13, 2018
You can not travel into the future. If you could, then after a lifetime of trying you would be there by now, but you are still in the present, just where you always were.

The timeline is a human construct. When viewed objectively an event travels from the past to the future along a timeline of your own construction, but viewed subjectively (from here), you always remain in the present, you are the event, change occurs where you are now.

Thus it may be scientifically valid to observe the progression of an objectively observed event progressing along a time line, but it is not a valid nor true subjective observation as subjectively we are confined to the present and it is in the present, not the past, that we were born in and it is in the present, not the future, that we will die.
1 / 5 (1) Dec 15, 2018
I've had infinite mass and traveled back in time.

Using A Virtual Reality Headset.

I can only visit moments of time that I've previously captured with a black-hole camera
known as a 360video camera.

Amazing. TRY IT! search online for ThisIsMeInVR for instructions how to do it.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.