Parks help cities – but only if people use them

November 20, 2018 by Thaisa Way, The Conversation
Tiny Paley Park, surrounded by skyscrapers in New York City, introduced the concept of a ‘pocket park’ in dense urban centers. Credit: Aleksandr Zykov/Flickr, CC BY-SA

In cities, access to parks is strongly linked with better health for both people and neighborhoods.

Children suffer higher rates of obesity when they grow up in without a in easy reach. Because low-income neighborhoods have fewer green spaces, poorer children are most likely to face other health problems, too, including asthma due to poor air quality.

But access to is not the only ingredient in creating healthy communities, my research on urban landscapes shows. Parks are good for people only if people use them.

And that's a question of design.

What is a park?

The first truly public park – a green space paid for by public funds, on publicly owned land and intended to serve the public – was Birkenhead Park, near Liverpool, England. Designed by Joseph Paxton to improve the health of the poor, it opened in 1847 to a crowd of 10,000.

When landscape architect Frederick Law Olmsted visited Birkenhead in 1850, he was inspired to bring the idea home to "democratic America."

In 1857, he and architect Calvert Vaux won the competition to create Central Park in New York City. Their now iconic design – 750 acres of grassy lawns, trees and winding paths – came to define what Americans and Europeans alike have come to expect from a great urban park.

Olmsted would eventually design over 100 big, green parks, from Montreal and Buffalo to Louisville and beyond.

As cities commissioned ever more parks, an entire profession grew up around them.

Landscape architects built parks in big cities worldwide, each modified slightly to reflect local culture.

Americans, in particular, embraced sociologist W.E.B. Du Bois's belief that green space would "restore the bodies, minds, and spirits of urban dwellers weakened by the city's punishing environment."

Seattle’s Freeway Park: Inviting or sketchy? Credit: Nmnmnm112211/Wikimedia, CC BY
Parks are not neutral

Public parks can work their magic only if they give what people they need. That differs from population to population.

Scholars, historians, feminists and African-American leaders have observed that people perceive and use green spaces differently depending on their community's historical experience and cultural standards.

Freeway Park, opened in 1974 in Seattle, is a densely wooded urban landscape nestled between two highways. The park is seen by many as intimate and lush. But some women feel unsafe walking alone there because, they say, they can't see who is approaching or coming up behind them.

Meanwhile, African-Americans in the South may feel unwelcome in parks named after Confederate generals and featuring large Confederate statues. Generally speaking, black people are underrepresented as visitors to the U.S. National Park system, a statistic experts attribute to the historic legacy of segregation in public spaces.

Similar segregated use shows up with New York's Highline park. The park, first opened in 2009, runs through the Chelsea neighborhood of Manhattan, which is home to several public housing projects.

Nearly one-third of the area's are people of color. Highline visitors, on the other hand, are overwhelmingly white.

In community forums, locals say they don't perceive the park – a repurposed elevated railway – as having been built for them. If they don't see people who look like them using it, they may stay away.

In other words, the mere existence of a park does not ensure that a community benefits from it.

Designed for easy access

This fact has given rise to new kinds of parks – ones uniquely designed for local communities.

In 1967, the firm of Zion Breen Richardson Associates created the "pocket park" concept with Paley Park in New York City. Small and privately owned but opened to the public during the work day, this park occupies just one-tenth of an acre and is surrounded on three sides by tall buildings.

Washington’s redesigned Wenatchee Park features Mexican-inspired kiosks for music and celebration. Credit: Stephanie Bower, CC BY-SA

Many downtown districts are now speckled with these tiny, often hidden, parks. There's nothing grand about them, but for workers needing a break, they offer much-needed respite.

More recently, when designers began work on San Francisco's shorefront India Basin Park, the on the team realized that access points had to be a design priority. Certain nearby residents – namely, those living in the predominantly black Hunters Point neighborhood – would struggle to use the park, despite its proximity. A shoreline road built decades ago had cut their upland community off from the water's edge.

Rehabilitated walkways from Hunter's Point to the waterfront, then, will inform the design of the park, which will be developed over the next 15 years. The planned paths, stairways and crosswalks should offer their own type of "green" landscape, one that meets the needs of the current residents and is historically appropriate in hilly San Francisco.

Cultural relevance

Latino residents in southside Wenatchee, Washington, have also been teaming with designers to develop a new design that might attract more neighbors to their underused local park, the Kiwanis Methow Park.

Drawing on Mexican influence, the transformed park will feature a "kiosko" pavilion that hosts mariachi music, dances and culturally significant celebrations.

Dozens of "padrinos," or godparents, have signed up to maintain the park, whose new design was spearheaded by the Trust for Public Land and the landscape architecture firm Site Workshop.

Context-specific design crosses international borders in other ways.

In a shantytown outside Lima, Peru, residents teamed up with the University of Washington to build a school garden that is also open to the public.

During school hours, the outdoor classroom teaches local students about local plants, including some that are edible. Other times, it doubles as a quiet place of respite for community members in this sprawling, dense and noisy neighborhood.

Frederick Law Olmsted and W.E.B. Du Bois were right: Cities need parks. But designers have come a long way over the last century in learning that can only help cities when residents embrace them.

Explore further: Improving city parks may be one path to help make residents more active

Related Stories

Using virtual reality to plot urban green spaces

April 13, 2018

City dwellers who are weary of the concrete jungle often seek out a bit of nature. Whether they visit an urban park or find a small green space, residents can gain a host of benefits. Research in environmental psychology ...

New York's Central Park goes officially car-free

June 27, 2018

New York's iconic Central Park officially goes car-free Wednesday after the final vehicle drives through the green oasis and tourist magnet in the heart of America's most populous urban jungle.

Recommended for you

Sculpting stable structures in pure liquids

February 21, 2019

Oscillating flow and light pulses can be used to create reconfigurable architecture in liquid crystals. Materials scientists can carefully engineer concerted microfluidic flows and localized optothermal fields to achieve ...

Researchers make coldest quantum gas of molecules

February 21, 2019

JILA researchers have made a long-lived, record-cold gas of molecules that follow the wave patterns of quantum mechanics instead of the strictly particle nature of ordinary classical physics. The creation of this gas boosts ...

LMC S154 is a symbiotic recurrent nova, study suggests

February 21, 2019

Astronomers have conducted observations of a symbiotic star in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), known as LMC S154, which provide new insights about the nature of this object. Results of these observations, presented in a ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.