White mass shooters receive sympathetic media treatment

July 17, 2018 by Jeff Grabmeier, The Ohio State University

White mass shooters receive much more sympathetic treatment in the media than black shooters, according to a new study that analyzed coverage of 219 attacks.

Findings showed that white shooters were 95 percent more likely to be described as "mentally ill" than black shooters.

Even when black shooters were described as mentally ill, the was not as forgiving as it was for whites responsible for similar kinds of attacks, said Scott Duxbury, lead author of the study and a doctoral student in sociology at The Ohio State University.

"There's a big difference in how black and white mass shooters are covered in the ," Duxbury said.

"Much of the media coverage of white shooters framed them as sympathetic characters who were suffering from extreme life circumstances. But black shooters were usually made to seem dangerous and a menace to society."

For example, when shooters were framed in the media as mentally ill, 78 percent of white attackers were described as being victims of society—as being under a lot of stress, for example—versus only 17 percent of black shooters.

Duxbury conducted the research with Laura Frizzell and Sadé Lindsay, also sociology doctoral students at Ohio State. Their study appears online in the Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency.

The researchers defined mass shootings as those in which four or more victims were shot in a single event, not including the perpetrator.

They used two news data sources to collect 433 media articles or transcripts about 219 randomly selected mass shootings in the United States from 2013 through 2015.

The researchers controlled for a variety of factors that could influence coverage, including the number of victims; whether any victims were women, children, family or romantic partners; whether the perpetrator committed suicide; whether the took place in public; and whether the shooting was framed as gang violence.

After taking these factors into account, findings showed that whites were 95 percent more likely than blacks to be described in coverage as mentally ill. Latinos were 92 percent more likely than blacks to be described as mentally ill in media reports.

Shootings that were murder-suicides had significantly higher odds of being attributed to mental illness, as did those that occurred in public places.

But the number of victims, or whether the victims were women or children, were not related to whether the shooter was labeled as mentally ill.

The researchers identified several themes in articles that framed mass shooters as mentally ill. The most common theme—found in about 46 percent of the articles—was that the shooter was a "victim of society." This included articles that said the shooter was "going through a lot," was "stressed out" or "suffered abuse as a child."

About 28 percent of articles that framed shooters as mentally ill offered testimony to the attacker's good character, while another 21 percent said the shooting was unexpected or out of character. Another 14 percent said the shooter came from a good environment.

But these descriptions were almost always about white shooters, Duxbury said.

"Black shooters who were described as mentally ill never receive testament to their good character and the media never describe the shootings as out of character," he said.

"And only white shooters were ever talked about as coming from a good environment."

The researchers contrasted the coverage of two mass shooters—Josh Boren, a white man, and David Ray Conley, a black man.

"The comparison between Conley and Boren is striking. Both shooters were adult men who murdered their families. Both had a history of domestic violence and drug abuse and both had received treatment for mental illness. However, whereas the media described Josh Boren as a quiet, gentle man—a teddy bear—coverage of Conley described him as perpetually violent, controlling and dangerous," the researchers said.

The researchers also analyzed shootings that were described as gang affiliated, because these attacks almost always involved minority shooters. Here the most consistent themes in coverage involved the criminal history of the perpetrators, their status as a public menace and the problems of the community.

These results provide a marked contrast with coverage of other , Duxbury said.

"When the media frame a mass shooting as stemming from , they talk about the perpetrators as being perpetually violent and a menace to society," he said.

"But when a shooting is attributed to , the media treat it as an isolated incident, or the result of the pressures on the perpetrator."

Explore further: Media portrayal of public shooters can perpetuate stereotypes

More information: Scott W. Duxbury et al. Mental Illness, the Media, and the Moral Politics of Mass Violence, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency (2018). DOI: 10.1177/0022427818787225

Related Stories

Media portrayal of public shooters can perpetuate stereotypes

April 26, 2017

As the pervasiveness of media reports on public shootings increase, the way in which media cover these violent stories can have broad social implications, including the creation and perpetuation of racial and mental health ...

Study shows rapid rise in mass school shootings in the US

April 19, 2018

More people have died or been injured in mass school shootings in the US in the past 18 years than in the entire 20th century. In a new study published in Springer's Journal of Child and Family Studies, researchers have reviewed ...

'Media contagion' is factor in mass shootings, study says

August 4, 2016

People who commit mass shootings in America tend to share three traits: rampant depression, social isolation and pathological narcissism, according to a paper presented at the American Psychological Association's annual convention ...

Recommended for you

Understanding urban issues through credit cards

August 20, 2018

Digital traces from credit card and mobile phone usage can be used to map urban lifestyles and understand human mobility, according to a report led by UCL, MIT and UC Berkeley.

5 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

julianpenrod
1.6 / 5 (7) Jul 17, 2018
This article can be called frightening because of the methodology. The "researchers" casualtly and automatically apply the myth that whites and blacks are necessarily alike. Effects from society that whites and blacks feel cannot be said necessarily to be the same. Many if not most whites do feel a responsibility to keeping society running, blacks do blame everything on whites and have a verified history of leaving when responsibilities became too much. It's also a myth that whites and blacks necessarily respond to situations the same way. It may be said that there are more mass murderers among whites, but there are many times as many blacks who have killed at least once. And note the casual insistence that Boren couldn't possible be quiet and gentle and a refusal to accept Conley was violent and controlling!
BendBob
1.8 / 5 (5) Jul 17, 2018
Hopefully, the other races will be greater than 50% of the USA population soon. The changes will take some time and soon whites will be not able to continue with idiot ideas.
Puzzled
1 / 5 (2) Jul 18, 2018
I wish this people publishing sociology or economy articles stayed out of politics, just as they stay out of science.
Puzzled
1 / 5 (3) Jul 18, 2018
Hopefully, the other races will be greater than 50% of the USA population soon. The changes will take some time and soon whites will be not able to continue with idiot ideas.


Who's going to pay your welfare when we are all gone?
Doug_Nightmare
3 / 5 (2) Jul 18, 2018
If elsewhere was so great then why are they all here? America does not belong to all of humankind.

Pray for global winter to restore world cultures to their aboriginal homes.

Imagine Brunhilde telling Olaf to fix the roof and hearing, "Mañana momma!"

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.