Cars bad for children and the planet

November 16, 2018 by Hulya Gilbert, Andrew Allan, Carolyn Whitzman Johannes Pieters, The Conversation
Notice the difference? Drop-off time at an inner-city Copenhagen school. Credit: Hulya Gilbert, Author provided

Children today spend more time in cars than previous generations. They also spend less time playing on the streets and in unstructured and unsupervised activity outdoors. The lack of opportunities for physical activity and the loss of freedom to explore their local neighbourhood is bad news for children's physical, social and mental well-being.

Though equally important, the environmental cost of these trends is not well understood. As rapid urbanisation extends across the globe, continues to be challenging. Transport is one of the biggest sources of greenhouse gas emissions. And 46% of transport-related emissions come from private vehicles.

We know surprisingly little, however, about the detailed reasons for individual private car use. An international study highlights that households with children have higher rates of car ownership and use. In Australia, official statistics on pay a great deal of attention to the "journey to work", but car travel that can be attributed to child-related activities has not been fully explored.

Research on 's travel patterns tends to focus on the "journey to school". While school trips are important, this provides only a narrow image of children's actual travel patterns. They also make many trips to non-school destinations and extracurricular activities such as sport, music and dance classes.

We recently reviewed local government policies related to sustainable mobility and -and-youth-friendly cities. Our review found little consideration of children and young people in transport planning policies across Australia. This is despite the fact that the decline in their walking and cycling rates was widely recognised.

Why are walking and cycling rates decreasing?

Several factors contribute to lower rates of walking and cycling among children and their limited use of public transport. These range from urban form to social and .

Australian suburbs typically have low density and segregated land uses, which privilege the car over other travel modes. This situation is worse in outer suburbs which have limited public transport and poor provision for walking and cycling. These outer suburbs are also more likely to have lower socio-economic status and a larger proportion of families with children.

All together, these suburban conditions add to the social disadvantage resulting from limited access to services and activities that are critical for families with children. This further encourages private car use.

Changing social structures mean families usually are on tight schedules. These changes include increases in employment for women and in the number of both single-parent families and families where both parents are in paid work. Because the car is relatively cheap and easy to use for individual mobility in Australian cities, it is generally the uncontested way to manage these schedules.

In addition, the increased individualisation as a common characteristic of Western societies usually means parents are expected to provide strict supervision of children's movements. In the conditions described above, the most practical way to do this is usually to drive them in a car.

Of course this increases the number of cars on our streets, particularly around schools and other common destinations for children. This then perpetuates parents' concerns about traffic safety, leading in turn to even more private car use.

Child-centred sustainable mobility

What is perhaps most striking about the trend towards chauffeuring children is that these facts are seemingly becoming accepted as unavoidable outcomes of modern society. They are largely ignored in transport planning.

We have argued that children have a in sustainable mobility. Greater attention to the mobility needs of families with children will produce many social and environmental benefits.

The importance of children's role in sustainable mobility can be grouped under two themes.

First, children's needs in today's lifestyles mean they have an active role in contributing to increased private car use. The daily lives of families with children offer a good example of the context in which carbon-intensive travel patterns occur. If their mobility needs can be met more sustainably (even partially) we are likely to achieve significant carbon savings.

Second, and perhaps more importantly, children have a role as catalysts for behavioural change towards sustainable cities. This is because childhood is a key stage for establishing sustainable travel habits as opposed to "trying to modify already ingrained habits later in life".

A better understanding of children's travel patterns would provide a solid foundation for sustainable mobility policies. Planning and transport policies that are responsive to children's specific needs are likely to have more effective and longer-lasting outcomes, with many related benefits for social sustainability and public health.

Explore further: Shedding light on children's physical activity

Related Stories

Indian women confined to the home in cities designed for men

August 30, 2018

The inequality between men and women in India is stark, and nowhere more so than on the streets of its cities, which are undeniably the domain of men. Of course, this is partly because there are fewer women in the population. ...

Recommended for you

Japan to make crater on asteroid to get underground samples

March 18, 2019

Japan's space agency said Monday that its Hayabusa2 spacecraft will follow up last month's touchdown on a distant asteroid with another risky mission—dropping an explosive on the asteroid to make a crater and then collect ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

guptm
not rated yet Nov 17, 2018
Entire North America is car-based and they keep on promoting to use car on individual basis. They plan cities for cars. They discourage walk and public transport. Even kids have their own cars. What a shame on this type of thinking!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.