Which square is bigger? Honeybees see visual illusions like humans do

November 22, 2017 by Scarlett Howard Adrian Dyer, The Conversation
Flowers may take advantage of visual illusions to attract bees. Credit: www.shutterstock.com

When a human looks at a distant skyscraper, it appears small to the eye. It's a visual illusion, and we use other contextual information to know the building is actually tall.

Our new study shows, for the first time, that honeybees see size-based visual illusions too. Whether a size illusion is seen, or not, depends on how a target object is viewed.

These new results help us understand how evolved in different species over time.

How humans experience illusions

Humans see lots of different illusions such as mirages, illusions of shape, length, size, and even colour (remember that dress?).

Visual illusions are errors in your own perception which can allow you to process the very complex visual information you see more easily.

One of the strongest geometric illusions we humans see is an illusion of size, called the Ebbinghaus Illusion.

Interestingly, species such as bottlenose dolphins, bower birds, domestic chicks, and redtail splitfins see this illusion in the same way as humans. However, animals such pigeons, domestic dogs, and bantams see the opposite illusion to what we see, and baboons do not see an illusion at all.

To understand why different species see size illusions in such different ways, and how an insect with a miniature brain might view a size illusion, we developed an experimental design using honeybees.

The lines or shapes around an object can change the way your brain sees it. Credit: Scarlett Howard
Why do animals perceive illusions differently?

It's intriguing that some species view size illusions the same way as us, and some animals do not. Why is it that a baboon does not see any illusion when looking at the Ebbinghaus Illusion? Why do pigeons and dogs see the opposite illusion to us? Our team decided to look into the methodology of the past studies that had shown these differences.

When baboons, pigeons, dogs, and bantams were tested, they were looking at the illusion from either a set distance or from a forced close-range distance. For example, dogs had to touch the correct option with their noses, and birds had to peck the correct option meaning these species were viewing the illusion at a very close distance. Baboons, on the other hand, were viewing the illusion at a set distance, unable to move closer than a certain distance from a screen that presented the illusionary pictures.

With this knowledge, we decided to test honeybees using two study conditions:

a free-flying set-up where bees could fly at any distance from the size illusion before making decisions, and a constrained viewing set-up where bees could only view and make decisions about the illusion from one set distance.

Ebbinghaus Illusion: The central circles are of identical size, but are perceived as very different by humans because we use context to inform our vision. Credit: Scarlett Howard
How does a bee view size illusions?

To determine if bees could perceive size illusions, we first had to find a way to ask them.

We trained one group of bees to always choose the larger black square on a square white background and another group of bees to always choose the smaller black square on a square white background.

When bees had learnt to either choose larger or smaller sized black square targets, we manipulated the size of the background, thus trying to induce the perception of a visual illusion (similar to the Delboeuf Illusion).

We ran this experiment using our free-flying, unrestricted viewing condition and also using a restricted viewing condition where independent bees were unable to choose their own to make decisions.

Bees can help us design better camera technology.

Eureka! Training conditions explain why different animals see illusions differently. Bees in the unrestricted viewing condition perceived illusions, while bees in the restricted viewing condition did not see size illusions.

Now, we are interested in whether some past study results were due to experimental set-up: maybe more or even all animals could perceive illusions like humans, depending on the context in which they are viewing these illusions.

What does this mean for the evolution of vision?

Visual illusions are useful because they allow us to process complex scenes, with multiple pieces of information, as a whole by using context as a cue. Since different see size illusions, understanding how this works could help us learn more about how vision itself evolved.

One explanation of why such different animal species, from humans to bees, see size illusions is because an ancient ancestor had this ability, and it has been conserved throughout evolution. However, a more likely scenario is that the evolution of visual illusion perception is due to convergent evolution. This occurs when different species evolved the ability to perceive illusions separately.

Stimuli used in experiments. Credit: Scarlett Howard

The ability of bees to perceive a size in a free-flying environment also has implications for flower evolution. Flowers could have evolved to exploit the ability of seeing illusions to make nectar areas look more appealing. One genus of flower, Wurmbea, appears to have illusionary properties such as differently sized flowers with patterns reminiscent of size illusions such as the Ebbinghaus and Delboeuf Illusions.

A very important lesson from this study is that viewing context can make scenes appear very different to reality. This is very important to remember when working on vision in humans or any other animal.

Wurmbea flower as seen through a special camera simulating bee vision. Credit: http://ro.uow.edu.au/asj/vol5/iss1/7

Explore further: Fish can be fooled – just like humans

Related Stories

Optical illusions show vision in a new light

March 11, 2011

Optical illusions have fascinated humans throughout history. Greek builders used an optical illusion to ensure that that their columns appeared straight (they built them with a bulge) and we are all intrigued by the mental ...

Animals could help reveal why humans fall for illusions

March 21, 2014

Visual illusions, such as the rabbit-duck and café wall are fascinating because they remind us of the discrepancy between perception and reality. But our knowledge of such illusions has been largely limited to studying humans.

Recommended for you

Multiple stellar populations detected in the cluster Hodge 6

February 18, 2019

Using ESO's Very Large Telescope (VLT), astronomers have found that the cluster Hodge 6 hosts multiple stellar populations. The detection could provide important hints on the formation and evolution of Hodge 6 and star clusters ...

Predicting sequence from structure

February 18, 2019

One way to probe intricate biological systems is to block their components from interacting and see what happens. This method allows researchers to better understand cellular processes and functions, augmenting everyday laboratory ...

Energetic particles can bombard exoplanets

February 18, 2019

TRAPPIST-1 is a system of seven Earth-sized worlds orbiting an ultra-cool dwarf star about 120 light-years away. The star, and hence its system of planets, is thought to be between five-to-ten billion years old, up to twice ...

Meteorite source in asteroid belt not a single debris field

February 17, 2019

A new study published online in Meteoritics and Planetary Science finds that our most common meteorites, those known as L chondrites, come from at least two different debris fields in the asteroid belt. The belt contains ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.